Closed-Loop Deep Brain Stimulation for Refractory Chronic Pain

Prasad Shirvalkar, Tess L. Veuthey, Heather E. Dawes, Edward F. ChangFrontiers Comput. Neurosci 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel framework for treating chronic pain using closed-loop deep brain stimulation (DBS). By integrating real-time neural biomarkers of pain with control theory, the authors aim to create personalized, adaptive therapies that can dynamically adjust stimulation to disrupt abnormal brain network synchrony underlying chronic pain.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Chronic pain is a debilitating condition affecting millions, often refractory to existing treatments. Current deep brain stimulation (DBS) approaches for pain are largely "open-loop," meaning they deliver continuous, fixed stimulation to a single brain region. This one-size-fits-all approach has yielded mixed results, likely because it fails to account for the complex, multidimensional nature of chronic pain (involving somatosensory, affective, and cognitive components) and the dynamic, individual variability of each patient's pain experience. The authors argue that chronic pain arises from abnormal synchronization between brain networks associated with these dimensions, and that a more sophisticated, adaptive stimulation strategy is needed.

Methods

The paper proposes a theoretical framework for closed-loop DBS for chronic pain, drawing heavily on control theory and neuroscience. Key methodological elements include:

  • Multidimensional Pain State Representation: The authors conceptualize pain as a multidimensional state, influenced by somatosensory, affective, and cognitive inputs. They propose using state-space models, common in control engineering, to represent the dynamic evolution of neural activity across multiple brain regions.
  • Biomarker Identification: They suggest identifying neural biomarkers (specifically local field potentials or LFPs) in key brain regions (S1 for somatosensory, dACC for affective, and OFC for cognitive) that correlate with a patient's subjective pain state.
  • Closed-Loop Control Framework: The core innovation is the application of control theory principles to DBS. This involves:
  • Sensing: Using implanted electrodes to record neural signals (LFPs) from multiple brain regions.
  • Reference Signal: Defining a "pain-free" state as the desired target.
  • Controller: An algorithm that compares the sensed neural signals to the reference state and calculates the necessary stimulation adjustments.
  • Actuator: The DBS device, which delivers stimulation to the brain.
  • Comparison of Stimulation Paradigms: The paper contrasts open-loop, patient-triggered, sensor-triggered, and true closed-loop DBS, arguing that the latter offers the most promising approach for dynamically managing pain states.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a theoretical framework and proposes future experimental protocols, rather than presenting results from a specific dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chronic Pain as Network Dyssynchrony: The central hypothesis is that chronic pain is not simply an overactive signal, but rather an abnormal synchronization between distinct brain networks responsible for different aspects of pain perception.
  • Personalized Medicine for Pain: The authors strongly advocate for a personalized approach, where stimulation is tailored to individual neural signatures of pain, moving beyond the current "one-size-fits-all" model.
  • Leveraging Control Theory: Applying established control engineering principles to neuroscience offers a powerful framework for understanding and intervening in complex brain dynamics like those involved in chronic pain.
  • Multisite Stimulation is Key: To address the multidimensional nature of pain, stimulation needs to target multiple brain regions simultaneously, rather than a single site.
  • LFPs as Tractable Biomarkers: Local field potentials are proposed as a practical and stable signal for identifying pain biomarkers, offering a balance between temporal/spatial resolution and signal reliability.

Key Results

Not applicable, as this paper presents a theoretical framework and does not report experimental results.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Artificial Distinctions: The authors acknowledge that imposing artificial distinctions between somatosensory, affective, and cognitive components of pain is a simplification, as these systems are highly interconnected.
  • DBS as Artificial Input: DBS introduces an artificial input that may drive neural signals into unnatural states, potentially leading to reduced efficacy or side effects. The goal of closed-loop DBS is to keep signals within "natural bounds."
  • Biomarker Stability and Observability: It remains unclear whether hypothesized biomarkers will provide sufficient observability of the internal pain state in chronic pain patients, especially given the lack of chronic invasive recordings in these populations.
  • Computational Demands: Implantable devices need to be optimized for real-time, multi-dimensional state-space computation, which is currently a challenge.
  • Clinical Efficacy Uncertainty: The long-term success of DBS for chronic pain is still uncertain, requiring devices that allow for rapid exploration of stimulation parameters.
  • Future Work: The authors propose a pragmatic protocol for developing closed-loop DBS, including patient-triggered recordings, biomarker identification using LFP signals, and multivariate logistic regression for predicting pain states. They highlight the need for chronic, multi-site sensing and stimulating devices to validate their framework. A clinical trial is mentioned as being underway to develop closed-loop DBS algorithms for chronic neuropathic pain.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{shirvalkar2018closed,
  author = {Prasad Shirvalkar and Tess L. Veuthey and Heather E. Dawes and Edward F. Chang},
  title = {{Closed-Loop Deep Brain Stimulation for Refractory Chronic Pain}},
  journal = {Frontiers Comput. Neurosci.},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fncom.2018.00018},
}
Figure