Coastal Forests and Groundwater: Using Case Studies to Understand the Effects of Drivers and Stressors for Resource Management

Timothy J. Callahan, Devendra M. Amatya, Peter StoneSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the critical role of shallow groundwater in supporting coastal forest ecosystems, particularly in the southeastern U.S. It highlights how changes in water table levels, driven by both natural processes and human activities like development and groundwater extraction, can significantly impact forest health and wetland dynamics. The research emphasizes the urgent need for better data and collaborative management strategies to ensure the sustainability of these vital resources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal regions are experiencing rapid population growth, leading to increased pressure on natural resources, including forests. These forests provide essential ecosystem services, such as water filtration and habitat provision. However, the unique hydrology of coastal plains, characterized by shallow water tables, makes them particularly vulnerable to changes. This paper addresses the challenge of understanding and managing these complex interactions between groundwater, forest ecosystems, and human development. Specifically, it aims to:

  • Quantify the impact of groundwater dynamics: How do fluctuations in the shallow water table, influenced by precipitation, evapotranspiration, and human activities, affect coastal forest health and wetland function?
  • Identify key drivers and stressors: What are the primary factors (natural and anthropogenic) that influence groundwater levels and, consequently, forest ecosystems?
  • Inform resource management: How can this understanding be translated into effective strategies for managing coastal forest resources in the face of increasing development and climate change?

The paper focuses on case studies from the Francis Marion National Forest in South Carolina, a region representative of many coastal plain environments facing similar challenges.

Methods

The paper is primarily a review and synthesis of existing research, drawing on two decades of studies in the Francis Marion National Forest and surrounding areas. It integrates information from:

  • Hydrological monitoring: Data from piezometers and stream gauges were used to track water table fluctuations, streamflow, and temperature.
  • Geological surveys: Information on soil types, aquifer characteristics, and geological formations was utilized to understand groundwater flow pathways and storage.
  • Ecological studies: Existing research on forest types, wetland characteristics, and vegetation responses to hydrological conditions was incorporated.
  • Conceptual modeling: The paper presents conceptual diagrams to illustrate the complex interactions between groundwater, surface water, and forest ecosystems under different scenarios (e.g., natural conditions vs. groundwater pumping).
  • Literature review: A comprehensive review of published research on coastal hydrology, forest ecosystems, and the impacts of human activities was conducted.

While not introducing novel experimental methods, the paper's strength lies in its synthesis of diverse data and its application to a specific, vulnerable ecosystem.

Datasets

The paper references data collected from various sources, primarily related to the Francis Marion National Forest and the Turkey Creek watershed in South Carolina. These include:

  • Water level and temperature data: Collected from streambed wells and nested piezometers over several years (e.g., 2006-present).
  • Precipitation data: Recorded from meteorological stations.
  • Evapotranspiration (ET) estimates: Derived from water table fluctuation methods and eddy covariance measurements.
  • Geological maps and reports: Providing information on aquifer systems, soil types, and stratigraphy.
  • National Wetlands Inventory maps: Used to illustrate the distribution of wetlands.

No new datasets were introduced in this paper; it synthesizes existing data and literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shallow water tables are the norm and critical: Coastal plain forests, especially in the southeastern U.S., are characterized by shallow water tables (<3m) that are fundamental to the existence and function of numerous wetland ecosystems.
  • Small water table shifts have big impacts: Even modest changes in water table depth can lead to significant consequences, ranging from groundwater flooding to ecosystem stress due to drought conditions.
  • Groundwater extraction is a major stressor: Pumping from deeper aquifers, even if seemingly isolated, can have complex and potentially detrimental effects on shallow groundwater systems and the dependent forest ecosystems. The paper highlights the difficulty in accurately assessing these interconnected impacts.
  • Development pressures are multifaceted: Beyond direct groundwater extraction, land use changes like sand mining and urbanization for housing development also stress forest resources and alter hydrological regimes.
  • Forest restoration needs hydrological consideration: Efforts to restore native forest types, such as longleaf pine, must consider their potential impacts on water balance and ET rates, which can differ significantly from current dominant species like loblolly pine.
  • Paleoenvironmental records are vulnerable: Organic-rich wetland sediments hold valuable historical climate and ecological data, but are susceptible to destruction by drainage, fire, or excavation, leading to an irreversible loss of information.
  • Interdisciplinary collaboration is essential: Effective management requires a multidisciplinary approach, integrating hydrology, ecology, geology, and social sciences to understand and address the complex challenges facing coastal forests.

Key Results

The paper does not present specific quantitative results in the form of statistical analyses or model outputs. Instead, it synthesizes findings from previous studies to illustrate key relationships and challenges:

  • Hydrological Sensitivity: Data from the Turkey Creek watershed demonstrates a rapid response of water levels to storm events, indicating the shallow nature of the aquifer and the low specific yield of the soils. A 5mm loss in water can cause a 5cm drop in the water table.
  • ET Flux: Groundwater ET (ETg) rates were estimated to be around 0.8 mm/day in the forested ecosystem during a specific period, highlighting the significant role of vegetation in water withdrawal from shallow groundwater.
  • Aquifer Connectivity: Evidence suggests a tendency for downward leakage from the surficial aquifer to deeper formations like the Santee Limestone, though flow impedance exists. This connectivity is crucial for understanding the impacts of deep aquifer pumping.
  • Drought Impacts: Studies showed that during drought periods, shallow aquifers recovered more quickly from rainfall events than deeper ones, suggesting that storm event water primarily moves into shallow storage or discharges to streams.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Data Gaps: The paper repeatedly emphasizes the need for more comprehensive and long-term data on shallow groundwater dynamics and their interactions with forest ecosystems.
  • Model Uncertainty: While models are used, the paper acknowledges the difficulty in accurately predicting the impacts of groundwater extraction and the potential for misinterpretation, especially regarding aquifer interconnections.
  • Scale of Impact: The precise scale and magnitude of impacts from various stressors, particularly groundwater pumping, are not fully quantified.
  • Local Variability: While case studies are presented, the authors note that local differences in geology, hydrology, and vegetation can lead to unique challenges and require tailored management approaches.

Future Work:

  • Enhanced Hydrological Monitoring: Continued and expanded monitoring of water table levels, streamflow, and ET fluxes is crucial.
  • Improved Modeling: Development and validation of more sophisticated hydrological models that accurately represent shallow groundwater-ecosystem interactions are needed.
  • Investigating Aquifer Connectivity: Further research is required to precisely quantify the hydraulic connections between shallow and deeper aquifers to better predict the impacts of pumping.
  • Ecological Response Studies: More detailed studies are needed to understand how specific forest species and communities respond to varying hydrological conditions and stressors.
  • Long-term Impact Assessments: Research should focus on the long-term effects of groundwater extraction, land use change, and climate variability on coastal forest resilience.
  • Developing Management Tools: The creation of practical tools and guidelines for resource managers to assess and mitigate the risks associated with groundwater changes is essential.
  • Understanding Paleoenvironmental Records: Efforts to preserve and utilize the valuable information contained within wetland sediments are important for understanding long-term ecological processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Forests are receiving more attention for the ecosystem goods and services they provide and the potential change agents that may affect forest health and productivity. Highlighting case examples from coastal forests in South Carolina, USA, we describe groundwater processes with respect to stressors and potential responses of a wetland-rich forested landscape, the roles that this area has served, and the need for water resource data to inform forest management decisions. Forested lands in the southeastern U.S. coastal plain provide a rich set of goods and services for the region, and in one case, the Francis Marion National Forest acts as a buffer to urbanization from the surrounding Charleston metropolitan area. Information from two decades of studies in the forested watersheds there may inform scientists and managers in other coastal forested systems. The common hydrological theme in this region, which has a higher average annual rainfall (1370 mm) than the annual potential evapotranspiration (PET = 1135 mm), is a shallow (&lt;3 m) water table condition that supports a large range of natural wetlands and also creates management challenges across the region. Modest changes in the position of the water table can lead to either groundwater flooding and concomitant management challenges for forest services, or ecosystem stresses related to dry conditions in wetlands during times of below-normal precipitation or due to groundwater withdrawal. Development pressures have also stressed forest resources through the extraction of materials such as timber and sand mining, and the conversion to housing construction materials. These areas are also targeted for land development, to meet housing demands. In this paper, we discuss the role of groundwater in coastal forests and highlight opportunities for collaborative studies to better inform forest resource management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{callahan2017coastal,
  author = {Timothy J. Callahan and Devendra M. Amatya and Peter Stone},
  title = {{Coastal Forests and Groundwater: Using Case Studies to Understand the Effects of Drivers and Stressors for Resource Management}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su9030447},
}
Figure