TL;DR
Researchers at the National Institute of Metrology (NIM) have developed a novel electromagnet design for their joule balance, incorporating ferromagnetic material to significantly boost magnetic field strength and reduce coil heating. This innovation aims to improve the precision of Planck constant measurements, crucial for redefining the kilogram, by mitigating uncertainties associated with coil deformation and nonlinear magnetic effects.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The joule balance is a key instrument in the effort to redefine the kilogram based on fundamental physical constants, specifically the Planck constant. A critical aspect of the joule balance is the generation of a strong and stable magnetic field to exert a precise force on a suspended coil. Traditional joule balance designs often require substantial current in the exciting coils to achieve this, leading to significant coil heating. This heating can cause coil deformation and introduce uncertainties due to thermal expansion and air currents, impacting measurement accuracy. Previous attempts to mitigate this, such as using superconducting coils, proved too complex and expensive. This paper addresses the challenge of achieving a strong magnetic field with minimal coil heating and overcoming the nonlinearities introduced by new materials.
Methods
The core innovation lies in the design of a new electromagnet that utilizes a ferromagnetic material core. This core significantly enhances the magnetic field produced by the exciting coils. To manage the nonlinear characteristics and hysteresis inherent in ferromagnetic materials, the researchers propose a method of directly measuring the difference in magnetic flux linkage of the entire secondary coil system (including the suspended and compensation coils) at two vertical positions, rather than relying on traditional mutual inductance measurements. This approach aims to circumvent the uncertainties introduced by nonlinear magnetic behavior. The design also incorporates compensation coils to counteract the magnetic motive force generated by the suspended coil itself, ensuring a stable magnetic field distribution. Finite element method (FEM) simulations were used to analyze magnetic field profiles and calculate forces.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Ferromagnetic Core for Enhanced Field and Reduced Heating: The integration of a ferromagnetic material core dramatically increases the magnetic field strength (by a factor of ~14 compared to previous designs) while simultaneously reducing coil heating to a mere 7.5 W. This is a significant improvement for precision measurements.
- Flux Linkage Measurement to Bypass Nonlinearity: By measuring the difference in magnetic flux linkage rather than mutual inductance, the design effectively sidesteps the problematic nonlinearities and hysteresis of the ferromagnetic material, which would otherwise introduce significant measurement errors.
- Compensation Coils are Crucial: The inclusion of upper and lower compensation coils is essential for canceling out the magnetic field distortions caused by the current in the suspended coil, ensuring a stable and predictable magnetic field for accurate force measurements.
- Reluctance Force is Manageable: The paper analyzes the reluctance force (an additional force arising from changes in magnetic flux linkage) and demonstrates, through theoretical analysis and simulation, that it can be effectively controlled and minimized, especially when the measurement is performed symmetrically.
Key Results
The new electromagnet design achieves a magnetic field of approximately 85.6 mT in the air gap, a substantial increase from previous designs. Coil heating is reduced to 7.5 W, leading to minimal temperature rises (3 K for the exciting coil, 1 K in the air gap). The magnetic field profile is shown to be remarkably flat over a significant measurement interval (± 60 mm), with a relative change of only about 3 parts in 10⁴. Theoretical analysis suggests that the nonlinearity error introduced by the ferromagnetic material is negligible, and the reluctance force can be controlled to well below 1×10⁻⁸.
Limitations and Future Work
While the new design significantly improves upon previous iterations, some limitations and areas for future work are noted:
- Coil Heating in Vacuum: Although significantly reduced, coil heating still exists. For vacuum operation, special considerations for heat transmission will be necessary.
- Experimental Verification of Reluctance Force: The theoretical analysis of the reluctance force is based on an ideal proportionality to z. The paper acknowledges that the actual f(z) function needs to be measured experimentally, and the residual error η re-evaluated based on this data.
- Asymmetry in Reluctance Force Measurement: While theoretically manageable, achieving perfect symmetry in the vertical positions for reluctance force cancellation in practice can be challenging.
- Further Optimization: The paper implies that further theoretical analysis and optimization of the secondary current effects in the weighing phase are ongoing.
Summary updated