Clinical Trial Generalizability Assessment in the Big Data Era: A Review

Zhe He, Xiang D. Tang, Xi Yang, Yi Guo, Thomas J. George, Neil Charness, Kelsa Bartley, William R. Hogan, Jiang BianClinical 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Clinical studies, especially randomized, controlled trials, are essential for generating evidence for clinical practice. However, generalizability is a long-standing concern when applying trial results to real-world patients. Generalizability assessment is thus important, nevertheless, not consistently practiced. We performed a systematic review to understand the practice of generalizability assessment. We identified 187 relevant articles and systematically organized these studies in a taxonomy with three dimensions: (i) data availability (i.e., before or after trial (a priori vs. a posteriori generalizability)); (ii) result outputs (i.e., score vs. nonscore); and (iii) populations of interest. We further reported disease areas, underrepresented subgroups, and types of data used to profile target populations. We observed an increasing trend of generalizability assessments, but < 30% of studies reported positive generalizability results. As a priori generalizability can be assessed using only study design information (primarily eligibility criteria), it gives investigators a golden opportunity to adjust the study design before the trial starts. Nevertheless, < 40% of the studies in our review assessed a priori generalizability. With the wide adoption of electronic health records systems, rich real-world patient databases are increasingly available for generalizability assessment; however, informatics tools are lacking to support the adoption of generalizability assessment practice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2020clinical,
  author = {Zhe He and Xiang D. Tang and Xi Yang and Yi Guo and Thomas J. George and Neil Charness and Kelsa Bartley and William R. Hogan and Jiang Bian},
  title = {{Clinical Trial Generalizability Assessment in the Big Data Era: A Review}},
  booktitle = {Clinical},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1111/cts.12764},
}

Loading related content...

Figure