Clustering in Polygonal Domains

Mark de Berg, Leyla Biabani, Morteza Monemizadeh, Leonidas TheocharousISAAC 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles clustering problems (like finding optimal locations for facilities) within complex polygonal environments, where movement is restricted by walls and obstacles. They introduce novel algorithms that efficiently solve these problems by adapting existing techniques to the unique challenges of geodesic distances in polygons, achieving significant improvements in runtime.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Imagine you need to place a certain number of emergency response centers (k-medians) or cell towers (k-centers) within a city map that includes buildings and roads, where travel time is determined by the shortest path along roads, not straight lines. This is the essence of clustering in a polygonal domain with geodesic distance. Traditional clustering algorithms often assume free movement in Euclidean space (straight lines). However, real-world scenarios, like robot navigation in warehouses or emergency services in urban areas, require considering obstacles and restricted paths. This paper addresses the challenge of efficiently solving clustering problems (specifically k-median, k-center, and k-center with outliers) in such constrained environments, where the distance between points is measured along shortest paths within the polygon.

Methods

The authors build upon existing algorithms for clustering in Euclidean space and adapt them to the geodesic metric within polygonal domains.

  • Exact Algorithms for k-Median and k-Center with Outliers: They extend a divide-and-conquer approach that uses a "separator theorem" on the dual of the geodesic Voronoi diagram. This involves transforming the diagram into a planar graph structure that allows for efficient splitting of the problem. The key innovation is adapting this technique to handle the complexities of geodesic paths and the potentially non-triangulated dual graph of geodesic Voronoi diagrams. This results in sub-exponential time complexity in k but polynomial in the input size (n and m, the number of points and polygon vertices, respectively).
  • Approximation Algorithms for k-Center: For the k-center problem in a simple polygon, they leverage the concept of "coresets." A coreset is a small subset of the input points that allows for an approximate solution to the original problem. They first develop a coreset for the 1-center problem in a simple polygon, proving its existence and construction time. This technique is then extended to provide a (1+ε)-approximation for the k-center problem.
  • Coresets for 1-Center with Outliers: The paper also introduces coresets for the 1-center problem with outliers in metric spaces, including polygonal domains. They show the existence of a small coreset (size 2z+2) that provides a 3-approximation for the problem with z outliers. Furthermore, for the Euclidean plane, they derive an ε-coreset of size O(z/ε), improving upon existing bounds.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The algorithms are designed to work on a set of n points within a polygonal domain P with m vertices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geodesic Distance is Tricky: The core challenge is that geodesic distances in polygons don't behave as nicely as Euclidean distances. Standard geometric structures like Voronoi diagrams and their duals require careful adaptation.
  • Coresets are Powerful for Approximation: The concept of coresets proves to be a versatile tool for approximating clustering problems, especially when exact solutions are computationally expensive. The paper demonstrates their applicability even in non-Euclidean settings like polygonal domains.
  • Adapting Separator Theorems: The success of the exact algorithms hinges on adapting planar graph separator theorems to the geodesic Voronoi diagram's dual. This involves clever graph transformations to ensure the properties required by the theorems hold.
  • Outliers Add Complexity, but Coresets Help: Handling outliers in clustering is a significant challenge. The paper shows that coresets can effectively manage outliers, providing good approximations with manageable coreset sizes.
  • Geometric Inequalities in Polygons: Proving the coreset properties for the 1-center problem in polygons required developing or adapting geometric inequalities (like a geodesic version of the Pythagorean theorem) that don't directly translate from Euclidean geometry.

Key Results

  • Exact k-Median and k-Center with Outliers: An exact algorithm for discrete k-median and k-center with z outliers in a polygonal domain with complexity m and n points, running in time poly(n, m) + n<sup>o(√k)</sup>.
  • Approximation for k-Center: A (1+ε)-approximation algorithm for the k-center problem in a simple polygon with running time O(2<sup>O(k log k / ε)</sup> (n log m + m)).
  • Coresets for 1-Center with Outliers:
    • A 3-approximation coreset of size O(z) for the 1-center problem with z outliers in any metric space.
  • An ε-coreset of size O(z/ε) for the 1-center problem with z outliers in the Euclidean plane.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subexponential Dependency on k: While the exact algorithms are polynomial in n and m, they still have a subexponential dependency on k (n<sup>o(√k)</sup>). This means they are efficient for small values of k but might become slow for very large k.
  • Approximation Ratios: The coreset for the 1-center problem with outliers in metric spaces provides a 3-approximation. While this is a constant factor, further improvements might be possible.
  • Extension to More Complex Domains: The paper focuses on simple polygons and polygonal domains. Extending these results to more general polygonal regions or environments with more complex obstacle configurations could be a future direction.
  • Practical Implementation: The theoretical bounds are promising, but practical performance on real-world datasets would be an interesting area for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{berg2023clustering,
  author = {Mark de Berg and Leyla Biabani and Morteza Monemizadeh and Leonidas Theocharous},
  title = {{Clustering in Polygonal Domains}},
  booktitle = {ISAAC},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.4230/lipics.isaac.2023.23},
}
Figure