TL;DR
This paper introduces "Collaborative Multi-Expert-Systems" (CoMES), a novel approach to building knowledge-intensive systems by combining software engineering principles (product-lines, experience factory) with AI techniques (case-based reasoning, multi-agent systems). CoMES aims to create intelligent systems that learn and evolve by leveraging distributed knowledge from various sources, including human experts and software agents, to tackle complex knowledge work.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper addresses the growing challenge of developing and maintaining intelligent information systems that support "knowledge work" and "knowledge-intensive services." These services, prevalent in sectors like consulting, research, and specialized IT, rely heavily on accumulated expertise. Traditional approaches often struggle with the dynamic nature of knowledge, requiring constant updates and improvements. Furthermore, building these systems is expensive and time-consuming, often leading to the development of many specialized systems. The authors propose CoMES as a way to organize and manage this complex knowledge more effectively, making it more accessible and adaptable by treating knowledge as a product-line and fostering collaborative learning among diverse "experts" (both human and software agents).
Methods
The core of the CoMES approach lies in its hybrid methodology, integrating several key concepts:
- Knowledge-Lines: This extends the software product-line approach to the domain of knowledge-based systems. It emphasizes modularization and the creation of variants, allowing for systematic development and management of knowledge assets.
- Experience Factory: Borrowed from software engineering, this concept is adapted to create an "organizational unit" where software agents emulate human roles. The goal is to automate knowledge processes and facilitate continuous learning from experience.
- Case-Based Reasoning (CBR): Each software agent is envisioned as a CBR system. CBR systems solve new problems by retrieving and adapting solutions from past similar problems (cases). This allows agents to learn from specific experiences.
- Multi-Agent Systems (MAS): CoMES utilizes a multi-agent architecture where individual agents (often CBR-based) collaborate to achieve a common goal. This distributed approach allows for flexibility and scalability.
- Semantic Web Technologies: The authors mention integrating intelligent services within the Semantic Web, suggesting the use of ontologies and linked data for knowledge representation and interoperability.
- Empolis Information Access Suite (e:IAS): The technical implementation leverages this commercial suite, which provides components for CBR, text mining, rule engines, and knowledge management, enabling the creation of these intelligent agents and their integration.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the methodology and architecture, outlining application scenarios rather than presenting empirical results from specific datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- "Knowledge where it is produced": A central idea is to embed knowledge acquisition and learning directly into existing knowledge communities and workflows, rather than trying to extract and centralize knowledge artificially.
- Treating experts as agents: Both human and software entities are viewed as potential "experts" or agents within the system, fostering a collaborative learning environment.
- Modular and adaptable systems: The knowledge-line approach allows for the creation of flexible systems with reusable knowledge modules (agents), making them adaptable to evolving requirements.
- Learning from experience is critical: The emphasis on the "experience factory" and CBR highlights the importance of continuous learning and adaptation for knowledge-intensive services.
- Combining SE and AI: The paper demonstrates a powerful synergy between established software engineering practices and artificial intelligence techniques for building more robust and intelligent systems.
Key Results
Not discussed in the paper. The paper presents a research effort and a proposed methodology, along with application scenarios, rather than reporting on completed experiments or quantitative results.
Limitations and Future Work
- CoMES as a vision: The authors acknowledge that CoMES is currently more of a vision and a set of ideas, with only initial project activities underway.
- Integration challenges: Integrating diverse knowledge sources and agents, especially from different domains, remains a significant challenge.
- Future work: The authors plan to focus on developing a kernel architecture and implementation for CoMES, integrating requirements from various application scenarios, and further exploring the integration of intelligent services within the Semantic Web. They also aim to refine the understanding of different types of experience and how they can be effectively managed and utilized.
Summary updated