Codon Usage Bias in Autophagy-Related Gene 13 in Eukaryotes: Uncovering the Genetic Divergence by the Interplay Between Nucleotides and Codon Usages

Yicong Li, Rui Wang, Huihui Wang, Feiyang Pu, Xili Feng, Li Hua Jin, Zhongren Ma, Xiaoxia MaFrontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the evolutionary patterns of the autophagy-related gene 13 (atg13) across 226 eukaryotic species. It reveals that while nucleotide usage provides more evolutionary information than amino acid usage, natural selection plays a dominant role in shaping codon usage in atg13 genes, even more so than mutation pressure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the unexplored evolutionary trends of the atg13 gene, specifically focusing on how nucleotide usage and synonymous codon usage have evolved across diverse eukaryotic organisms. While atg13 is known to be a crucial gene for initiating autophagy, a fundamental cellular process, its genetic characteristics and evolutionary trajectory at the codon level remained largely unknown. Understanding these patterns is important for deciphering the functional conservation and divergence of autophagy machinery across species and could shed light on how genetic variations influence biological processes.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Phylogenetic Analysis: They constructed phylogenetic trees for the atg13 gene at both the nucleotide and amino acid levels using the Maximum Composite Likelihood model with UPGMA statistical method. This allowed them to visualize the evolutionary relationships between different species based on their atg13 gene sequences.
  • Information Entropy for Nucleotide Usage Bias: To quantify the bias in nucleotide usage at different codon positions (first, second, and third) and overall, they used information entropy. This metric helps understand how uniformly or unevenly nucleotides are used.
  • Relative Synonymous Codon Usage (RSCU): RSCU was calculated to assess synonymous codon usage bias for each atg13 gene. They defined codons with RSCU values >1.6 as overrepresented and <0.6 as underrepresented.
  • Dispersion of Synonymous Codon Usages (V_s value): To measure the variability of synonymous codon usage across species, they introduced a dispersion metric (V_s value). A lower V_s value indicates more stable usage.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): PCA was used to visualize the overall genetic divergence in synonymous codon and amino acid usages among the atg13 genes.
  • Effective Number of Codons (ENC) and GC Content (GC3): These standard metrics were used to quantify overall codon usage bias and its relationship with nucleotide composition at the third codon position, respectively.
  • Parity Rule 2 (PR2) Plot Analysis: This analysis was performed to evaluate the interplay between mutation pressure and natural selection on codon usage by examining the balance of A-T and G-C content at the third codon position.
  • Nucleotide Skew Analysis: Various skew metrics (GC, AT, purine, pyrimidine, keto, amino) were calculated to assess nucleotide composition distribution at different codon positions and their correlations.

Datasets

The study utilized the complete coding sequences of the atg13 gene from 226 eukaryotic organisms, obtained from the National Center for Biotechnology (NCBI) Genome database. No new benchmarks or datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nucleotide Usage Carries More Evolutionary Information: The study found that nucleotide usage patterns in the atg13 gene contain more genetic information about evolutionary trends than amino acid usages. This suggests that changes at the nucleotide level, even if they don't alter the amino acid sequence, are important markers of evolution.
  • Natural Selection Dominates Codon Usage: Despite the influence of mutation pressure, particularly in ancestral animals, the study strongly indicates that natural selection is the primary driver shaping atg13 codon usage across most eukaryotes. This is a significant finding, highlighting the active role of evolutionary forces in optimizing gene expression.
  • Species-Specific Patterns Emerge: The atg13 gene exhibits species-specific patterns in its synonymous codon usage. This implies that while the gene's core function is conserved, its expression and translation are fine-tuned differently across various lineages.
  • Codon Bias as a Bridge: Synonymous codon usage acts as a crucial link between nucleotide composition and amino acid sequences, storing additional evolutionary traces. This highlights the complex interplay of factors influencing gene evolution.
  • Third Codon Position is More Variable: Nucleotide usage bias is generally stronger at the first and second codon positions than at the third. However, the third codon position shows more variation in nucleotide usage patterns across different eukaryotic organisms, suggesting it's a more dynamic site for evolutionary adaptation.

Key Results

  • 'G' is Most Biased, 'C' Least: Within the atg13 genes, the nucleotide 'G' shows the highest usage bias, while 'C' shows the lowest.
  • ENC Values Indicate Moderate Bias: The effective number of codons (ENC) values for atg13 genes across the studied organisms generally fall between 50 and 55, indicating a moderate level of codon usage bias, rather than extreme bias.
  • Ancestral Animals Show Mutation Pressure Influence: In ancestral animals like Latimeria chalumnae, Petromyzon marinus, and Rhinatrema bivittatum, codon usage appears to be more influenced by mutation pressure from nucleotide composition.
  • Strong Selective Forces on Synonymous Codons: The study identified specific synonymous codons that exhibit highly variant usage patterns across species, while others remain remarkably stable. This points to strong selective pressures acting on these codons.
  • PCA Reveals Groupings: PCA analysis visualized distinct clustering of organisms based on their codon usage patterns, with mammals and sauropsids forming separate groups, and fishes showing significant dispersion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on a Single Gene: The study focuses exclusively on the atg13 gene. While this provides in-depth insights into this specific gene, future work could expand to other autophagy-related genes or genes involved in different cellular processes to see if similar evolutionary patterns hold.
  • Correlation vs. Causation: While the study demonstrates strong correlations between nucleotide composition, codon usage, and natural selection, further experimental work might be needed to definitively establish causal relationships.
  • Broader Evolutionary Context: The paper suggests that the atg13 gene stores evolutionary traces. Future research could explore how these traces relate to the functional adaptations of autophagy in different environments or under specific selective pressures.
  • Investigating Other Factors: While natural selection and mutation pressure are highlighted, other factors like tRNA abundance and mRNA stability could be further investigated for their role in shaping atg13 codon usage.

Summary updated

Abstract

Synonymous codon usage bias is a universal characteristic of genomes across various organisms. Autophagy-related gene 13 (<i>atg13)</i> is one essential gene for autophagy initiation, yet the evolutionary trends of the <i>atg13</i> gene at the usages of nucleotide and synonymous codon remains unexplored. According to phylogenetic analyses for the <i>atg13</i> gene of 226 eukaryotic organisms at the nucleotide and amino acid levels, it is clear that their nucleotide usages exhibit more genetic information than their amino acid usages. Specifically, the overall nucleotide usage bias quantified by information entropy reflected that the usage biases at the first and second codon positions were stronger than those at the third position of the <i>atg13</i> genes. Furthermore, the bias level of nucleotide 'G' usage is highest, while that of nucleotide 'C' usage is lowest in the <i>atg13</i> genes. On top of that, genetic features represented by synonymous codon usage exhibits a species-specific pattern on the evolution of the <i>atg13</i> genes to some extent. Interestingly, the codon usages of atg13 genes in the ancestor animals (<i>Latimeria chalumnae</i>, <i>Petromyzon marinus, and Rhinatrema bivittatum</i>) are strongly influenced by mutation pressure from nucleotide composition constraint. However, the distributions of nucleotide composition at different codon positions in the <i>atg13</i> gene display that natural selection still dominates <i>atg13</i> codon usages during organisms' evolution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021codon,
  author = {Yicong Li and Rui Wang and Huihui Wang and Feiyang Pu and Xili Feng and Li Hua Jin and Zhongren Ma and Xiaoxia Ma},
  title = {{Codon Usage Bias in Autophagy-Related Gene 13 in Eukaryotes: Uncovering the Genetic Divergence by the Interplay Between Nucleotides and Codon Usages}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fcimb.2021.771010},
}
Figure