Abstract
We have calculated the leading color-octet contributions to the production of $J/\psi$ particles in photon-proton collisions. Using the values for the color-octet matrix elements extracted from fits to prompt $J/\psi$ data at the Fermilab Tevatron, we demonstrate that distinctive color-octet signatures should be visible in $J/\psi$ photoproduction. However, these predictions appear at variance with recent experimental data obtained at HERA, indicating that the phenomenological importance of the color-octet contributions is smaller than expected from theoretical considerations and suggested by the Fermilab Tevatron fits.
Introduction: The Heavy Quarkonium Puzzle
In the mid-1990s, the production of heavy quarkonium—specifically the $J/\psi$ meson—presented a significant challenge to the Standard Model's perturbative QCD framework. The established "Color-Singlet Model" (CSM) assumed that a charm-anticharm ($c\bar{c}$) pair must be created in a color-neutral state to form a $J/\psi$. However, data from the Fermilab Tevatron showed $J/\psi$ production rates more than an order of magnitude higher than CSM predictions.
To resolve this discrepancy, physicists turned to Non-Relativistic QCD (NRQCD), which introduced the "color-octet" mechanism. This theory posits that $c\bar{c}$ pairs can be produced in color-charged (octet) states and subsequently evolve into color-neutral mesons by emitting soft gluons. While this model successfully described Tevatron data, its universality remained unproven. This paper investigates whether the same color-octet parameters can explain $J/\psi$ photoproduction at the HERA collider.
Theoretical Framework and Methodology
The authors employed NRQCD factorization to separate the calculation into two distinct regimes:
- Short-Distance Cross-Sections: Calculable using perturbative QCD, representing the initial creation of the $c\bar{c}$ pair.
- Long-Distance Matrix Elements (LDMEs): Non-perturbative constants representing the probability of the $c\bar{c}$ pair transitioning into a physical $J/\psi$.
The study focused on the energy distribution of the $J/\psi$ (the inelasticity variable $z$) and its transverse momentum ($p_\perp$). By sourcing LDME values from successful fits to CDF data at the Tevatron, the authors generated predictions for the H1 experiment at HERA.
Conflict with Experimental Data
The results revealed a stark contrast between theory and observation. The "smoking gun" for color-octet contributions in photoproduction was predicted to be a sharp rise in the energy spectrum as $z$ approaches 1.
Key findings include:
- Total Cross-Section Overprediction: Using Tevatron-derived parameters, the model significantly overpredicted the total $J/\psi$ photoproduction rate observed at HERA (as noted in Figure 2 of the original paper).
- Shape Discrepancy: While the color-octet model predicted a massive spike at high $z$, the HERA data remained relatively flat, aligning much more closely with the shape of the traditional Color-Singlet Model.
- Magnitude of Error: The discrepancy suggests that the color-octet matrix elements are at least an order of magnitude smaller than previously estimated from Tevatron fits.
Conclusion and Implications
The failure of the color-octet model to accurately predict HERA data indicates that the mechanism's phenomenological importance may have been overstated. While the color-octet terms are theoretically suppressed by the heavy quark velocity ($v$), dynamical factors can enhance them in specific kinematic regions. The mismatch at HERA suggests that the parameters used to explain Tevatron data may not be universal constants of nature.
Future work involving next-to-leading order (NLO) corrections and higher-statistics data from HERA will be essential to refine these matrix elements and determine if NRQCD can be reconciled with the full breadth of experimental results.
Summary updated