Cloud fraction response to aerosol driven by nighttime processes

Geoffrey Pugsley, Edward Gryspeerdt, Vishnu NairProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the impact of aerosols on marine stratocumulus clouds, a major source of climate uncertainty, is primarily driven by nighttime processes. By analyzing cloud changes over diurnal cycles, the research shows that aerosols influence cloud formation and breakup more significantly at night, setting the stage for daytime cloud behavior and radiative impact. This highlights the critical need for nighttime observations and improved diurnal cycle representation in climate models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aerosol-cloud interactions are a major unknown in climate science, particularly how aerosols affect stratocumulus clouds, which cover vast ocean areas and significantly influence Earth's energy balance. While stratocumulus clouds are strongly influenced by the day-night cycle, most previous research has focused on their daytime behavior. This leaves a gap in understanding how aerosols modulate these clouds over a full 24-hour period, which is crucial for accurately assessing climate forcing and the potential for climate intervention strategies like marine cloud brightening. The paper aims to disentangle the diurnal variations in aerosol-cloud interactions, specifically focusing on cloud fraction (CF) and liquid water path (LWP).

Methods

The researchers employed a novel Lagrangian framework to track air parcels and their associated cloud development over several days. This approach allows for the characterization of cloud changes over shorter timescales than traditional Eulerian methods, providing a more detailed view of diurnal evolution. To isolate the aerosol effect, they used the concentration of cloud condensation nuclei (Nd) as a proxy for aerosol influence. A key methodological innovation is the introduction of "adjusted change" metrics (ACFadj and ALWPadj). These metrics are designed to remove the "regression to the mean" effect, where initial cloud states might statistically influence observed changes, thereby isolating the true impact of aerosol concentration (Nd) on cloud fraction and liquid water path. They specifically analyzed morning and evening satellite observations to capture daytime and nighttime transitions.

Datasets

  • MODIS Terra: Used for retrieving cloud droplet number concentration (Nd) from its ~10:30 LST overpass.
  • GOES-17 ABI (Advanced Baseline Imager): Used for calculating cloud fraction (CF) based on cloud top phase masks. Morning (09:00 LST) and evening (18:00 LST) observations were used to define daytime and nighttime changes.
  • Remote Sensing Systems (RSS) microwave LWP product: Used for liquid water path (LWP) retrievals, chosen for its insensitivity to solar viewing geometry.
  • ERA5 reanalysis wind field: Used for advecting air parcels in the Lagrangian framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nighttime is the Driver: The most significant influence of aerosols on stratocumulus cloud fraction occurs during the nighttime. This is when aerosols appear to promote cloud formation and prevent breakup.
  • Daytime is Less Sensitive: While aerosols do influence daytime cloud processes, their impact on cloud fraction breakup is less pronounced compared to nighttime.
  • Precipitation Suppression is Key: The enhanced aerosol effect at night is likely linked to aerosol-induced suppression of precipitation, which is stronger during nighttime when stratocumulus precipitation is typically more intense.
  • Setting the Morning State: Nighttime cloud processes are crucial for determining the cloud state at the start of the day, which then dictates the daytime cloud evolution and its radiative impact.
  • LWP Thins During the Day, Offset at Night: Aerosols tend to thin clouds (reduce LWP) during the daytime, likely due to enhanced entrainment. However, this thinning effect is partially counteracted by other processes at night.
  • Diurnal Cycle is Crucial for Models: The strong diurnal signal in aerosol-cloud interactions means that climate models need to accurately represent these diurnal cycles to correctly assess aerosol forcing and the effectiveness of climate intervention strategies.

Key Results

  • Cloud Fraction (CF): Adjusted cloud fraction changes (ACFadj) show a much more pronounced increase with increasing aerosol concentration (Nd) during the nighttime compared to the daytime. This suggests aerosols play a more significant role in building up stratocumulus CF at night.
  • Liquid Water Path (LWP): Adjusted LWP changes (ALWPadj) decrease with increasing Nd during the daytime, indicating aerosols thin the cloud. At night, this thinning effect is less pronounced, especially at lower Nd, suggesting precipitation suppression might be offsetting entrainment enhancement.
  • Na-CF Sensitivity: The sensitivity of cloud fraction to aerosol (Nd-CF sensitivity) is observed to be strongest during the nighttime, further supporting the idea that nighttime processes are dominant.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Retrieval Biases: The study acknowledges potential biases in satellite retrievals, particularly for LWP under precipitating conditions and potential saturation issues with the GOES ABI instrument at certain times. However, they argue these artifacts are negligible for the CF measurements used.
  • Lagrangian Advection Uncertainties: While they performed sensitivity tests, accumulated errors in Lagrangian trajectory tracking over extended periods could affect the reliability of aerosol-cloud relationships.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for more nighttime observations of marine clouds. They also call for improved representation of the diurnal cycle in climate models to better constrain aerosol forcing and assess climate intervention strategies like marine cloud brightening. Further research is needed to fully understand the interplay between aerosol-induced precipitation suppression and entrainment enhancement over the diurnal cycle.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aerosol-cloud interactions remain one of the largest uncertainties in the anthropogenic forcing of the climate; a significant contribution to this is due to the aerosol effect on the development of cloud fraction and liquid water path in stratocumulus clouds. Stratocumulus are strongly modulated by the diurnal cycle, but many previous observational studies have primarily focused on the daytime behavior of these clouds. In this work, a Lagrangian framework is used to characterize the day-night variation in the cloud sensitivity to aerosol. It is shown that the cloud fraction response to aerosol is driven by nighttime processes, whereas aerosols play a lesser role in daytime cloud fraction breakup. The liquid water path response reveals that aerosols act to thin the cloud during the daytime; however, this effect is partially offset by other processes during the nighttime. These nighttime cloud processes play an important role in setting the cloud state at the start of the day and hence the daytime cloud evolution, during which stratocumulus clouds have the greatest radiative impact. Our findings are consistent with an aerosol induced suppression of precipitation that acts most effectively at night, when stratocumulus precipitation is strongest. These results highlight a requirement for nighttime observations of marine clouds and an improved representation of the diurnal cycle in model-observation comparisons, especially when assessing climate forcing and the viability of marine cloud brightening.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pugsley2025cloud,
  author = {Geoffrey Pugsley and Edward Gryspeerdt and Vishnu Nair},
  title = {{Cloud fraction response to aerosol driven by nighttime processes}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2509949122},
}
Figure