TL;DR
This study explores using clinician notes in electronic health records (EHRs) to measure patient-centered care (PCC). They found that PCC concepts are documented in clinical notes, and higher documentation is associated with better patient satisfaction scores, suggesting EHR notes could be a scalable tool for assessing PCC delivery.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Patient-centered care (PCC) is a crucial aspect of quality healthcare, emphasizing treating patients as whole individuals and involving them in their care. However, measuring PCC delivery is challenging. Current methods like direct observation or patient surveys are resource-intensive or prone to bias. This paper investigates whether clinical documentation within EHRs can serve as a more scalable and objective measure of PCC. Specifically, they aim to see if PCC concepts are documented and if this documentation correlates with patient satisfaction.
Methods
The researchers selected six VA medical centers, categorizing them by their scores on a patient satisfaction survey subscale related to self-management support. They then focused on clinical notes from patients seeking consultations for weight loss or smoking cessation, as these health issues often require significant behavioral change and self-management.
A team of experienced clinical abstractors was trained to identify specific PCC concepts within these notes. These concepts included:
- Goal intention: Patient's stated goals for their health.
- Mention of caregiver: Any reference to individuals supporting the patient.
- Progress toward goal: Documentation of steps taken towards achieving a goal.
- Provider support for goal progress: Notes indicating the clinician's encouragement or assistance.
- Shared decision-making: Evidence of collaborative decision-making between patient and provider.
- Social context: Information about the patient's social environment.
- Patient voice: Direct quotes or explicit references to the patient's own words.
The study used a consensus approach for coding, where abstractors discussed and resolved any disagreements to ensure consistency. They then analyzed the association between the presence of these documented PCC concepts and the patient satisfaction scores from the Survey for Healthcare Experiences of Patients (SHEP).
Datasets
The study utilized clinical notes from the Electronic Health Record (EHR) of patients at six VA medical centers. Specifically, they accessed notes related to weight loss (MOVE) and tobacco cessation consultations. Patient satisfaction data was obtained from the Survey for Healthcare Experiences of Patients (SHEP), focusing on the self-management support subscale.
Key Insights and Ideas
- EHR notes as a rich source for PCC: The study demonstrates that clinical notes, often considered unstructured data, contain valuable information about PCC. This opens up possibilities for using natural language processing (NLP) to analyze these notes at scale.
- "Patient voice" is frequently documented: The concept of "patient voice" (direct quotes or references to patient statements) was the most commonly documented PCC concept, suggesting clinicians are actively listening to and recording patient perspectives.
- Weight loss notes show stronger PCC correlation: The association between PCC documentation and patient satisfaction was more pronounced for weight loss notes compared to tobacco cessation notes. This might indicate differences in how patients approach these health behaviors or how clinicians document them.
- PCC documentation varies by site: Higher patient satisfaction scores for self-management support at a site were associated with greater documentation of PCC concepts, particularly for weight loss goals.
Key Results
- Out of 311 patients with relevant notes, 201 (64.6%) had at least one PCC concept documented.
- A total of 2434 PCC concepts were identified across 477 clinical notes.
- The most frequently documented PCC concepts were:
- Patient voice (82.1% of patients, 67.7% of notes)
- Patient goals (62.7% of patients, 63.3% of notes)
- Social context (52.2% of patients, 37.9% of notes)
- Provider support for goal progress (61.7% of patients, 40% of notes)
- Shared decision-making and mention of a caregiver were less frequently documented.
- Sites with higher patient satisfaction scores for self-management support showed significantly more documentation of patient goals in weight loss notes compared to lower satisfaction sites.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Satisfaction scores are site-level: The SHEP scores reflect overall site satisfaction, not necessarily the specific provider-patient interactions documented in the notes.
- Interrater reliability: While a consensus approach was used, establishing rigorous interrater reliability would be crucial for scaling up this work.
- Limited demographic data: The inability to access patient demographic information restricted the depth of analysis.
- Narrow note selection: The study focused on specific note types, which might have influenced the findings (e.g., low documentation of shared decision-making).
Future work should focus on:
- Scaling with NLP: Developing and refining NLP tools to automate the identification of PCC concepts in EHR notes.
- Longitudinal studies: Examining PCC documentation over time and across different patient-provider dyads.
- Broader note types: Investigating PCC documentation across a wider range of clinical note types.
- EHR design improvements: Advocating for structured documentation of PCC elements within EHR systems to facilitate both delivery and measurement.
- Investigating tobacco cessation differences: Further research is needed to understand why PCC documentation patterns differ between weight loss and tobacco cessation notes.
Summary updated