Cohort Profile for the Heat in Pregnancy- India (HiP-India) Study

Ramachandran Thiruvengadam, Sreevatsan Raghavan, Rekha Shanmugam, Tanya Isaac, Gabriela De Jesus Cipriano Flores, Arya Thonikund Sathishkumar, Sudhakar Reddy Bulla, Parul Dayal, Ayushi Ayushi, Mudita Gosain, Neera Parmar, Lovejeet Kaur, Divya Arya, Savita Singh, Sumit Misra, Dharmendra Sharma, Taruna Rattan, Mukesh Juyal, Sunil Kumar Nanda, Mary Daniel, Alaganandam Padma, Rachna Jain, Pranesh Nigam, Shantanu Pathak, Gabriel Davis Jones, Fadil Hannan, Bapu Koundinya Desiraju, Shailaja Sopory, Pallavi Kshetrapal, Sushil Prabakaran, Sangeeta Raman Jogi, Devarsetty Praveen, Alka Singh, Manu Vatish, Basky Thilagnathan, Sagnik Dey, Vidhya Venugopal, Ashok Khurana, Aris T. Papageorghiou, Yogesh Jain, Mark Woodward, Jane E. Hirst, Shinjini Bhatnagar, Nitya WadhwaWellcome 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Pregnant women in India are increasingly exposed to extreme heat, a factor linked to adverse pregnancy outcomes. This study protocol outlines a comprehensive, multi-site prospective cohort to investigate the physiological mechanisms by which heat impacts maternal, fetal, and placental health, aiming to inform crucial adaptation strategies and policies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Climate change is leading to more frequent and intense heatwaves globally, posing a significant threat to maternal and child health. Pregnant women, especially in low- and middle-income countries like India, are particularly vulnerable to the adverse effects of extreme heat, which have been associated with preterm birth, stillbirth, gestational diabetes, and preeclampsia. However, the precise biological mechanisms linking heat exposure to these outcomes, and the factors that make individuals more susceptible, remain poorly understood. This study aims to bridge this knowledge gap by characterizing the physiological and pathophysiological responses of mothers, placentas, and fetuses to varying levels of heat, humidity, and air pollution in India.

Methods

The HiP-India study employs a prospective, multicenter cohort design, recruiting 600 pregnant women with singleton pregnancies confirmed by ultrasound between 11-14 weeks gestation. The study spans three distinct climate zones in India: Gurugram (semi-arid), Bilaspur (humid sub-tropical), and Puducherry (tropical wet and dry).

Key methodological components include:

  • Environmental Monitoring: Participants will have their exposure to heat, humidity, and air pollution measured for 24 hours each trimester using individual and area monitoring devices. This includes wearable devices (Fitbit Sense 2, iButton sensors) and stationary loggers, complemented by satellite data and meteorological information.
  • Physiological Assessments: Measures include urinary specific gravity, core body temperature, heart rate, and blood pressure. Maternal hemodynamics will be assessed non-invasively using the USCOM 1A® pulsed wave monitor.
  • Fetal and Placental Evaluation: Fetal ultrasound will be used to assess growth and fetal-placental blood flow. Cardiotocography will be conducted in the third trimester. Maternal blood samples will be collected to analyze circulating biomarkers of placental function and stress.
  • Perceived Heat Stress: A modified HOTHAPS questionnaire will capture participants' subjective experience of heat stress.
  • Lactation Assessment: A subset of 100 women will undergo assessment of lactation physiology in the first two weeks postpartum, including timing of onset, milk composition, and hormone levels.
  • Data Analysis: A pre-specified Statistical Analysis Plan (SAP) will guide analyses, utilizing mixed-effects models (LME, GLMM, GAMM) to account for longitudinal and multi-site data, and Distributed Lag Non-Linear Models (DLNM) to examine delayed and non-linear exposure-response relationships. A Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) will inform confounder control.

Datasets

The study utilizes data collected prospectively from pregnant women. It also leverages existing data from the retrospective GARBH-Ini cohort and a large, nationally representative database of fetal heart rate monitoring.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mechanistic Focus: The study's strength lies in its deep dive into the mechanisms linking heat exposure to adverse outcomes, moving beyond simple associations to understand the biological pathways involved.
  • Multi-site, Multi-Climate Approach: By studying three distinct climate zones in India, the research can capture a wider range of heat exposures and their differential impacts, providing a more nuanced understanding than studies focusing on a single "high-heat" environment.
  • Integrated Monitoring: The combination of environmental, physiological, and biochemical measurements, along with subjective perception of heat stress, offers a holistic view of the heat-pregnancy interaction.
  • Novel Lactation Sub-study: Investigating the impact of heat on lactation is a unique and important aspect, addressing a critical period for infant nutrition and health.
  • Translational Relevance: The findings are explicitly aimed at informing climate adaptation strategies and emergency response policies, highlighting the direct public health impact of the research.

Key Results

As this is a protocol paper, specific results are not yet available. The paper outlines the planned study design, objectives, and methods for data collection and analysis. The expected outcomes include:

  • Characterization of physiological and pathophysiological responses of mother, placenta, and fetus to heat exposure.
  • Identification of critical windows and mechanisms of heat-related risk during pregnancy.
  • Identification of biomarkers and clinical factors associated with heat exposure and adverse pregnancy outcomes.
  • Understanding of how demographic and socioeconomic factors may modify the relationship between heat exposure and outcomes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Adolescent Exclusion: The exclusion of adolescents (<18 years), a group potentially at increased risk, is noted as a point for justification.
  • Home Births: The handling of data from potential home births needs clarification.
  • Consent Process: The ongoing nature of informed consent throughout the study visits is highlighted.
  • Intrapartum/Postpartum Measurements: The absence of specific intrapartum or postpartum measurements related to hydration and maternal physiology is identified as a potential missed opportunity, especially given the proximity to delivery.
  • Colostrum Sampling: The ethics and practicality of colostrum sampling, particularly for primiparous women with low supply, require clarification.
  • Exposure Representativeness: A single 24-hour exposure measurement per trimester might not fully represent trimester-level exposure, and the strategy for triangulating data from multiple devices and handling discrepancies needs to be clearly articulated.
  • Wearable Device Safety: Potential safety concerns related to wearable devices (theft, stigma, replacement) are raised.
  • Outcome Standardization: The standardization of diagnosis and documentation for outcomes across sites needs to be ensured.
  • Gestational Age Variation: Clarification is needed on the variation expected in "gestational age" as an outcome and the interpretation of sensitivity analyses based on "gestational timing of exposure" when all participants are enrolled early.
  • Comparator Group Framing: Reframing "winter-recruited participants" as "lower exposure periods" rather than a formal comparator group is suggested for clarity.
  • Outcome Hierarchy Consistency: Harmonizing the definition of primary and secondary outcomes across the manuscript, structured summary, and trial registration is recommended.
  • Preconception Factors: The impact of maternal preconception condition and exposure, particularly from the previous cool season, on pregnancy outcomes is suggested for consideration, potentially as a tertiary objective.
  • Fixed Air Conditioning: The restriction to women without fixed air conditioning, while enhancing exposure contrast, may limit external validity, and this limitation should be acknowledged and quantified.
  • Mediation Analysis Assumptions: The strong assumptions underlying the proposed mediation pathway require careful consideration and approaches to address unmeasured confounding and measurement error.

Future work will involve the implementation of the protocol, data analysis, and dissemination of findings to inform policy and practice.

Summary updated

Abstract

All necessary ethical approvals from relevant committees at participating institutions have been obtained. Written informed consent will be obtained from all participants. The findings from this study are expected to inform climate adaptation strategies and emergency response policies to protect pregnant populations from the impacts of extreme heat, both within India and in other similarly affected regions globally. Results are aimed for journal publication, communicate findings to participants in plain language, disseminating information at conferences and events of similar nature.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{thiruvengadam2025cohort,
  author = {Ramachandran Thiruvengadam and Sreevatsan Raghavan and Rekha Shanmugam and Tanya Isaac and Gabriela De Jesus Cipriano Flores and Arya Thonikund Sathishkumar and Sudhakar Reddy Bulla and Parul Dayal and Ayushi Ayushi and Mudita Gosain and Neera Parmar and Lovejeet Kaur and Divya Arya and Savita Singh and Sumit Misra and Dharmendra Sharma and Taruna Rattan and Mukesh Juyal and Sunil Kumar Nanda and Mary Daniel and Alaganandam Padma and Rachna Jain and Pranesh Nigam and Shantanu Pathak and Gabriel Davis Jones and Fadil Hannan and Bapu Koundinya Desiraju and Shailaja Sopory and Pallavi Kshetrapal and Sushil Prabakaran and Sangeeta Raman Jogi and Devarsetty Praveen and Alka Singh and Manu Vatish and Basky Thilagnathan and Sagnik Dey and Vidhya Venugopal and Ashok Khurana and Aris T. Papageorghiou and Yogesh Jain and Mark Woodward and Jane E. Hirst and Shinjini Bhatnagar and Nitya Wadhwa},
  title = {{Cohort Profile for the Heat in Pregnancy- India (HiP-India) Study}},
  booktitle = {Wellcome},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.12688/wellcomeopenres.24393.2},
}
Figure