Coherent structures in dissipative particle dynamics simulations of the transition to turbulence in compressible shear flows

Jan-Willem van de Meent, Alexander Morozov, Ellák Somfai, Eric Sultan, Wim van SaarloosPhysical 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that Dissipative Particle Dynamics (DPD), a particle-based simulation method, can accurately reproduce the complex coherent structures that govern the transition to turbulence in shear flows, even when the fluid is highly compressible. This finding highlights the robustness of these structures and validates DPD as a powerful tool for studying fluid dynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how smooth, laminar fluid flow transitions into chaotic, turbulent flow is a fundamental challenge in fluid mechanics. For parallel shear flows, like those found in pipes or between plates, research has revealed that this transition isn't a sudden jump but is often mediated by specific, organized patterns called "coherent structures." These structures, like streaks and streamwise vortices, can even sustain themselves, a phenomenon known as the self-sustaining process (SSP). While these structures have been observed experimentally and simulated using traditional methods (like Direct Numerical Simulations or DNS), their behavior in compressible fluids, especially at the low Mach numbers relevant to many real-world scenarios, has been less explored. This paper aims to investigate the robustness of these coherent structures and the SSP mechanism in compressible shear flows using a particle-based simulation technique, DPD.

Methods

The core of this research lies in using the Dissipative Particle Dynamics (DPD) method. DPD is a mesoscopic simulation technique that represents fluids as discrete particles interacting through conservative, dissipative, and random forces. This approach sacrifices microscopic detail for computational efficiency, allowing for simulations of larger systems and longer timescales than traditional molecular dynamics. The authors specifically employed DPD to model two classic shear flow geometries: plane Couette flow (flow between two plates moving in opposite directions) and pressure-driven pipe flow. They then analyzed the resulting flow fields to identify coherent structures and study the transition to turbulence. A key aspect of their approach was to investigate how compressibility, controlled by tuning DPD parameters and thus the effective Mach number, affects the transition.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors generated their own simulation data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Robustness of Coherent Structures: The paper's most striking finding is that the coherent structures governing the transition to turbulence in shear flows are remarkably similar to those observed in incompressible flows, even when the DPD fluid is highly compressible (Mach numbers orders of magnitude lower than typical DPD compressibility). This suggests that the fundamental physics of the transition is quite resilient to compressibility effects.
  • DPD as a Valid Tool: The successful reproduction of known phenomena in fluid turbulence using DPD validates its use for studying complex non-linear instabilities. This is particularly significant as DPD is often easier to extend to multiphase and viscoelastic flows than traditional methods.
  • Compressibility's Influence: While the structures are robust, compressibility does have a noticeable effect. It shifts the transition to higher Reynolds numbers and can make the transition less abrupt, potentially even continuous, compared to the bistable, jump-like transitions seen in incompressible flows.
  • Bistability and Control: The study confirms the bistable nature of the transition, where both laminar and weakly turbulent states can coexist. They also show that initial forcing can be used to create specific turbulent states (like 1-pair modes), which can then be sustained or relaminarize.

Key Results

  • DPD simulations successfully reproduced streak and streamwise vortex structures characteristic of the self-sustaining process (SSP) in shear flows.
  • The transition to turbulence in DPD simulations showed a bistable behavior, consistent with experimental and DNS findings for incompressible flows.
  • Increasing compressibility (decreasing Mach number) led to a shift in the transition to higher Reynolds numbers.
  • For highly compressible flows, the transition appeared to become smoother, moving away from the sharp, jump-like bifurcation observed at lower compressibility.
  • The paper provides visualizations (Figures 1 and 2) showing these coherent structures in both plane Couette and pipe flow simulations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Compressibility vs. Thermal Fluctuations: The authors acknowledge that it's not definitively clear whether the observed differences in transition behavior (continuous vs. jump-like) are solely due to compressibility, finite temperature effects, or a combination of factors. Further work is needed to disentangle these influences.
  • DPD's Intrinsic Compressibility: A noted limitation of DPD is its inherent compressibility, which means that even when aiming for low Mach numbers, the fluid is still significantly more compressible than many real-world fluids. This limits the range of Mach numbers that can be accurately explored.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that DPD's flexibility makes it ideal for exploring interactions in more complex fluid systems. They also plan to conduct a more detailed study of the dynamical transitions observed in the pipe flow simulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present simulations of coherent structures in compressible flows near the transition to turbulence using the dissipative particle dynamics method. The structures we find are remarkably consistent with experimental observations and direct numerical simulations (DNS) simulations of incompressible flows, despite a difference in Mach number of several orders of magnitude. The bifurcation from the laminar flow is bistable and shifts to higher Reynolds numbers when the fluid becomes more compressible. This work underlines the robustness of coherent structures in the transition to turbulence and illustrates the ability of particle-based methods to reproduce complex nonlinear instabilities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{meent2008coherent,
  author = {Jan-Willem van de Meent and Alexander Morozov and Ellák Somfai and Eric Sultan and Wim van Saarloos},
  title = {{Coherent structures in dissipative particle dynamics simulations of the transition to turbulence in compressible shear flows}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.78.015701},
}
Figure