Cobot Motion Planning Algorithm for Ensuring Human Safety Based on Behavioral Dynamics

Бо Лю, Weiping Fu, Wen Wang, Rui Li, Zhiqiang Gao, Lixia Peng, Huilong DuSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel cobot motion planning algorithm that prioritizes human psychological safety by modeling and mitigating stress caused by robot proximity. By developing a "psychological safety field" and integrating it with behavioral dynamics, the algorithm enables robots to move more "friendly" and reduce human anxiety during human-robot collaboration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As collaborative robots (cobots) become more prevalent in workplaces, ensuring not only the physical safety but also the psychological well-being of human workers is crucial. While existing research has focused on collision avoidance and physical safety standards, there's a significant gap in quantitatively understanding and addressing the psychological stress humans experience due to cobot behavior. This stress can lead to decreased trust, increased mental workload, and reduced efficiency. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a motion planning approach that considers and actively reduces human psychological stress.

Methods

The core of this research lies in developing a Psychological Safety Field (PSF) model. This model is inspired by gravity and traffic safety fields and quantifies human psychological stress as a combination of "potential energy" (from static environments) and "kinetic energy" (from cobot motion).

Key methodological steps include:

  • Quantitative Study of Psychological Stress: A comprehensive experiment was designed to measure human psychological stress (using Skin Conductance Response - SCR) when a cobot approached different body parts (head, chest, abdomen) at various speeds and minimum distances.
  • Psychological Safety Field (PSF) Model Development: Data from the experiments were used to derive equations that model the relationship between cobot approach parameters (speed, distance, body part) and human psychological stress. This resulted in a "psychological safety field formula."
  • Integration with Behavioral Dynamics: The PSF model was integrated as a feedback mechanism into a behavioral dynamics motion planning algorithm. This algorithm, which typically uses attraction to targets and repulsion from obstacles, was enhanced to incorporate the human psychological stress factor.
  • Collision Detection and Speed Adjustment: A system was developed to detect the minimum distance between the cobot and human body parts in real-time and adjust the cobot's speed accordingly, based on social rules and defined personal/intimate zones.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, it introduces a new experimental dataset collected through a controlled experiment involving 41 volunteers. This dataset captures human psychological stress responses (SCR) and physiological signals (EMG) under various cobot approach scenarios (different speeds, distances, and body parts). This experimental setup and the collected data form the basis for developing and validating the PSF model and the improved motion planning algorithm.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quantifying Psychological Stress: The research successfully quantifies the impact of cobot proximity, speed, and approach direction on human psychological stress, moving beyond qualitative observations.
  • The "Psychological Safety Field": The concept of a PSF provides a novel framework for understanding and modeling human emotional responses to cobot actions, treating psychological stress as a field that influences robot behavior.
  • "Friendly" Robot Behavior: The improved algorithm leads to cobot movements that are perceived as more "friendly" by humans, suggesting that considering psychological factors can significantly enhance human-robot interaction.
  • Beyond Physical Safety: This work highlights the critical need to address psychological well-being in HRC, recognizing that it's as important as physical safety for successful collaboration.

Key Results

  • Reduced Psychological Stress: The validation experiments demonstrated that the proposed improved motion planning algorithm significantly reduced participants' psychological stress compared to a standard algorithm. This was evidenced by lower mean values in valence and arousal ratings, and notably, lower EMG signal metrics (mean, max, variance, RMS, iEMG).
  • Improved Human Perception: 87.1% of participants found the robot's movements planned by the improved algorithm to be more "friendly" and effective in reducing psychological stress.
  • Effective Collision Avoidance: The improved algorithm allowed the robot to avoid participants with a larger avoidance angle and reduced speed, contributing to a less stressful experience.
  • Statistical Significance: A one-way ANOVA confirmed a significant difference in psychological stress reduction between the improved and unimproved algorithms, with a confidence level of 96.59%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Participant Demographics: The psychological safety field law experiment was limited by a concentrated age range of participants (20-30 years old) and a lack of older participants. The authors acknowledge that personality, age, and experience can influence psychological stress and suggest that parameter adjustments (like kr) can help accommodate these differences.
  • Experimental Environment: The validation experiments were conducted in a quiet laboratory setting, which may not fully replicate the conditions of a factory environment with higher workloads and noise. The authors suggest adjusting parameters (λtar, λv) to better suit factory settings.
  • Future Research: The authors plan to focus on adjusting the motion algorithm to better fit populations with different personalities. They also mention that further research results have been published in Chinese journals, implying ongoing work in this area.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently, the safety of workers has gained increasing attention due to the applications of collaborative robots (cobot). However, there is no quantitative research on the impact of cobot behavior on humans' psychological reactions, and these results are not applied to the cobot motion planning algorithms. Based on the concept of the gravity field, this paper proposes a model of the psychological safety field (PSF), designs a comprehensive experiment on different speeds and minimum distances when approaching the head, chest, and abdomen, and obtains the ordinary surface equation of psychological stress about speed and minimum distance by using data fitting. By combining social rules and PSF models, we improve the robot motion planning algorithm based on behavioral dynamics. The validation experiment results show that our proposed improved robot motion planning algorithm can effectively reduce psychological stress. Eighty-seven point one percent (87.1%) of the experimental participants think that robot motion planned by improved robot motion planning algorithms is more "friendly", can effectively reduce psychological stress, and is more suitable for human-robot interaction scenarios.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{2022cobot,
  author = {Бо Лю and Weiping Fu and Wen Wang and Rui Li and Zhiqiang Gao and Lixia Peng and Huilong Du},
  title = {{Cobot Motion Planning Algorithm for Ensuring Human Safety Based on Behavioral Dynamics}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22124376},
}
Figure