Code of Ethics: A Transoral Robotic Surgery Case Study

Yun ZhouProceedings of the Wellington Faculty of Engineering Ethics and Sustainability Symposium 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel, interdisciplinary code of ethics for robotics, synthesizing principles from engineering, medicine, and human-robot interaction. It then applies this framework to the complex case study of transoral robotic surgery (TORS) to demonstrate its practical utility in ensuring robotic technology benefits society.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As robots become increasingly autonomous and integrated into our lives, ethical dilemmas arise. The paper highlights the need for a comprehensive ethical framework to guide the development and deployment of robotic technologies, ensuring they are beneficial and not harmful to society. Existing ethical guidelines are often siloed within specific disciplines, and there's a lack of a unified approach for the interdisciplinary field of robotics. The paper aims to bridge this gap by creating a robust code of ethics and demonstrating its application in a real-world scenario.

Methods

The authors conducted a literature review of existing ethical codes and principles from various fields, including engineering (ENZ Code of Ethical Conduct), medical research (WMA Declaration of Helsinki), and computer science (ACM Code of Ethics). They also analyzed ethical issues specific to Human-Robot Interaction (HRI), drawing from research on topics like "Wizard of Oz" (WoZ) technology and privacy concerns. Based on this comprehensive review, they synthesized five core ethical principles for robotics. These principles were then applied to a case study of Transoral Robotic Surgery (TORS) to illustrate their practical implementation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interdisciplinary Synthesis is Crucial: Robotics is inherently interdisciplinary, so its ethical framework must draw from and integrate principles from engineering, medicine, computer science, and HRI.
  • Five Pillars of Robotic Ethics: The paper proposes five essential ethical principles:
  • Safeguard Health and Safety: This encompasses both physical and mental well-being, requiring robots to be designed to avoid causing harm and to respect human frailty.
  • Product Capability Transparency: Users and the public should be fully informed about a robot's capabilities and limitations to prevent deception and manage expectations.
  • Data Protection and Privacy: Human rights to data protection and privacy must be paramount, with robust safeguards and informed consent mechanisms.
  • Predictable and Reconstructible Behavior: Robot actions should be predictable and their decision-making processes reconstructible to ensure accountability.
  • Ethical Board Approval for Research: Studies and research involving robots must undergo ethical board review and approval.
  • TORS as a Testbed: Transoral Robotic Surgery (TORS) serves as a compelling case study, demonstrating how these ethical principles can be applied to a complex, high-stakes robotic application.
  • Ethical Risk Assessment: The paper advocates for a concise ethical risk assessment for all robotic products and services to allow for timely intervention and calibration of ethical values.

Key Results

The paper successfully synthesizes existing ethical guidelines into a novel, five-principle code of ethics for robotics. It then demonstrates the applicability of this code through a detailed analysis of Transoral Robotic Surgery (TORS). For TORS, the paper illustrates how each of the five principles can be addressed:

  • Health and Safety: Designing robots to avoid ableist morphologies and providing termination mechanisms for lost control.
  • Transparency: Ensuring surgeons and patients understand the robot's capabilities and limitations.
  • Data Protection: Informing patients about data collection and ensuring high-level security for surgical data.
  • Predictability: Ensuring predictable robot behavior is crucial for accountability in case of surgical accidents.
  • Ethical Approval: While less directly applicable to the TORS procedure itself, the principle emphasizes the need for ethical review for any novel uses or research involving the technology.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the paper provides a framework and a case study, but further work is needed to fully operationalize and validate the proposed code of ethics. The paper suggests that a concise ethical risk assessment should be applied to robotic products and services. This assessment would involve all stakeholders (users, engineers, vendors) to ensure robotic technology is truly beneficial to human society. Future work could involve developing more detailed guidelines for implementing each ethical principle and exploring how to effectively integrate these principles into the design and development lifecycle of robotic systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Robotics is a high technology that integrates various disciplines such as computer engineering, artificial intelligence, mechanics, bionics, and so forth. Due to its interdisciplinary nature, multiple fields such as engineering, medical, computer and Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) are reviewed in order to satisfy the objective that to develop a code of ethics for robotics. For the main outcomes of the paper, a code of ethics that combines multiple fields is produced. In total, there are five essential ethical principles that are outlined in the code of ethics. In addition, the paper also proposes the idea that there can be a concise ethical risk assessment to apply to any robotic product or service in order for any stakeholders to intervene in time to calibrate its ethical value, such that the robotic technology can truly be beneficial to human society.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2022code,
  author = {Yun Zhou},
  title = {{Code of Ethics: A Transoral Robotic Surgery Case Study}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Wellington Faculty of Engineering Ethics and Sustainability Symposium},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.26686/wfeess.vi.7661},
}
Figure