Combined analysis of all three phases of solar neutrino data from the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory

B. Aharmim, S. N. Ahmed, A. E. Anthony, N. Barros, E. W. Beier, A. Bellerive, B. Beltrán, M. Bergevin, S. D. Biller, K. Boudjemline, M. G. Boulay, B. Cai, Y-d. Chan, D. Chauhan, M. Chen, B. T. Cleveland, G. A. Cox, X. Dai, Huiqiu Deng, J. A. Detwiler, M. DiMarco, P. J. Doe, G. Doucas, P.‐l. Drouin, F. A. Duncan, M. Dunford, E. D. Earle, S. R. Elliott, H. C. Evans, G. T. Ewan, J. Farine, H. Fergani, F. Fleurot, R. Ford, J. A. Formaggio, N. Gagnon, J. Tm. Goon, K. Graham, E. Guillian, S. Habib, R. L. Hahn, A. L. Hallin, E. D. Hallman, P. J. Harvey, R. Hazama, W. J. Heintzelman, J. Heise, R. L. Helmer, A. Hime, C. Howard, M. Huang, P. Jagam, B. Jamieson, N.a. Jelley, M. Jerkins, K. Keeter, J. Klein, L. L. Kormos, M. Kos, C. Kraus, C. B. Krauss, A. Krüger, T. Kutter, Christopher C. M. Kyba, R. Lange, J. Law, I. Lawson, K. T. Lesko, J. R. Leslie, J. C. Loach, R. MacLellan, Steve Majerus, H.‐b. Mak, J. Maneira, R. D. Martin, N. McCauley, A.b. McDonald, S. McGee, M. L. Miller, B. Monreal, J. Monroe, B. G. Nickel, A. J. Noble, H. M. O’Keeffe, N. S. Oblath, R. W. Ollerhead, G. D. Orebi Gann, S. M. Oser, Richard A. Ott, S. J. M. Peeters, A. W. P. Poon, G. Prior, S. D. Reitzner, K. Rielage, B.c. Robertson, R. G. H. Robertson, Yuri Smirnov, M. H. Schwendener, J. A. Secrest, S. R. SeibertPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We report results from a combined analysis of solar neutrino data from all phases of the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO). By exploiting particle identification information obtained from the proportional counters installed during the third phase, this analysis improved background rejection in that phase of the experiment. The combined analysis of the SNO data resulted in a total flux of active neutrino flavors from ${}^{8}\mathrm{B}$ decays in the Sun of $(5.25\pm0.16{(\mathrm{stat}.)}_{-0.13}^{+0.11}(\mathrm{syst}.))\times{10}^{6}\text{ cm}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$, while a two-flavor neutrino oscillation analysis yielded $\Delta{m}_{21}^{2}=(5.6_{-1.4}^{+1.9})\times{10}^{-5}\text{ eV}^{2}$ and $\tan^{2}\theta_{12}=0.427_{-0.029}^{+0.033}$. A three-flavor neutrino oscillation analysis combining the SNO result with results of all other solar neutrino experiments and reactor neutrino experiments yielded $\Delta{m}_{21}^{2}=(7.46_{-0.19}^{+0.20})\times{10}^{-5}\text{ eV}^{2}$, $\tan^{2}\theta_{12}=0.443_{-0.025}^{+0.030}$, and $\sin^{2}\theta_{13}=(2.49_{-0.32}^{+0.20})\times{10}^{-2}$.

Introduction: Solving the Solar Neutrino Problem

For decades, the "Solar Neutrino Problem" stood as one of the most significant challenges in particle physics. Experiments consistently detected far fewer electron neutrinos ($\nu_e$) from the Sun than predicted by standard solar models. The Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO) provided the definitive solution by demonstrating that neutrinos undergo flavor oscillation—changing from electron neutrinos into muon or tau neutrinos during their journey to Earth.

While SNO's previous results were released in distinct phases, this paper presents the "final word" from the collaboration: a unified, combined analysis of all three experimental phases. This approach allows for a more precise determination of the total $^8$B solar neutrino flux and significantly tighter constraints on neutrino mixing parameters.

The SNO Experiment and its Phases

The SNO detector was a unique facility located 2 km underground in a nickel mine near Sudbury, Ontario. At its core was a 12-meter diameter acrylic vessel containing 1,000 tonnes of heavy water ($D_2O$), surrounded by ultra-pure light water ($H_2O$) for shielding.

Schematic of the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory detector, illustrating the nested vessel structure and shielding.

The experiment was conducted in three distinct phases, each utilizing a different method for detecting neutrons produced by neutral-current (NC) interactions:

  • Phase I (D$_2$O): Neutrons were captured by the deuterium in the heavy water.
  • Phase II (Salt): Two tonnes of NaCl were added to enhance neutron capture efficiency and provide a distinct signal.
  • Phase III (NCD): An array of $^3$He-filled proportional counters (Neutral Current Detectors) was installed to provide an independent measurement of the neutron flux.

Methodology: A Unified Approach

The primary challenge of this work was performing a Combined Maximum Likelihood Fit across all three phases. By fitting all data simultaneously, the collaboration could rigorously account for correlated systematic uncertainties arising from different detector configurations.

A major technical highlight of this analysis is the improved Particle Identification (PID) for Phase III. The researchers developed a sophisticated algorithm based on waveform analysis of the NCD pulses. By examining features like kurtosis and skewness, they were able to separate neutron signals from alpha-particle backgrounds originating from trace radioactivity. This technique maintained approximately 75% of the neutron signal while rejecting over 98% of the background, drastically reducing errors for the final phase.

Furthermore, the team used a model-independent parameterization of the $\nu_e$ survival probability ($P_{ee}$) as a function of energy. This allowed them to extract the underlying physics before comparing the results to specific oscillation models.

Key Results and Oscillation Parameters

The combined analysis confirms the consistency of the $^8$B flux across all detector eras. The total flux of active neutrino flavors was measured at $(5.25 \pm 0.16 \text{ (stat.)} ^{+0.11}_{-0.13} \text{ (syst.)}) \times 10^6 \text{ cm}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$, showing excellent agreement with standard solar models.

One of the critical tests for neutrino oscillation models is the search for "Earth matter effects," where the neutrino survival probability changes as they pass through the Earth at night.

Day and night energy spectra of neutrino events. The lack of significant asymmetry helps constrain the Large Mixing Angle (LMA) region of oscillation parameters.

As shown in the figure above, the day and night spectra are highly consistent. The absence of a significant day/night asymmetry further narrows the allowed "Large Mixing Angle" (LMA) region of the oscillation parameter space.

The final global three-flavor analysis, which combines SNO data with other solar experiments and reactor data from KamLAND, yielded the following high-precision parameters:

  • Mass Difference: $\Delta m^2_{21} = (7.46^{+0.20}_{-0.19}) \times 10^{-5} \text{ eV}^2$
  • Mixing Angle: $\tan^2 \theta_{12} = 0.443^{+0.030}_{-0.025}$
  • Third Mixing Angle: $\sin^2 \theta_{13} = (2.49^{+0.20}_{-0.32}) \times 10^{-2}$

This analysis also established a robust upper bound of $\sin^2 \theta_{13} < 0.053$ at the 95% confidence level.

Conclusion and Legacy

This combined analysis represents the culmination of the SNO project. By integrating data from all phases and applying advanced background rejection, the collaboration has provided the most definitive measurement of solar neutrino oscillations to date. While the SNO detector has been decommissioned, its legacy continues through the SNO+ experiment and next-generation projects like JUNO, which aim to explore the neutrino mass hierarchy and lower-energy solar neutrinos with even greater precision.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report results from a combined analysis of solar neutrino data from all phases of the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO). By exploiting particle identification information obtained from the proportional counters installed during the third phase, this analysis improved background rejection in that phase of the experiment. The combined analysis of the SNO data resulted in a total flux of active neutrino flavors from ${}^{8}\mathrm{B}$ decays in the Sun of $(5.25\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.16{(\mathrm{stat}.)}_{\ensuremath{-}0.13}^{+0.11}(\mathrm{syst}.))\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\mathrm{cm}}^{\ensuremath{-}2}{\mathrm{s}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$, while a two-flavor neutrino oscillation analysis yielded $\ensuremath{\Delta}{m}_{21}^{2}=(5.{6}_{\ensuremath{-}1.4}^{+1.9})\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}5}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\mathrm{eV}}^{2}$ and ${\mathrm{tan}}^{2}{\ensuremath{\theta}}_{12}=0.{427}_{\ensuremath{-}0.029}^{+0.033}$. A three-flavor neutrino oscillation analysis combining the SNO result with results of all other solar neutrino experiments and reactor neutrino experiments yielded $\ensuremath{\Delta}{m}_{21}^{2}=(7.{46}_{\ensuremath{-}0.19}^{+0.20})\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}5}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\mathrm{eV}}^{2}$, ${\mathrm{tan}}^{2}{\ensuremath{\theta}}_{12}=0.{443}_{\ensuremath{-}0.025}^{+0.030}$, and ${\mathrm{sin}}^{2}{\ensuremath{\theta}}_{13}=(2.{49}_{\ensuremath{-}0.32}^{+0.20})\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}2}$.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aharmim2013combined,
  author = {B. Aharmim and S. N. Ahmed and A. E. Anthony and N. Barros and E. W. Beier and A. Bellerive and B. Beltrán and M. Bergevin and S. D. Biller and K. Boudjemline and M. G. Boulay and B. Cai and Y-D. Chan and D. Chauhan and M. Chen and B. T. Cleveland and G. A. Cox and X. Dai and Huiqiu Deng and J. A. Detwiler and M. DiMarco and P. J. Doe and G. Doucas and P.‐L. Drouin and F. A. Duncan and M. Dunford and E. D. Earle and S. R. Elliott and H. C. Evans and G. T. Ewan and J. Farine and H. Fergani and F. Fleurot and R. Ford and J. A. Formaggio and N. Gagnon and J. TM. Goon and K. Graham and E. Guillian and S. Habib and R. L. Hahn and A. L. Hallin and E. D. Hallman and P. J. Harvey and R. Hazama and W. J. Heintzelman and J. Heise and R. L. Helmer and A. Hime and C. Howard and M. Huang and P. Jagam and B. Jamieson and N.A. Jelley and M. Jerkins and K. Keeter and J. Klein and L. L. Kormos and M. Kos and C. Kraus and C. B. Krauss and A. Krüger and T. Kutter and Christopher C. M. Kyba and R. Lange and J. Law and I. Lawson and K. T. Lesko and J. R. Leslie and J. C. Loach and R. MacLellan and Steve Majerus and H.‐B. Mak and J. Maneira and R. D. Martin and N. McCauley and A.B. McDonald and S. McGee and M. L. Miller and B. Monreal and J. Monroe and B. G. Nickel and A. J. Noble and H. M. O’Keeffe and N. S. Oblath and R. W. Ollerhead and G. D. Orebi Gann and S. M. Oser and Richard A. Ott and S. J. M. Peeters and A. W. P. Poon and G. Prior and S. D. Reitzner and K. Rielage and B.C. Robertson and R. G. H. Robertson and Yuri Smirnov and M. H. Schwendener and J. A. Secrest and S. R. Seibert},
  title = {{Combined analysis of all three phases of solar neutrino data from the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevc.88.025501},
}
Figure