CO in MASsive Spirals (CO-MASS): an IRAM 30m CO emission line survey of the CGM-MASS sample

Yu Huang, Jiangtao Li, Yan Jiang, Ping Zhou, Jianghui Xu, Liyuan Lu, Yang YangarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

There exist extremely massive spiral galaxies in isolated environments, with stellar masses several times that of the Milky Way, yet their star formation rates (SFRs) are comparable to or even lower than that of the Milky Way. In this paper, we investigate the molecular gas properties of such galaxies to better understand the origin of their low SFRs. We present IRAM 30m CO observations of five extremely massive spirals from the CGM-MASS sample. We compare their star formation efficiencies (SFEs) with the Kennicutt-Schmidt relation and find that these massive spirals generally exhibit low efficiency in converting molecular gas into stars. We further compare their molecular gas masses with their atomic gas and stellar masses, and also include the CHANG-ES sample galaxies observed with the IRAM 30m telescope in a similar manner for comparison. Our sample galaxies show low efficiency in converting atomic to molecular gas and have lower molecular gas fractions, suggesting that their suppressed star formation stems from both limited gas supply and inefficient star formation. Considering potential cold gas sources in massive spirals, we argue that their current reservoirs likely originate from past starburst or merger events rather than ongoing accretion in present isolated environments. Finally, we examine the location of these galaxies on the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation, finding them baryon-deficient and deviating from the trend of lower-mass galaxies. This suggests either a significant undetected baryonic component or a flattening/turnover of the relation at the high-mass end, consistent with the stellar mass-halo mass relation.

Introduction: The Mystery of "Gentle Giants"

In the local universe, most massive galaxies follow a predictable path: they are typically "red and dead" ellipticals. However, a rare population of "super-spirals" challenges this paradigm. These isolated galaxies possess stellar masses several times that of the Milky Way while maintaining their spiral structure. Despite their immense size, their star formation rates (SFRs) are surprisingly low—comparable to or even lower than the Milky Way’s.

This study addresses whether this "laziness" is a supply problem (a lack of cold molecular gas) or an efficiency problem (an inability to convert existing gas into stars). By surveying carbon monoxide (CO) emission, the authors map the molecular gas reservoirs of these giants to determine what quenches their cosmic engines.

Methodology and Data

The CO-MASS survey targeted five isolated massive spirals from the CGM-MASS sample: UGCA 145, NGC 550, UGC 12591, NGC 669, and NGC 5908. Observations were conducted using the IRAM 30m telescope, detecting $^{12}$CO $J=1–0$ and $J=2–1$ emission lines as proxies for molecular hydrogen ($H_2$).

Because single-dish observations only cover specific regions, the team utilized WISE 22 $\mu$m infrared data to scale local measurements to the total molecular gas mass of the entire galaxy. For comparison, they included the CHANG-ES sample, representing "normal" star-forming edge-on galaxies. Ancillary atomic hydrogen (HI) data from the ALFALFA survey and literature provided a complete picture of the total gas budgets.

Results: The Double Whammy of Inefficiency

The survey revealed that these massive spirals suffer from a "double whammy" of star formation suppression. First, they exhibit low efficiency in converting atomic (HI) gas into molecular ($H_2$) fuel. Second, they are significantly less efficient at turning that molecular fuel into stars.

The Kennicutt-Schmidt relation showing the low star formation efficiency of the CGM-MASS sample compared to the CHANG-ES sample.

As shown in the Kennicutt-Schmidt (K-S) relation, these galaxies deviate significantly from the standard trend. Their gas depletion timescales are nearly an order of magnitude longer than normal—approximately 10 billion years compared to the typical 2 billion years. Furthermore, the $R_{21}$ line ratios (the ratio between $J=2-1$ and $J=1-0$ transitions) were generally below 0.7, suggesting the molecular gas is cold and diffuse, residing in the outer envelopes of clouds rather than dense, star-forming cores.

Discussion: Morphological Quenching and Baryon Deficiencies

The authors propose morphological quenching as a primary driver for this inefficiency. The massive central bulges of these galaxies likely stabilize the gas disks against the gravitational instabilities required for star formation.

Gas fraction (HI + H2) relative to stellar mass, highlighting the baryon deficiency in massive spirals.

Analysis of the gas fractions relative to stellar mass reveals that these galaxies are "baryon-deficient." When plotted on the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation, they fall below the expected trend for lower-mass galaxies. This suggests they either lost significant gas during their evolution or possess a large reservoir of "hidden" warm/hot gas currently undetectable by radio and millimeter telescopes. Given their isolation, current gas reservoirs are likely "leftovers" from ancient mergers or starburst events, as calculated "hot-mode" accretion rates from the halo are insufficient to replenish the consumed gas.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The CO-MASS survey indicates that the suppressed star formation in extremely massive spirals stems from both limited gas supply and inefficient conversion processes. While the sample size is small, the results provide a compelling look at galaxy evolution at the high-mass end. Future high-resolution observations with interferometers like ALMA or NOEMA are essential to map the spatial distribution of gas and confirm the role of morphological quenching. Additionally, deeper HI mapping may reveal the "missing baryons" in extended, low-density envelopes.

Summary updated

Abstract

There exist extremely massive spiral galaxies in isolated environments, with stellar masses several times that of the Milky Way, yet their star formation rates (SFRs) are comparable to or even lower than that of the Milky Way. In this paper, we investigate the molecular gas properties of such galaxies to better understand the origin of their low SFRs. We present IRAM 30m CO observations of five extremely massive spirals from the CGM-MASS sample. We compare their star formation efficiencies (SFEs) with the Kennicutt-Schmidt relation and find that these massive spirals generally exhibit low efficiency in converting molecular gas into stars. We further compare their molecular gas masses with their atomic gas and stellar masses, and also include the CHANG-ES sample galaxies observed with the IRAM 30m telescope in a similar manner for comparison. Our sample galaxies show low efficiency in converting atomic to molecular gas and have lower molecular gas fractions, suggesting that their suppressed star formation stems from both limited gas supply and inefficient star formation. Considering potential cold gas sources in massive spirals, we argue that their current reservoirs likely originate from past starburst or merger events rather than ongoing accretion in present isolated environments. Finally, we examine the location of these galaxies on the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation, finding them baryon-deficient and deviating from the trend of lower-mass galaxies. This suggests either a significant undetected baryonic component or a flattening/turnover of the relation at the high-mass end, consistent with the stellar mass-halo mass relation.
BibTeX
@misc{huang2025co,
  author = {Yu Huang and Jiangtao Li and Yan Jiang and Ping Zhou and Jianghui Xu and Liyuan Lu and Yang Yang},
  title = {{CO in MASsive Spirals (CO-MASS): an IRAM 30m CO emission line survey of the CGM-MASS sample}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2510.16441},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.16441},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure