TL;DR
Hepatitis E virus (HEV) exhibits distinct codon usage patterns across its various genotypes, influenced by a combination of natural selection and mutation pressure. Understanding these patterns offers insights into HEV evolution and could aid in developing better vaccines and diagnostics.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Hepatitis E virus (HEV) is a significant emerging zoonotic pathogen with a diverse range of genotypes infecting humans, animals, and potentially bridging species. While codon usage bias is known to influence viral gene expression, adaptation, and evolution in many viruses, the specific codon usage patterns and the driving forces behind them in HEV remained largely uncharacterized. This study aims to fill that knowledge gap by comprehensively analyzing the codon usage across seven major HEV genotypes.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-faceted bioinformatic approach to dissect HEV codon usage:
- Data Collection: They gathered 98 complete coding sequences of HEV from the GenBank database, representing seven genotypes (HEV-1, HEV-3, HEV-4, HEV-8, HEV-B, HEV-C1, and HEV-C2).
- Nucleotide Composition Analysis: They calculated the frequencies of nucleotides (A, T, G, C) and GC content at different codon positions to understand the basic building blocks of the viral genomes.
- Relative Synonymous Codon Usage (RSCU): This standard method quantifies the preference for specific synonymous codons (codons that code for the same amino acid). An RSCU value greater than 1 indicates a preferred codon, while a value less than 1 suggests underutilization.
- Principal Component Analysis (PCA): PCA was used to reduce the dimensionality of RSCU data, allowing visualization of major patterns and variations in codon usage across different genotypes.
- Relative Dinucleotide Abundance Analysis: This technique examines the frequency of pairs of adjacent nucleotides (dinucleotides), which can be influenced by translation selection and host immune evasion strategies.
- Parity Rule 2 (PR2) Analysis: PR2 plots help to distinguish between the influences of mutation pressure and natural selection on codon usage by analyzing the balance of purines (A, G) and pyrimidines (T, C) at the third codon position.
- Effective Number of Codons (ENC) Analysis: ENC values provide a measure of codon usage bias, with lower ENC values indicating higher bias. The ENC-plot analysis further helps to differentiate between the roles of mutation pressure and natural selection.
- Neutrality Plot Analysis: This method plots GC content at the third codon position against GC content at the first two positions to infer the relative contributions of mutation pressure and natural selection.
- Relative Codon Deoptimization Index (RCDI): RCDI was used to compare the codon usage similarity between HEV and its hosts, providing insights into adaptation.
Datasets
The study utilized a dataset of 98 complete HEV coding sequences obtained from the NCBI GenBank database. These sequences represented seven HEV genotypes: HEV-1, HEV-3, HEV-4, HEV-8, HEV-B, HEV-C1, and HEV-C2. The authors excluded HEV-2, HEV-5, HEV-6, and HEV-7 due to limited available sequences.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Genotype-Specific Signatures: HEV isn't a monolithic entity; its various genotypes exhibit distinct codon usage patterns. This suggests that different evolutionary pressures have shaped each lineage.
- G/C Richness Preference: Most HEV genotypes show a preference for codons ending in G or C, a common strategy in many viruses to enhance mRNA stability and translation efficiency. HEV-8 is a notable exception, showing a slight tendency towards A/U endings.
- Natural Selection Reigns Supreme: The primary driver shaping HEV codon usage bias appears to be natural selection, which favors codons that optimize gene expression and protein synthesis. Mutation pressure plays a supporting role, particularly in certain genotypes.
- Dinucleotide Signatures: HEV exhibits unique dinucleotide usage patterns, suggesting that translation selection has played a role in shaping these sequences. The underrepresentation of CpG dinucleotides, common in many viruses, might be an immune evasion strategy.
- Host Adaptation Clues: The RCDI analysis suggests that ORF1, encoding non-structural proteins, is generally more adapted to host environments than ORF2 (capsid protein) and ORF3 (involved in viral release). This could imply ORF1's critical role in establishing infection.
Key Results
- Nucleotide Composition: Six out of seven HEV genotypes showed a preference for codons ending in G/C, with HEV-B exhibiting the strongest bias. HEV-8 showed a slight bias towards A/U.
- RSCU Analysis: A total of 13 codons were preferentially used across HEV genotypes, with 10 of them ending in G/C. HEV-3 and HEV-4 displayed very similar codon usage patterns. HEV-1 showed the highest number of preferred and overrepresented codons, indicating the strongest codon usage bias.
- PCA Findings: PCA revealed distinct clustering of HEV genotypes, highlighting genotype-specific codon usage patterns. However, HEV-4 and HEV-8 ellipses overlapped significantly with other genotypes, suggesting potential variability or sampling bias.
- Dinucleotide Abundance: UpG was generally overrepresented, while CpG was underrepresented across most HEV genotypes. These patterns varied between complete genomes and individual ORFs.
- ENC Values: The mean ENC value for complete HEV genomes was 53.5, with significant differences across genotypes. HEV-1 had the lowest ENC (48.9), indicating the highest codon usage bias.
- Driving Forces: Natural selection was identified as the predominant force shaping codon usage bias in HEV-1, HEV-3, HEV-B, and HEV-C1. In contrast, HEV-4, HEV-8, and HEV-C2 were influenced by a combination of natural selection and mutation pressure.
- Host Adaptation: RCDI values indicated that ORF1 generally showed higher adaptation to hosts compared to ORF2 and ORF3, suggesting a greater role for ORF1 in cross-species transmission.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Limited Sequence Availability: For some HEV genotypes, the number of available sequences in GenBank was limited, which might not perfectly capture the full spectrum of codon usage bias. However, they included all available reference sequences to mitigate this.
- Gene-Specific Differences: While overall genome-wide analysis is informative, it can mask variations in codon usage among different genes (ORFs) within the genome.
- Lack of Experimental Validation: The study relies solely on bioinformatics analysis. The authors suggest that experimental studies would be beneficial to validate their findings.
Future work could focus on:
- Expanding Sequence Data: Increasing the sampling and sequencing of HEV, especially for underrepresented genotypes, would lead to a more robust understanding.
- Investigating ORF4: The role of ORF4 in HEV-1 and HEV-C warrants further investigation, as its function appears to differ significantly between these genotypes.
- Experimental Validation: Conducting experimental studies to confirm the inferred roles of natural selection and mutation pressure, and to explore the functional implications of codon usage bias on HEV replication and pathogenesis.
- Vaccine and Therapeutic Development: The insights gained into codon usage bias could inform the design of more effective HEV vaccines and antiviral therapies.
Summary updated