CO2 Corrosion Behavior of X70 Steel under Typical Gas–Liquid Intermittent Flow

Qiang Li, Wenguang Jia, Kaixiang Yang, Wenfeng Dong, Bingcheng LiuMetals 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the CO2 corrosion of X70 steel in wet gas pipelines, specifically focusing on the complex gas-liquid intermittent flow pattern. Researchers developed a novel testing device to simulate this flow and found that while flow velocity significantly impacts the overall corrosion rate, the gas-liquid ratio plays a crucial role in promoting localized corrosion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pipelines transporting natural gas often encounter "wet gas" conditions, where water and acidic gases like CO2 coexist. This creates a corrosive environment. The flow of this gas-liquid mixture within pipelines isn't uniform; it can manifest as various "flow patterns." One such pattern, gas-liquid intermittent flow, is particularly challenging because its unsteady nature can lead to severe corrosion, including localized pitting. While conventional flow patterns have been studied, the specific influence of intermittent flow on pipeline steel corrosion, especially for high-strength steels like X70, remains poorly understood. This lack of understanding hinders effective corrosion prevention strategies in these critical infrastructure components.

Methods

The researchers developed a custom-built testing apparatus designed to accurately simulate gas-liquid intermittent flow. This device allowed for precise control over temperature, flow velocity, and, crucially, the frequency and ratio of gas and liquid phases. They employed a combination of electrochemical techniques, including:

  • Open Circuit Potential (OCP): To monitor the potential of the steel over time and reach a stable state.
  • Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS): To probe the corrosion mechanism and quantify resistance parameters related to corrosion.
  • Potentiodynamic Polarization: To determine corrosion kinetics and identify anodic and cathodic reaction behaviors.

Following electrochemical testing, the steel samples underwent Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Energy Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDS) to observe and analyze the corrosion morphology and the composition of the corrosion product films.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the custom testing device.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Intermittent Flow is a Distinct Challenge: The unsteady nature of intermittent flow, characterized by alternating bulk liquid and thin water film phases, creates a more complex corrosion environment than steady-state flow.
  • Flow Velocity vs. Gas-Liquid Ratio: The study highlights a critical interplay: flow velocity is the primary driver of the overall corrosion rate, while the gas-liquid ratio dictates the type of corrosion, specifically promoting localized attack.
  • Localized Corrosion Mechanism: The non-uniform formation of protective FeCO3 scale under intermittent flow conditions, especially at higher gas-liquid ratios, creates galvanic cells on the steel surface. This leads to enhanced corrosion in areas lacking the protective film.
  • The "Grey Zone" Effect: The alternating wetting and drying in intermittent flow can create conditions similar to the "grey zone" where corrosion product formation and dissolution are in constant flux, hindering the development of a stable, protective layer.

Key Results

  • Flow Velocity Dominance: Generally, increasing flow velocity led to higher corrosion rates, as evidenced by decreasing charge transfer resistance (Rct) in EIS analysis.
  • Gas-Liquid Ratio Influence:
    • At low flow velocities (0.5 m/s), increasing the gas-liquid ratio consistently increased the corrosion rate.
  • At high flow velocities (2 m/s), the effect of the gas-liquid ratio was more nuanced, with the corrosion rate initially decreasing and then increasing, with the lowest corrosion observed at a 1:1 ratio.
  • Localized Corrosion Trigger: Higher gas-liquid ratios (e.g., 5:1) were consistently associated with the promotion of localized corrosion, characterized by deeper, non-uniformly distributed craters, regardless of flow velocity.
  • Corrosion Product Morphology: SEM analysis revealed that at higher gas-liquid ratios, corrosion products were more porous and unevenly distributed, facilitating localized attack. In contrast, lower gas-liquid ratios (or full immersion) showed more uniform, albeit sometimes cracked, corrosion product layers.
  • Correlation Analysis: Spearman correlation analysis indicated that flow velocity had a more profound negative correlation with Rct (and thus corrosion rate) than the gas-liquid ratio.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Gas-Liquid Ratios: The study explored a specific range of gas-liquid ratios (5:1, 2:1, 1:1, 0:1). Further investigation into a wider range of ratios could provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Specific Steel Grade: The study focused on X70 steel. Future work could explore the behavior of other pipeline steel grades under similar conditions.
  • Flow Pattern Nuances: While "intermittent flow" was simulated, the paper acknowledges that real-world pipelines can exhibit more complex flow regimes. Further research could delve into the impact of transitions between different flow patterns.
  • Long-Term Effects: The experiments were conducted over 12 hours. Long-term studies would be valuable to understand the evolution of corrosion products and their protective capabilities over extended periods.
  • Inhibition Strategies: The findings on localized corrosion mechanisms could inform the development of targeted corrosion inhibitors or mitigation strategies for intermittent flow conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Gas–liquid intermittent flow is a kind of flow pattern that distinguishes itself from the conventional flow by the apparent non-steady feature, which causes serious corrosion issues, including localized corrosion. Although it widely exists in wet gas pipelines, how the gas–liquid intermittent flow influences CO2 corrosion of pipeline steels remains a problem to be clarified. In this work, a testing device that enables good simulation of gas–liquid intermittent flow in wet gas pipelines under various conditions was developed and used to perform experimental studies, combining electrochemical tests and corrosion morphology observations. The result shows that flow velocity and gas–liquid ratio act together to affect the CO2 corrosion behavior of X70 steel in typical intermittent flow conditions. The flow velocity has a more profound effect on the corrosion rate, while the gas–liquid ratio is associated with the occurrence of localized corrosion. The effect of the gas–liquid ratio on corrosion behavior was discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023co,
  author = {Qiang Li and Wenguang Jia and Kaixiang Yang and Wenfeng Dong and Bingcheng Liu},
  title = {{CO2 Corrosion Behavior of X70 Steel under Typical Gas–Liquid Intermittent Flow}},
  booktitle = {Metals},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/met13071239},
}
Figure