Columnar localization and laminar origin of cortical surface electrical potentials

Vyassa L. Baratham, Maximilian E. Dougherty, Peter Ledochowitsch, Michel M. Maharbiz, Kristofer E. BouchardbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a combination of high-resolution electrocorticography (µECoG) in rats and a detailed biophysical simulation of a cortical column to pinpoint the origin of surface electrical signals. They found that these signals are tightly localized to individual cortical columns and primarily generated by neurons in the deeper, infragranular layers (V and VI), challenging previous assumptions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Electrocorticography (ECoG) is a powerful tool for understanding brain activity, bridging basic neuroscience and clinical applications. However, a significant challenge has been precisely localizing the sources of ECoG signals on the brain's surface and understanding which neuronal populations generate them. This lack of understanding limits our ability to interpret ECoG data and design better brain-computer interfaces. The authors aim to resolve this by investigating the spatial localization and laminar origin of evoked ECoG responses.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Experimental Recordings: They used custom-designed, high-density micro-ECoG (µECoG) arrays with small electrodes (40 µm diameter) to record electrical activity from the auditory cortex of anesthetized rats. These recordings captured a wide frequency range (2-12,000 Hz) to analyze various neurobiological signals.
  2. Biophysical Simulation: They built a full-scale, biophysically detailed model of a cortical column using the NEURON simulation environment. This model incorporated detailed neuronal morphologies, ion channel dynamics, and synaptic connections, allowing them to simulate the generation of cortical surface electrical potentials (CSEPs) from individual neuronal segments.

By combining these methods, they could experimentally validate findings from their simulations and use the model to explore aspects not easily accessible experimentally, such as isolating the contributions of specific neuronal layers.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data from their own experiments and a publicly available dataset for the biophysical model construction.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cortical Columnar Localization: Evoked µECoG signals are not diffuse but are tightly localized to a single cortical column (approximately 200-500 µm in diameter). This localization is anisotropic, meaning it's stronger in certain directions (dorsal-ventral) than others (anterior-posterior), aligning with the functional organization of the cortex.
  • Infragranular Dominance: Contrary to common intuition that superficial layers would be the primary source, the study reveals that neurons in the deeper, infragranular layers (V and VI) contribute the vast majority (~85%) of the high-gamma signal recorded at the cortical surface.
  • Cell Density and Synchronicity are Key: The contribution of a neuronal layer to the surface signal is primarily determined by the number of neurons (density) and their synchronized activity, rather than just their distance from the electrode. Deeper layers have more neurons and higher synchrony, outweighing their greater distance.
  • High-Gamma as a Biomarker: The high-gamma frequency band (65-170 Hz) of ECoG signals appears to be a reliable biomarker for the firing rates of pyramidal neurons in layers V and VI.

Key Results

  • Spatial Localization: µECoG signals were found to be anisotropically localized to ≤±200 µm on the cortical surface, consistent with the size of a cortical column.
  • Laminar Contribution: Biophysical simulations showed that layers V and VI contributed approximately 85% of the evoked high-gamma signal.
  • Model Validation: The biophysical model successfully reproduced the experimentally observed evoked spectrum, including a peak frequency around 100 Hz, and predicted relationships between input amplitude, response magnitude, and frequency content that were confirmed experimentally.
  • Anisotropy: Spatial spread of correlations showed greater values in the dorsal-ventral direction compared to the anterior-posterior direction, reflecting the functional organization (tonotopy) of the auditory cortex.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: While the biophysical model is highly detailed, it still represents a simplification of the complex brain. For instance, the simulation of the secondary peak at ~375 Hz in experimental data was not reproduced, suggesting potential contributions from neurons in other layers (II/III) or interactions with adjacent cortical columns not fully captured by the single-column model.
  • Extrapolation to Humans: The study was conducted in rats. While the authors suggest the findings may extrapolate to humans due to the conserved columnar organization of the cortex, further validation in human studies would be beneficial.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose that different frequency components of ECoG signals might reflect activity from different cortical layers, suggesting these could serve as biomarkers for distinct computations. They also suggest experimental approaches using laminar probes and optogenetics to further investigate these layer-specific contributions. The biophysical simulation approach is highlighted as a critical tool for future research into ECoG signal origins.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Electrocorticography (ECoG) methodologically bridges basic neuroscience and understanding of human brains in health and disease. However, the localization of ECoG signals across the surface of the brain and the spatial distribution of their generating neuronal sources are poorly understood. To address this gap, we recorded from rat auditory cortex using customized μECoG, and simulated cortical surface electrical potentials with a full-scale, biophysically detailed cortical column model. Experimentally, μECoG-derived auditory representations were tonotopically organized and signals were anisotropically localized to ≤±200 μm, i.e., a single cortical column. Biophysical simulations reproduce experimental findings, and indicate that neurons in cortical layers V and VI contribute ∼85% of evoked high-gamma signal recorded at the surface. Cell number and synchronicity were the primary biophysical properties determining laminar contributions to evoked μECoG signals, while distance was only a minimal factor. Thus, evoked μECoG signals primarily originate from neurons in the infragranular layers of a single cortical column. In Brief Baratham et al., investigated the localization and origins of sensory evoked ECoG responses. They experimentally found that ECoG responses were anisotropically localized ≤±200 μm, i.e., a single cortical column. Biophysically detailed simulations revealed that neurons in layers V &VI were the primary sources of evoked ECoG responses, in contrast to common thinking. Highlights Evoked μECoG signals are localized on the surface to a cortical column. Neurons in cortical layers V and VI constitute the vast majority of the signal recorded at the surface. Different laminar contributions to ECoG signal are driven by cell density and synchronicity.
BibTeX
@misc{baratham2021columnar,
  author = {Vyassa L. Baratham and Maximilian E. Dougherty and Peter Ledochowitsch and Michel M. Maharbiz and Kristofer E. Bouchard},
  title = {{Columnar localization and laminar origin of cortical surface electrical potentials}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.08.16.456540},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure