Co-design: a novel approach to create value-added products in the creative fashion industry

Colin Gale, Gaopeng Zhang, Yu ShiJournal of Textile Engineering & Fashion Technology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Additional value creation is a critical characteristic of innovative products. Co-design is regarded as an effective approach to creating additional experience value through customer engagement in the product development process. It does not only benefit the comprehension of customer desires but also the inspiration for creating and increasing customer loyalty. However, some barriers may exist in value-creation chains in many creative industries, such as the designer-driven product design, forecast-based marketing, homogeneity of products, long product and development cycles, mass production and so forth. As a typical creation-intensive industry, the fashion industry is focused on in this paper to be surveyed in terms of practices of co-design. This paper has analysed the co-design practices in the fashion industry in terms of market research, design model and manufacturing. Several practitioners who implement co-design strategy in fashion product development have been observed and analysed from the perspective of the value creation chain. The study result demonstrates that customer involvement, co-creating design method, collaborative product development mechanism are the essential aspects of the implementation of co-design in the fashion industry.

Introduction

The traditional fashion industry is currently grappling with a "production-oriented" model. This legacy approach is characterized by designer-driven trends, long development cycles, and a resulting homogeneity of products. In the competitive landscape of the 21st century, simply offering a specific aesthetic style or basic functional technology is no longer sufficient to maintain a market advantage.

Modern consumers have become increasingly sophisticated; they no longer seek passive consumption but rather "enjoyable experiences" and "self-fulfillment." This shift necessitates a transition from being purely designer-driven to being value-driven. This paper explores "co-design"—the collaborative creation between designers and customers—as a strategic framework to bridge the gap between traditional manufacturing and the modern need for "value-added" products.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

To analyze the impact of co-design, the study employs a qualitative case study methodology, drawing on several key theoretical models to categorize product value and consumer creativity.

The Value Positioning Map

Central to the analysis is Cagan and Vogel’s Breakthrough Product Theory. This theory posits that breakthrough products are those that successfully integrate high levels of both style and technology to create significant value for the user. Products are categorized into four quadrants based on these two axes: Cost-driven, Style-driven, Tech-driven, and Breakthrough (high style, high technology, and high value).

The Value Positioning Map categorizes products based on the intensity of style and technology, highlighting the 'Breakthrough' quadrant of high value.

Levels of Creativity

The research also utilizes Sanders and Stappers’ framework for levels of creativity, which classifies customer involvement into four distinct types: Doing (product use), Adapting (modifying for a need), Making (building from components), and Creating (generating new ideas from scratch). By applying these models to corporate case studies including DKNY, Issey Miyake, IC3D, and Threadless, the paper identifies how co-design disrupts traditional value chains.

Key Insights: Beyond "Form Follows Function"

A primary insight of this research is the rejection of the post-industrial adage "form follows function." In the modern era, breakthrough products must fulfill a "higher value state" where form and function are integrated to meet emotional and experiential "wants" rather than just utilitarian "needs."

Co-design acts as a value chain disruptor by injecting customer input at various stages:

  • The "Fuzzy Front End": Involving customers in the earliest design stages allows for qualitative research that identifies "value opportunity gaps" before prototyping begins.
  • Mass Customization Efficiency: Modularizing components allows companies to provide customized value (e.g., bespoke fit) without sacrificing the cost-efficiencies of mass production.

Implementation Models in Fashion

The study identifies four successful models of co-design currently practiced in the industry:

  1. Convertible Clothing (e.g., DKNY "Cozy"): This model allows users to "re-design" their garment post-purchase. A single item can be worn in multiple ways, satisfying the desire for creative self-expression while offering economic value.
  2. Semi-Manufactured Design (e.g., Issey Miyake’s A-POC): Utilizing computer-controlled knitting, this process creates a "tube" of fabric that customers cut and shape themselves. This provides a sense of self-achievement and a unique "experience value."
  3. Online Mass Customization (e.g., IC3D): Bespoke platforms allow users to select specific fabrics, shapes, and fits. This creates high functional value through personalization while maintaining industrial efficiency.
  4. Crowdsourcing (e.g., Threadless): By using "collective intelligence" to vote on or submit designs, brands can identify market hits before production. This significantly reduces inventory risk and builds intense brand loyalty.

Challenges and Future Directions

Despite the benefits, several hurdles remain for the widespread adoption of co-design. Traditional firms often suffer from internal silos, where marketing, design, and manufacturing departments fail to collaborate seamlessly. Furthermore, translating the "untrained" desires of customers into technical manufacturing specifications presents a significant communication barrier.

Future research should focus on refining the "criteria system" for evaluating conflicting values (e.g., speed vs. sustainability) and identifying which specific additional values—whether ergonomic, emotional, or social—resonate most strongly with modern consumers.

Conclusion

Co-design offers a robust path for the fashion industry to survive in increasingly competitive markets. By moving toward a collaborative product development mechanism, brands can transition from mass production to mass customization, ensuring that they meet the sophisticated experiential needs of the 21st-century consumer.

Summary updated

Abstract

Additional value creation is a critical characteristic of innovative products. Co-design is regarded as an effective approach to creating additional experience value through customer engagement in the product development process. It does not only benefit the comprehension of customer desires but also the inspiration for creating and increasing customer loyalty. However, some barriers may exist in value-creation chains in many creative industries, such as the designer-driven product design, forecast-based marketing, homogeneity of products, long product and development cycles, mass production and so forth. As a typical creation-intensive industry, the fashion industry is focused on in this paper to be surveyed in terms of practices of co-design. This paper has analysed the co-design practices in the fashion industry in terms of market research, design model and manufacturing. Several practitioners who implement co-design strategy in fashion product development have been observed and analysed from the perspective of the value creation chain. The study result demonstrates that customer involvement, co-creating design method, collaborative product development mechanism are the essential aspects of the implementation of co-design in the fashion industry. The significance of this study is not only to offer an effective approach for the fashion industry to survive in increasingly competitive markets but also to point out the developing direction of the relative creative industries. In the conclusion, the paper suggests that further studies related to co-design need to be addressed and would primarily concern themes about the various additional values for innovative products and services and mass customization in creative industries.
BibTeX
@article{gale2021co,
  author = {Colin Gale and Gaopeng Zhang and Yu Shi},
  title = {{Co-design: a novel approach to create value-added products in the creative fashion industry}},
  journal = {Journal of Textile Engineering \& Fashion Technology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.15406/jteft.2021.07.00280},
}
Figure