Combination of ultrasonic elastography and Ki-67 index as a novel predictive modality for the prognosis in clinic stage III breast cancer

Rui Du, Weiwei Shu, Baoding Chen, Xin Zhang, Xincai Wu, Mengyuan Shang, Zheng Zhang, Zhongqun Wang, Hao Zhang, Yuefeng LiResearch 2019 · DOI

Predicting the prognosis of patients with advanced (Stage III) breast cancer remains a significant clinical challenge. While traditional imaging focuses on tumor morphology, a new study published in Research Square proposes a multi-modal approach that combines biological markers with biomechanical tissue properties to improve survival estimates.

The Challenge of Stage III Prognosis

Clinic stage III breast cancer represents an advanced disease state where 5-year survival rates typically hover between 30% and 40%. Current treatment protocols involve aggressive combinations of chemotherapy, radiotherapy, and surgery. However, the heterogeneous nature of these tumors means that patients with similar-looking tumors can have vastly different outcomes.

Standard diagnostic tools like mammography and conventional ultrasound primarily assess the "morphology"—the size, shape, and echo patterns—of a tumor. These features often fail to capture the underlying biological activity or physical changes in the tumor microenvironment that signal progression or response to therapy.

Methodology: The "Seed and Soil" Approach

To address this gap, researchers developed a predictive model based on the "seed and soil" hypothesis, looking at both the cancer cell's proliferative drive and the physical environment it inhabits.

The study analyzed data from 112 patients with stage III breast cancer, focusing on two key data types:

  1. Biological Marker (Ki-67 Index): A protein marker for cell proliferation. A high Ki-67 index indicates a more aggressive, rapidly dividing tumor (the "seed").
  2. Biomechanical Imaging (Ultrasonic Elastography - UE): This technique measures tissue stiffness. The researchers utilized both Compression Elastography (CE) and Shear Wave Elastography (SWE) to derive quantitative parameters, specifically the Strain Ratio and Young’s Modulus (the "soil").

By tracking these patients over a median of 61 months, the team used a multivariate Cox regression model to identify which variables independently predicted survival.

Key Findings and the Predictive Nomogram

The research identified three critical variables that, when combined, provided a robust prediction of patient outcomes: Ki-67 classification, Strain Ratio, and Young’s Modulus.

The Predictive Model

The final mathematical model was established as: $$RR(t) = \exp(1.104 \cdot X1 + 0.901 \cdot X4 + 0.972 \cdot X5)$$ Where X1 represents Ki-67 classification, X4 represents Strain Ratio, and X5 represents Young's Modulus.

Among these, the Ki-67 index was found to have the most significant influence on survival prediction, followed by Young’s modulus and the strain ratio. This confirms that while cellular proliferation is the primary driver of malignancy, the stiffness of the surrounding tissue provides essential prognostic context.

Accuracy and Clinical Utility

The model's performance was evaluated using the concordance index (C-index), achieving a score of 0.762. This indicates a high level of predictive accuracy, significantly better than traditional morphological assessment alone.

To make these findings accessible to clinicians, the researchers translated the model into a nomogram. This graphical tool allows doctors to input a patient's specific biological and biomechanical data to estimate their 5-year survival probability. For instance, a patient with high stiffness (Young’s modulus of 100kPa) and a high Ki-67 index (68%) might show a 5-year survival probability of only 15%, prompting clinicians to consider more intensive or alternative therapeutic strategies.

Limitations and Future Directions

While promising, the authors note that this model requires further refinement. The study was retrospective and conducted on a relatively small cohort of 112 patients at a single institution. Future work will focus on:

  • External Validation: Testing the model against diverse patient populations from other hospitals.
  • Prospective Trials: Validating the model's utility in real-time clinical decision-making.
  • Reducing Operator Bias: While quantitative measures like Young's modulus are more objective, the consistency of elastography imaging can still be influenced by technician skill.

Conclusion

By integrating the biological "seed" and the biomechanical "soil," this novel modality offers a more comprehensive view of breast cancer progression. The combination of UE and Ki-67 provides a non-invasive, highly accurate tool that could eventually help personalize treatment plans for patients facing advanced breast cancer.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background To investigate the feasibility of combination of ultrasonic elastography (UE) and Ki-67 index as a novel predictive modality for the prognosis of clinic stage Ⅲ breast cancer. Methods Of 112 patients, Multi-parameter of UE were obtained after analyzing elastograms of 112 lesions which were recorded classification of Ki-67 by histopathologic diagnosis. Multivariate Survival analysis was performed by using multivariate Cox model. The nomograms was established to predict the probability of clinic stage Ⅲ breast cancer according to the selected independently significant variables in the multivariate Cox model. The model was internally validated using Harrell’s concordance index. Results ⅢC had significant difference in all ultrasonic elastography (UE) parameters (P < 0.05) and were statistically different from ⅢA and ⅢB (P < 0.01). The Cox model was RR (t)= Exp(1.104* X1+0.901*X4+0.972*X5) (X1: classification of Ki-67, X4: classification of strain ratio, X5: classification of Young's modulus). The nomogram showed that Ki-67 had the greatest influence on survival prediction, followed by Young's modulus and strain ratio. Internal validation revealed a concordance index of 0.76. Conclusions Our study explored a novel modality in predicting the prognosis of clinic stage Ⅲ breast cancer combining a tumor marker with breast UE imaging. A nomogram was developed to prove that the model was helpful to estimate the 5-year survival of the patients.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{du2019combination,
  author = {Rui Du and Weiwei Shu and Baoding Chen and Xin Zhang and Xincai Wu and Mengyuan Shang and Zheng Zhang and Zhongqun Wang and Hao Zhang and Yuefeng Li},
  title = {{Combination of ultrasonic elastography and Ki-67 index as a novel predictive modality for the prognosis in clinic stage III breast cancer}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.2.13995/v1},
}
Figure