Cold plate performance enhancement based on parametric modeling of multiple structures

Kai Zhao, Xiaoxia Sun, Yuanqing Xia, Qiangqiang Li, Lili Shen, Min LinFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how to optimize liquid-cooled "cold plates" for high-power electronics by comparing different internal geometries. By using parametric modeling and CFD simulations, the researchers demonstrate that integrated fin structures provide superior temperature uniformity and lower flow resistance compared to traditional cylindrical rod structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As power electronics (like those in electric vehicles or aerospace systems) become smaller and more integrated, they face a massive thermal challenge: high heat flow density. It isn't just about the total heat; it’s about uniformity.

When a cold plate cools a chip unevenly, the resulting temperature fluctuations create thermal stress. Over time, this stress leads to fatigue failure in packaging materials, reducing the reliability and lifespan of the entire module. Traditional "plain" liquid-cooled channels often struggle to maintain a consistent temperature across the heating surface. The authors sought to design a "homogeneous" cold plate that balances effective heat dissipation with the energy cost of pumping fluid through the system (flow resistance).

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of theoretical derivation and numerical simulation:

  • Parametric Modeling: They created three distinct internal architectures for the cooling channels: a "Normal" structure (plain channel), a structure with "Sticks" (cylindrical rods), and a structure with "Fins" (rectangular plate-like inserts).
  • Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): Using ANSYS Fluent, they simulated steady-state, laminar, and incompressible flow. They focused on a heating surface of 1,200 mm² with a heat flow of 100,000 W/m².
  • Field Synergy Principle: This is a key theoretical framework used to analyze the results. It suggests that convective heat transfer is most efficient when the velocity vector of the fluid and the temperature gradient vector are well-aligned (i.e., a smaller intersection angle).
  • Sensitivity Analysis: They used the Pearson correlation coefficient to determine which design variables (like inlet velocity or hydraulic radius) had the most significant impact on cooling performance.

Datasets

As a simulation-based study, the paper does not use external experimental datasets. Instead, it generates its own data through:

  • Parametric Sweeps: Testing various hydraulic radii and inlet velocities.
  • Grid Independence Study: The authors verified their results by testing six different mesh densities (from 150,000 to 590,000 cells) to ensure the simulation accuracy wasn't tied to the resolution of the digital model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Sticks" Penalty: While adding cylindrical rods (sticks) increases the surface area for heat transfer and effectively lowers the maximum temperature ($T_{max}$), it comes at a high cost. The rods create significant flow resistance, requiring much more pumping power.
  • The Fin Advantage: The fin structures were the "Goldilocks" solution. They provided excellent heat dissipation and the best temperature uniformity. Crucially, they achieved this with significantly lower flow resistance than the rod structures.
  • Flow Guidance vs. Obstruction: The fins act to separate and guide the flow. By preventing the fluid from "remixing" too early and maintaining higher velocities along the channel walls, they optimize the heat transfer coefficient without the massive pressure drop seen in the "stick" design.
  • Synergy is Key: The study confirmed that the fin structure maintains a better "field synergy angle" (closer to 90° in the central zone) compared to the plain channel, explaining why it outperforms the other designs theoretically.

Key Results

  • Temperature Uniformity: The fin structure showed the highest level of temperature homogeneity across the heating surface.
  • Pressure Drop: The structure with sticks resulted in a pressure drop approximately 300 Pa higher than the normal cold plate. In contrast, the fin structure offered a much more efficient trade-off between cooling and resistance.
  • Sensitivity: The internal structure type and the hydraulic radius of the inlet were found to be the most influential factors on the outlet temperature. Increasing the hydraulic radius was shown to directly improve cooling by increasing the mass flow rate of the coolant.
  • Material Performance: Using copper as the base material, the researchers determined that the integrated fin column heat sink is significantly better than the cylindrical version when thermal resistance is held constant.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for further exploration:

  • Laminar Focus: The study focused on laminar flow (Reynolds numbers between 200 and 700). Future research could investigate how these structures behave under turbulent flow conditions.
  • Geometry Optimization: While they compared rods and fins, they suggest that future work should look at more complex configurations, such as triangular structures or varying the angles of the fins to further "tune" the flow.
  • Evaluation Metrics: The authors suggest incorporating more diverse performance indicators in future studies, such as the Nusselt number and vortex volume, to provide an even more comprehensive view of cooling efficiency.

Summary updated

Abstract

Power electronic equipment to miniaturization, high integration direction while facing the problem of high heat flow density and uneven temperature distribution. The large temperature fluctuations and uneven temperature distribution in the operation of power electronic equipment will lead to thermal stress, and excessive thermal stress or uneven distribution will cause fatigue failure of the packaging material, resulting in reduced reliability, module failure, and reduced life of power electronic equipment. In this paper, we propose two kinds of liquid-cooled flow channel non-linear reinforced heat transfer homogeneous liquid-cooled plate, which is theoretically derived to achieve the design requirement of uniform temperature on the heating side wall surface. The thermal design of the cold plate is carried out using ANSYS Workbench, and the indicators of various structures of the cold plate are analyzed and compared in terms of their ability to dissipate heat and maintain temperature uniformity. Based on the original runner structure, the heat dissipation performance of the rod structure and fin structure was evaluated, and the form of the internal heat dissipation structure of the runner was determined. The results show that the integrated liquid cooling plate temperature uniformity and flow resistance of both factors, the fin column heat sink is significantly better than the cylindrical fin column heat sink in the case of the same thermal resistance, the fin column heat sink flow resistance is significantly lower than the cylindrical fin column heat sink.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2023cold,
  author = {Kai Zhao and Xiaoxia Sun and Yuanqing Xia and Qiangqiang Li and Lili Shen and Min Lin},
  title = {{Cold plate performance enhancement based on parametric modeling of multiple structures}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.1087682},
}
Figure