Collaborative capacity planning method of wind-photovoltaic-storage equipment in microgrids considering different energy selling incomes

Lingyu Liang, Xiangyu Zhao, Wenqi Huang, Liming Sun, Ziyao Wang, Fengsheng ChenFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

Abstract

A microgrid is a promising small-scale power generation and distribution system. The selling prices of wind turbine equipment (WT), photovoltaic generation equipment (PV), and battery energy storage equipment (BES) have a significant impact on microgrid profits, which, in turn, affects the planning capacity of renewable energy. However, existing research has not yet conducted in-depth modeling and analysis for different kinds of energy generation electricity prices. This paper proposes an optimal capacity planning method for wind-photovoltaic-storage equipment, considering different energy selling incomes in microgrids. Stochastic characteristics of renewable energy (WT and PV), selling prices of different types of energy, and timing coupling characteristic are considered in the proposed model. In addition, the configuration capacities of WT, PV, and BES are modeled as discrete decision variables, according to the type of specific equipment. The comprehensive life cycle cost (LCC) is considered an objective function. It can be found that the proposed collaborative capacity planning model is a mathematical programming problem with complex nonlinear constraints and integer variables. To solve this problem, a cultural gray wolf optimization algorithm (CGWO) is applied in this paper. The proposed method’s efficiency, convergence, superiority, and effectiveness are verified through a case study. Moreover, the impact of different new energy sales prices on capacity planning results is also revealed in the article.

Introduction: The Microgrid Planning Challenge

As the global energy landscape shifts toward carbon neutrality, microgrids—small-scale power systems that integrate renewable generation and storage—have emerged as a critical solution. However, determining the optimal capacity for wind turbines (WT), photovoltaic (PV) arrays, and battery energy storage (BES) remains a complex engineering challenge.

Framework of collaborative capacity planning in a microgrid.

Most existing planning models assume a flat rate for selling excess energy back to the main grid. In reality, market incentives and subsidies often vary depending on the energy source or the timing of discharge. Furthermore, these problems are non-linear and involve discrete variables—engineers cannot install fractions of a turbine—while also needing to account for the stochastic nature of weather and load demand.

Methodology

Life Cycle Cost (LCC) Modeling

The researchers developed a comprehensive Life Cycle Cost (LCC) objective function to minimize total expenses over the system's lifespan. This model factors in:

  • Annualized Investment & Maintenance: Capital expenditures and operational costs.
  • Outage Compensation: Penalties incurred when the microgrid fails to meet local demand.
  • Grid Interactions: The cost of purchasing power during shortages and the revenue generated from selling surpluses.
  • Scrapping Profit: The residual value of equipment at the end of its service life.

The Cultural Gray Wolf Optimization (CGWO) Algorithm

To navigate the complex search space of this non-linear problem, the study introduces the Cultural Gray Wolf Optimization (CGWO) algorithm. Standard GWO mimics the social hierarchy and hunting behavior of gray wolves (Alpha, Beta, and Delta) to find optimal solutions.

Schematic of the Gray Wolf Optimization (GWO) search mechanism.

The "Cultural" enhancement improves upon the standard GWO in three ways:

  1. Genetic Algorithm (GA) Initialization: Uses "cultural genes" to create a high-quality initial population.
  2. Exponential Convergence: Replaces linear search decay with an exponential law to avoid local optima.
  3. Adaptive Search Strategy: Employs a weighted approach to explore the search space more effectively than simple averaging.

Key Insights and Results

Economic Dynamics and the "Squeeze-Out" Effect

The study reveals a competitive relationship between wind and solar assets. Sensitivity analysis shows that as the selling price for wind energy increases, the model doesn't just add wind capacity; it actively "squeezes out" solar capacity to maximize net profit. Conversely, high selling prices for battery storage (BES) were found to incentivize PV growth, as storage allows the system to capture cheap solar energy and sell it during peak price periods.

Performance Benchmarking

The CGWO algorithm demonstrated superior performance compared to traditional methods like Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) and Genetic Algorithms (GA).

  • Convergence: CGWO reached an optimal value representing a net life-cycle profit of -1.1908 × 10⁶ yuan.
  • Stability: Convergence tests showed that CGWO consistently finds the global optimum regardless of starting conditions, outperforming peers in both speed and solution quality.
  • Efficiency: Despite the complexity of an 8,760-hour annual simulation, the algorithm completed the task in under 15 seconds.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the proposed model provides a robust framework for microgrid planning, the authors identify several areas for future research. Current models use static price coefficients, which may not capture the volatility of modern electricity markets. Future iterations could incorporate Distributionally Robust Optimization (DRO) to manage price uncertainty. Additionally, integrating dynamic demand response—where the load adjusts based on real-time availability—could further optimize the collaborative capacity of these renewable systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

A microgrid is a promising small-scale power generation and distribution system. The selling prices of wind turbine equipment (WT), photovoltaic generation equipment (PV), and battery energy storage equipment (BES) have a significant impact on microgrid profits, which, in turn, affects the planning capacity of renewable energy. However, existing research has not yet conducted in-depth modeling and analysis for different kinds of energy generation electricity prices. This paper proposes an optimal capacity planning method for wind-photovoltaic-storage equipment, considering different energy selling incomes in microgrids. Stochastic characteristics of renewable energy (WT and PV), selling prices of different types of energy, and timing coupling characteristic are considered in the proposed model. In addition, the configuration capacities of WT, PV, and BES are modeled as discrete decision variables, according to the type of specific equipment. The comprehensive life cycle cost (LCC) is considered an objective function. It can be found that the proposed collaborative capacity planning model is a mathematical programming problem with complex nonlinear constraints and integer variables. To solve this problem, a cultural gray wolf optimization algorithm (CGWO) is applied in this paper. The proposed method’s efficiency, convergence, superiority, and effectiveness are verified through a case study. Moreover, the impact of different new energy sales prices on capacity planning results is also revealed in the article.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liang2023collaborative,
  author = {Lingyu Liang and Xiangyu Zhao and Wenqi Huang and Liming Sun and Ziyao Wang and Fengsheng Chen},
  title = {{Collaborative capacity planning method of wind-photovoltaic-storage equipment in microgrids considering different energy selling incomes}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2023.1264986},
}
Figure