Coherent olfactory bulb gamma oscillations arise from coupling independent columnar oscillators

Shane T. Peace, Benjamin C. Johnson, Jesse C. Werth, Guoshi Li, Martin E. Kaiser, Izumi Fukunaga, Andreas T. Schaefer, Alyosha Molnar, Thomas A. ClelandJournal of Neurophysiology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

The olfactory bulb generates synchronized gamma oscillations, crucial for sensory processing, through the coupling of independent "columnar" oscillators. This coupling is mediated by GABAergic synapses, allowing for robust, widespread network coherence even when local processing units are diverse. This mechanism supports precise spike timing and phase coding, essential for efficient neural communication.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The olfactory bulb (OB) is a critical early processing center for smell, generating rhythmic gamma oscillations (20-70 Hz) in response to odor stimulation. These oscillations are thought to be vital for encoding olfactory information through precise spike timing, rather than just firing rates. A key question has been how the OB achieves widespread, synchronized gamma oscillations across its entire structure, given that individual neurons and local circuits are highly diverse. Specifically, how can a network with heterogeneous inputs and local processing units maintain a coherent, "common clock" signal that spans the entire OB? This paper aims to elucidate the underlying dynamical mechanisms responsible for this widespread coherence.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • In vitro OB slice preparations: They used microelectrode array (MEA) recordings from acute horizontal slices of mouse olfactory bulbs.
  • Optogenetic and Pharmacological Stimulation: Sensory neuron axons (OSNs) expressing channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) were optogenetically stimulated. Additionally, chemical agonists (ACPD, CCh) were used to evoke gamma oscillations.
  • MEA Recordings: A 60-electrode planar MEA was used to record local field potentials (LFPs) from the external plexiform layer (EPL) of the OB slices, allowing for spatial mapping of oscillatory activity.
  • Intracellular Recordings: Whole-cell patch-clamp recordings were performed in both slice and in vivo preparations to investigate the activity of individual neurons (mitral cells and granule cells).
  • GABA(A) Receptor Blockade: The role of GABA(A)ergic inhibition was investigated by bath-applying antagonists like bicuculline methiodide (BMI) and gabazine.
  • Computational Modeling: A biophysically realistic network model of the OB was constructed and modified to simulate both slice and in vivo conditions, allowing for the testing of hypotheses about connectivity and coherence.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study primarily relies on experimental recordings from mice and computational modeling.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Columnar Oscillators: The OB appears to be composed of independent "columnar" oscillators, likely corresponding to glomeruli and their associated principal neurons and interneurons. These local oscillators are intrinsically GABA(A) receptor-independent.
  • GABA(A)-Mediated Coupling: The widespread, synchronized gamma oscillations observed in the intact OB are achieved by coupling these independent columnar oscillators via GABA(A)-ergic synapses. This inter-columnar coupling synchronizes the local oscillators into a faster, coherent network rhythm.
  • Slice vs. In Vivo Differences: In slice preparations, where long-range lateral connections are severed, coherence is localized to these "columns." In the intact in vivo network, however, extensive lateral connections between mitral cells and granule cells enable these local oscillators to synchronize globally.
  • Coherence, Not Power: Blocking GABA(A) receptors in slices doesn't reduce the power of gamma oscillations in individual electrodes, but it significantly reduces the spatial coherence between them. This explains why previous studies using lower-resolution electrodes might have reported a stronger dependence of gamma power on GABA(A)ergic signaling.
  • Spike Timing Constraint: The synchronized gamma oscillations effectively constrain the timing of action potentials in principal neurons, supporting hypotheses of spike timing-based sensory coding.

Key Results

  • Optogenetic stimulation of OSN arbors or pharmacological activation (ACPD, CCh) reliably evoked persistent gamma oscillations in OB slices.
  • GABA(A) receptor blockade in slices reduced the peak frequency of oscillations and significantly impaired inter-electrode coherence, but did not reduce oscillatory power.
  • In vivo recordings and computational modeling demonstrated that long-range lateral connections in the intact OB are crucial for generating global gamma coherence, effectively coupling the local columnar oscillators.
  • The computational model successfully replicated the observed differences in coherence between slice and in vivo preparations, supporting the proposed mechanism of coupled columnar oscillators.
  • Action potentials of principal neurons were phase-constrained with respect to the evoked gamma oscillations, particularly with ChR2 stimulation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Slice Preparation Artifacts: The authors acknowledge that the slice preparation severs long-range lateral connections, leading to localized coherence. While they model this, the full complexity of in vivo connectivity is challenging to perfectly replicate.
  • Model Simplifications: While biophysically realistic, the computational model is still a simplification of the complex OB circuitry.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that understanding these mechanisms is crucial for understanding how coherence patterns are managed and shifted according to environmental factors, and how they reflect spike timing-based computations and the gating of interareal communication. Further research could explore how these properties relate to specific olfactory behaviors and learning.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spike timing-based representations of sensory information depend on embedded dynamical frameworks within neuronal networks that establish the rules of local computation and interareal communication. Here, we investigated the dynamical properties of olfactory bulb circuitry in mice of both sexes using microelectrode array recordings from slice and in vivo preparations. Neurochemical activation or optogenetic stimulation of sensory afferents evoked persistent gamma oscillations in the local field potential. These oscillations arose from slower, GABA(A) receptor-independent intracolumnar oscillators coupled by GABA(A)-ergic synapses into a faster, broadly coherent network oscillation. Consistent with the theoretical properties of coupled-oscillator networks, the spatial extent of zero-phase coherence was bounded in slices by the reduced density of lateral interactions. The intact in vivo network, however, exhibited long-range lateral interactions that suffice in simulation to enable zero-phase gamma coherence across the olfactory bulb. The timing of action potentials in a subset of principal neurons was phase-constrained with respect to evoked gamma oscillations. Coupled-oscillator dynamics in olfactory bulb thereby enable a common clock, robust to biological heterogeneities, that is capable of supporting gamma-band spike synchronization and phase coding across the ensemble of activated principal neurons.<b>NEW & NOTEWORTHY</b> Odor stimulation evokes rhythmic gamma oscillations in the field potential of the olfactory bulb, but the dynamical mechanisms governing these oscillations have remained unclear. Establishing these mechanisms is important as they determine the biophysical capacities of the bulbar circuit to, for example, maintain zero-phase coherence across a spatially extended network, or coordinate the timing of action potentials in principal neurons. These properties in turn constrain and suggest hypotheses of sensory coding.
BibTeX
@article{peace2024coherent,
  author = {Shane T. Peace and Benjamin C. Johnson and Jesse C. Werth and Guoshi Li and Martin E. Kaiser and Izumi Fukunaga and Andreas T. Schaefer and Alyosha Molnar and Thomas A. Cleland},
  title = {{Coherent olfactory bulb gamma oscillations arise from coupling independent columnar oscillators}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00361.2023},
}
Figure