CO Oxidation on Pt-Group Metals from Ultrahigh Vacuum to Near Atmospheric Pressures. 2. Palladium and Platinum

Feng Gao, Yuhao Wang, Yun Cai, D. Wayne GoodmanThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates CO oxidation on palladium and platinum surfaces across a wide pressure range, revealing distinct reaction regimes. Crucially, it debunks claims of superior oxide reactivity, demonstrating that a transient, oxygen-rich metallic state is actually the most active phase, and that oxide formation can lead to reduced reactivity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The catalytic oxidation of carbon monoxide (CO) by oxygen (O2) is a fundamental reaction in many industrial processes, including automotive catalytic converters. Understanding how this reaction behaves across different pressures is critical for designing efficient catalysts. Previous studies had proposed that certain oxidized forms of platinum group metals, specifically platinum oxides, exhibited superior catalytic activity compared to their metallic counterparts. This "superior oxide reactivity" hypothesis, if true, would significantly alter our understanding of catalytic mechanisms. This paper aims to resolve this discrepancy by systematically studying CO oxidation on well-defined palladium and platinum single crystal surfaces under both ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) and near-atmospheric pressure conditions, directly challenging the oxide hypothesis.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) surface science techniques and high-pressure reaction studies.

  • Low-Pressure Studies (UHV):
    • CO Oxidation Experiments: Single crystal surfaces of Pd(100), Pd(111), Pd(110), and Pt(110) were exposed to O2/CO mixtures at pressures up to 2 x 10⁻³ Torr.
  • Polarization Modulation Infrared Reflection Absorption Spectroscopy (PM-IRAS): This technique was used to monitor the surface CO coverage and identify different CO species adsorbed on the metal surface by analyzing their vibrational frequencies.
  • High-Pressure Studies (Near-Atmospheric):
    • Batch Reactor Setup: The entire UHV chamber was pressurized with O2/CO mixtures (up to 88 Torr).
  • Baratron Manometer: Used to measure the total gas pressure change, from which the CO2 formation rate (turnover frequency, TOF) was calculated.
  • PM-IRAS: Continuously monitored surface CO species during high-pressure reactions.
  • Sample Placement: Experiments were conducted with the sample inside an infrared cell and also in the main chamber to investigate the influence of mass transport.

The key innovation here is the seamless integration of low- and high-pressure studies on well-defined single crystals, allowing for a direct comparison and the identification of pressure-dependent phenomena like mass transfer limitations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on in situ measurements of reaction rates and surface species rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No "Pressure Gap": The study demonstrates a continuous transition in CO oxidation behavior from low to high pressures, refuting the existence of a "pressure gap" where reaction mechanisms drastically change.
  • The "Hyperactive" State: A transient, oxygen-rich metallic state is identified as the most active phase for CO oxidation, leading to high reaction rates. This state is characterized by very low surface CO coverage.
  • Debunking Oxide Superiority: The paper provides strong evidence against the notion that oxidized platinum group metals are superior catalysts for CO oxidation. Instead, oxide formation on palladium was observed to reduce reactivity.
  • Three Distinct Reaction Regimes: At high pressures, three regimes are consistently observed:
  • CO-inhibited metallic regime: Low reaction rates due to CO blocking active sites.
  • Transient, oxygen-rich metallic regime: Very high reaction rates, limited by oxygen availability for adsorption.
  • High-temperature regime: Either mass transfer limited or limited by the reduced reactivity of an oxidized surface.
  • Mass Transfer is Crucial: The authors repeatedly emphasize the significant role of mass transfer limitations, especially at higher pressures, which can be easily overlooked and lead to erroneous conclusions.
  • Structure Insensitivity (Mostly): For stoichiometric and mildly oxidizing conditions, the reaction rates on different Pd and Pt facets are similar, suggesting a "structure insensitive" reaction, largely controlled by CO desorption. However, under heavily oxidizing conditions, differences emerge.

Key Results

  • Low Pressure: CO inhibition (but not O inhibition) was observed. Optimized CO conversion reached ~40% and was independent of the O2/CO ratio at pressures below ~1 x 10⁻⁴ Torr. Surface CO coverage was extremely low (<0.01 ML) when the reaction rate maximized.
  • High Pressure (Pd):
    • Three regimes were clearly identified.
  • A transient high-rate regime (regime ii) with TOF up to ~1600 was observed.
  • Oxidation of Pd was evidenced by the appearance of new CO species at 2142 and 2087 cm⁻¹ in the third regime, and this oxide phase showed lower reactivity than the metallic surface.
  • Circumventing mass transfer (e.g., by placing the sample in the main chamber) led to significantly higher TOFs (~7700 at 1150 K) on the metallic surface.
  • High Pressure (Pt):
    • Similar three regimes were observed.
  • Crucially, no evidence of Pt oxidation (no new CO species indicative of oxides) was found under the studied conditions, even at high O2/CO ratios. This directly contradicts previous claims of Pt oxide superiority.
  • At conditions where Frenken et al. claimed to observe superior oxide reactivity on Pt(110) (425 K, high O2/CO), this study found the Pt surface to be fully covered by CO with a barely measurable reaction rate.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Transient Regime Characterization: The second, high-rate regime is very short-lived (<1 min), making detailed spectroscopic characterization challenging. The authors used rapid scanning PM-IRAS to capture some data but acknowledge the difficulty.
  • Nature of the Oxidized Phase: While Pd oxidation was detected, the precise composition, structure, and thickness of the surface oxide phase remain uncertain. The authors tentatively suggest a 3D surface oxide.
  • Pt Oxidation Conditions: The paper notes that Pt surface oxides have been reported at much higher temperatures (625 K) and pressures than those used in the Frenken et al. studies. Further investigation into the specific conditions required for stable Pt oxide formation and their catalytic activity is warranted.
  • Structure Sensitivity: While largely structure insensitive under mild conditions, the authors suggest that the second regime might exhibit some structure sensitivity, which could be a direction for future research.
  • Mass Transfer Mitigation: The paper highlights methods to mitigate mass transfer limitations (e.g., sample placement, reduced sample size) and suggests further exploration of these strategies to access intrinsic kinetic data.

Summary updated

Abstract

CO oxidation on Pd(100), -(111), -(110), and Pt(110) single crystals was studied at steady-state conditions at low (≤2 × 10−3 Torr) and high (2−88 Torr) pressures at various reactant compositions. At low pressures the reaction fell into two regimes, one with a CO-dominant surface where the CO2 formation rate is low, and a second with an O-dominant surface where the reaction rate is high. Within this second regime, the reaction is collision-limited with no oxygen inhibition. Under high-pressure reaction conditions, three reaction regimes are evident: (i) a CO-inhibited metallic regime displaying a low CO2 formation rate; (ii) an oxygen-rich metallic regime with a high CO2 formation rate; and (iii) a high-temperature regime where the CO2 formation rate is either mass transfer limited on a metallic surface or limited by the reduced reactivity of the oxidized surface. The superior activity of Pt group metal oxides compared to the reduced metal, as proposed recently, was not observed in this study.
BibTeX
@article{gao2008co,
  author = {Feng Gao and Yuhao Wang and Yun Cai and D. Wayne Goodman},
  title = {{CO Oxidation on Pt-Group Metals from Ultrahigh Vacuum to Near Atmospheric Pressures. 2. Palladium and Platinum}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1021/jp8077985},
}
Figure