Coherent movement patterns of female northern elephant seals across the NE Pacific Ocean

Shichao Pei, Xiangliang Zhang, Vı́ctor M. Eguı́luz, Sarah S. Kienle, Patrick W. Robinson, Daniel P. Costa, Carlos M. DuarteFrontiers in Marine Science 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Northern elephant seals engage in large-scale foraging migrations traveling up to 15,000 km over 8 months in the northeast Pacific. While traditionally considered solitary migrants, we demonstrate here that female seals migrate in a surprisingly coherent manner for individual northern elephant seals traveling in over such a large region of the ocean. Animal movement remained coherent, in terms of the direction of individual swimming relative to group movement, throughout much of their migrations. Movement coherence remained well above the value expected if the movement was independent until the migrating seals were further than 1,000 km from the colony, beyond which movement coherence declined. Migrating seals presented regional aggregations consisting of female seals traveling within the center of the aggregation, closely following the main migration pathway, with individuals isolated on the extremes of the aggregation. These formations were preserved in the out-and-return migration trips. Animals at the edges of the group show an absence of correlation in their movement with the rest of animals. The observed movements exhibited a lag in the group movement patterns that was greater for female animals > 1,000 km apart. A model that reproduced movement based on the average individual movement properties failed to reproduce the observed movement patterns. In turn, when a parameter was introduced that reflected group behavior, the resulting modelled movement conformed to the observed patterns, thereby demonstrating the presence of coherent, or synchronized, movement. Whereas the duration of female migration is ultimately constrained by reproductive biology, the coherent movement may involve both endogenous and exogenous cues determining the timing of the initiation of return across 25 million $km^2$ in the northeast Pacific.

Introduction

Satellite tracking has revolutionized our understanding of individual animal movements, yet collective behavior in large marine predators remains poorly understood. Northern elephant seals (Mirounga angustirostris) perform two massive migrations per year: a short post-breeding trip and a long 8-month foraging trip. Traditionally, these animals were viewed as solitary wanderers because they are rarely seen together at sea. This study challenges that assumption, investigating whether thousands of seals follow a shared "oceanic highway" and utilize a common "clock" to synchronize their movements across 25 million $km^2$ of the Northeast Pacific.

Methods

The researchers analyzed a 10-year tracking archive from the Tagging of Pacific Predators (TOPP) program, involving 321 tagged female northern elephant seals and over one million individual positions. To quantify group dynamics, they utilized several metrics:

  • Movement Coherence: The consistency of an individual's swimming direction relative to the group's overall movement.
  • Group Spread: The total area covered by the population over time.
  • Simulation Modeling: Real data were compared against a "Naive Model" (independent movement) and a "Center-of-Mass Model" (group-influenced movement).

Group Dynamics and Spatial Fidelity

The migration exhibits a distinct internal structure. A "core" of seals follows the main migration pathway closely, while "maverick" individuals on the periphery show less correlation with the group. This spatial organization is preserved during both the outward and return phases of the journey. Analysis of group spread shows clear seasonal cycles, with the population expanding as they move further into the Pacific and contracting as they return to the colony.

Figure A: Distance from origin, group spread, and spatial density of seal locations.

Movement Coherence and the 1,000 km Threshold

Movement coherence remains remarkably high throughout the majority of the migration, staying well above the values expected for independent movement. However, a clear threshold exists: once seals are more than 1,000 km from the colony, the "social" or coherent signal begins to decay. At these greater distances, individuals likely prioritize local foraging cues over group-level synchronization. Modeling confirmed that individual-based movement properties alone cannot replicate the observed distribution; only models incorporating group behavior parameters matched the real-world data.

Figure B: Movement coherence relative to distance and time, alongside migratory tracks.

The Solar Clock and Synchronized Return

One of the most striking findings is the precision of the return journey. Regardless of their specific location in the vast Pacific, seals initiate their return trip around March 28 (short trip) and September 7 (long trip). These dates align closely with the solar equinoxes, suggesting that day length serves as a universal trigger. The median lag time for initiating the return trip among nearest neighbors was just one day, despite being separated by hundreds of kilometers.

Conclusion

Female northern elephant seals are not solitary migrants but move in a highly synchronized fashion. This coherence is likely maintained through a combination of endogenous biological clocks and exogenous cues, such as the solar equinox and Earth's magnetic field. While the exact sensory mechanisms for this coordination remain to be fully elucidated, the failure of individualistic models to explain seal distribution highlights the fundamental importance of collective behavior in the life history of these deep-diving predators.

Summary updated

Abstract

Northern elephant seals engage in large-scale foraging migrations traveling up to 15,000 Km over 8 months in the northeast Pacific. While traditionally considered solitary migrants, we demonstrate here that female seals migrate in a surprisingly coherent manner, for individual northern elephant seals traveling in over such a large region of the ocean. Animal movement remained coherent, in terms of the direction of individual swimming relative to group movement, throughout much of their migrations. Movement coherence remained well above the value expected if the movement was independent until the migrating seals were further than 1,000 Km from the colony, beyond which movement coherence declined. Migrating seals presented regional aggregations consisting of female seals traveling within the center of the aggregation, closely following the main migration pathway, with individuals isolated on the extremes of the aggregation. These formations were preserved in the out-and-return migration trips. Animals at the edges of the group show an absence of correlation in their movement with the rest of animals. The observed movements exhibited a lag in the group movement patterns that was greater for female animals > 1,000 Km apart. A model that reproduced movement based on the average individual movement properties failed to reproduce the observed movement patterns. In turn, when a parameter was introduced that reflected group behavior, the resulting modelled movement conformed to the observed patterns, thereby demonstrating the presence of coherent, or synchronized, movement. Whereas the duration of female migration is ultimately constrained by reproductive biology, the coherent movement may involve both endogenous and exogenous cues determining the timing of the initiation of return across 25 million Km 2 in the northeast Pacific.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pei2023coherent,
  author = {Shichao Pei and Xiangliang Zhang and Vı́ctor M. Eguı́luz and Sarah S. Kienle and Patrick W. Robinson and Daniel P. Costa and Carlos M. Duarte},
  title = {{Coherent movement patterns of female northern elephant seals across the NE Pacific Ocean}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2023.689953},
}
Figure