CODC: A copula based model to identify differential coexpression

Sumanta Ray, Snehalika Lall, Sanghamitra BandyopadhyaybioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces CODC, a novel method using copulas to identify differential coexpression between gene pairs across different conditions. CODC models the dependency structure of gene expression and uses the distance between these structures as a measure of differential coexpression, outperforming existing methods and demonstrating robustness to noisy data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how gene expression patterns change between different biological states (e.g., normal vs. disease) is crucial for uncovering disease mechanisms and identifying biomarkers. Gene coexpression analysis, which looks at how genes' expression levels rise and fall together, is a key tool for this. However, existing methods often rely on simple correlation differences, which can miss subtle changes in the dependence structure between genes. This paper addresses the challenge of accurately identifying these subtle, yet biologically significant, shifts in how gene pairs are coexpressed, especially in the presence of noisy biological data.

Methods

The core of CODC lies in its use of copulas. Copulas are powerful statistical tools that allow us to model the dependence structure between random variables separately from their individual distributions (marginals).

Here's how CODC works:

  1. Empirical Copula for Dependency: For each gene pair and each condition (e.g., normal vs. tumor), CODC constructs an empirical copula. This effectively models the joint distribution of their expression profiles, capturing their dependency.
  2. Distance as Differential Coexpression: The key innovation is measuring the "differential coexpression" of a gene pair by calculating a statistical distance (specifically, the Kolmogorov-Smirnov distance) between the two copula-based joint distributions derived from the two conditions. A larger distance signifies a more significant change in their coexpression pattern.
  3. Module Identification: After calculating these differential coexpression scores for all gene pairs, CODC employs hierarchical clustering on the resulting distance matrix to identify groups of genes (modules) that exhibit coordinated differential coexpression.
  4. Robustness: A significant advantage of CODC is its inherent robustness to noisy data, stemming from the "scale-invariant" property of copulas. This means that even if the underlying gene expression data is noisy, the method can still reliably detect differential coexpression.

Datasets

The proposed CODC method was evaluated using five publicly available pan-cancer RNA-Seq datasets from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) data portal:

  • Breast invasive carcinoma (BRCA)
  • Head and Neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSC)
  • Liver hepatocellular carcinoma (LIHC)
  • Thyroid carcinoma (THCA)
  • Lung Adenocarcinoma (LUAD)

These datasets consist of matched normal and tumor samples, allowing for direct comparison of gene expression patterns between the two states.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Correlation Differences: The most significant insight is the move from simply comparing correlation coefficients to modeling and comparing the entire dependence structure using copulas. This allows for the detection of more nuanced changes in coexpression.
  • Sensitivity to Subtle Changes: CODC's ability to detect "mild changes" in coexpression patterns is a crucial advantage, as these subtle shifts might be biologically important but missed by less sensitive methods.
  • Inherent Noise Robustness: The scale-invariant property of copulas makes CODC naturally robust to noisy biological data, a common challenge in transcriptomics. This is a major practical benefit.
  • Module-Level Insights: By extending the analysis to module identification, CODC provides a higher-level view of coordinated changes in gene expression networks, which can be more informative than individual gene pair analysis.

Key Results

  • Outperforms State-of-the-Art: CODC demonstrated superior performance compared to existing methods (DiffCoex, CoXpress, DiffCoMO) across five pan-cancer datasets, particularly in detecting differential coexpression.
  • Improved Classification Accuracy: When used to classify samples based on differentially coexpressed gene pairs, CODC achieved higher accuracy compared to competing methods.
  • Robustness to Noise: Simulations showed that CODC maintains a high percentage of correctly identified differentially coexpressed gene pairs even with significant levels of added noise.
  • Meaningful Biological Modules: The identified differentially coexpressed modules were enriched with biologically relevant pathways and Gene Ontology (GO) terms, suggesting that CODC effectively captures biologically meaningful patterns. For example, pathways like 'Complement and coagulation cascades' and 'Tryptophan metabolism' were strongly associated with BRCA modules.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While not explicitly detailed as a limitation, the use of empirical copulas and hierarchical clustering can be computationally intensive, especially for very large datasets.
  • Extension to Multiple Genes: The paper notes that copulas are inherently multivariate and can be extended to measure the dependence structure of multiple genes, suggesting a natural direction for future work to analyze larger gene networks.
  • Further Validation: While the study uses five pan-cancer datasets, further validation across a wider range of biological contexts and experimental designs could strengthen the findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Differential coexpression has recently emerged as a new way to establish a fundamental difference in expression pattern among a group of genes between two populations. Earlier methods used some scoring techniques to detect changes in correlation patterns of a gene pair in two conditions. However, modeling differential coexpression by mean of finding differences in the dependence structure of the gene pair has hitherto not been carried out. We exploit a copula-based framework to model differential coexpression between gene pair in two different conditions. The Copula is used to model the dependency between expression profiles of a gene pair. For a gene pair, the distance between two joint distributions produced by copula is served as differential coexpression. We used five pan-cancer TCGA RNA-Seq data to evaluate the model which outperforms the existing state-of-the-art. Moreover, the proposed model can detect a mild change in the coexpression pattern across two conditions. For noisy expression data, the proposed method performs well because of the popular scale-invariant property of copula. Additionally, we have identified differentially coexpressed modules by applying hierarchical clustering on the distance matrix. The identified modules are analyzed through Gene Ontology terms and KEGG pathway enrichment analysis.
BibTeX
@misc{ray2019codc,
  author = {Sumanta Ray and Snehalika Lall and Sanghamitra Bandyopadhyay},
  title = {{CODC: A copula based model to identify differential coexpression}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/725887},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure