TL;DR
This paper proposes a new framework for "asymmetric co-creativity" where only the computer is expected to be creative in a dialogue system. It defines this by breaking down co-operative creativity into message, contextual, and communicative aspects, and applies it to the "Peace Machine" concept for fostering better human communication.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper addresses a gap in the field of human-computer creativity. Existing research often assumes creativity from both human and computer in co-creative systems. However, many practical applications, like dialogue systems designed to assist users, don't require the human to be creative. Instead, the computer needs to be creative in how it conveys information or helps the user achieve a goal. This paper aims to define and model this "asymmetric" form of co-creativity, where the computational agent is the primary creative party, while the human user is simply cooperating.
Methods
The authors propose a theoretical framework for asymmetric co-creativity by drawing on interdisciplinary perspectives, particularly from pragmatics and cognitive science. They break down co-operative creativity into three key components:
- Message Creativity: How the computer creatively expresses its intended message. This is further divided into creativity in denotation (the core meaning) and connotation (the style and emotional impact).
- Contextual Creativity: How the computer adapts its communication based on the user and the ongoing conversation. This includes user adaptation, role identification, and time perspective.
- Communicative Creativity: How the computer adheres to or creatively deviates from the principles of co-operative conversation (Grice's maxims: manner, quality, quantity, relevance).
This framework is then applied to the "Peace Machine" concept, a system designed to promote peaceful communication.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Asymmetric Co-Creativity: The core idea is that creativity isn't always a two-way street in human-computer interaction. Dialogue systems often need to be creative for the user, not with the user in a reciprocal creative sense.
- The "Peace Machine" as a Testbed: This concept provides a concrete application for the theoretical framework, highlighting how creative communication can be used to de-escalate conflict and foster understanding.
- Creativity within Constraints: The paper emphasizes that even within the strict rules of co-operative conversation (Grice's maxims), there's significant room for computational creativity. This involves finding novel ways to express messages, adapt to context, and even strategically deviate from conversational norms.
- Denotation vs. Connotation: The distinction between the literal meaning (denotation) and the stylistic/emotional aspect (connotation) is crucial for understanding how a system can be creative without altering the core message. For example, conveying a price can be done creatively through its phrasing.
- The Importance of Context and User Modeling: Understanding the user's background, preferences, and the current conversational situation is key to enabling creative and effective communication.
Key Results
This paper is primarily theoretical and proposes a framework rather than presenting empirical results from experiments or datasets. The "key results" are the conceptual insights and the developed framework itself. The paper demonstrates how the proposed framework can be applied to the Peace Machine concept, illustrating potential areas for computational creativity in message, context, and communication.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the Peace Machine concept is ambitious and its implementation is complex. They note that while the framework is presented, its practical application and evaluation require further development. Specifically, they mention that:
- The framework needs to be tested in various settings to validate the hypotheses about user adaptation.
- Accurately assessing and incorporating the non-linguistic context in human-like ways remains a challenge.
- The practical implementation of creative deviations from conversational maxims requires careful consideration to avoid unintended negative consequences.
Future work would likely involve building and evaluating systems based on this framework, particularly within the Peace Machine context, to empirically test its effectiveness in promoting co-operative and creative communication.
Summary updated