Clinical practice guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of adult diffuse glioma‐related epilepsy

Shuli Liang, Xing Fan, Ming Zhao, Xia Shan, Wenling Li, Ping Ding, Gan You, Zhen Hong, Xuejun Yang, Guoming Luan, Wenbin Ma, Hui Yang, Yongpin You, Tianming Yang, Liang Li, Wei‐Ping Liao, Lei Wang, Xun Wu, Xinguang Yu, Jianguo Zhang, Qing Mao, Yuping Wang, Wenbin Li, Xuefeng Wang, Chuanlu Jiang, Xiaoyan Liu, Songtao Qi, Xingzhou Liu, Yan Qu, Jiwen Xu, Weimin Wang, Zhi Song, Jinsong Wu, Zhixiong Liu, Ling Chen, Yuanxiang Lin, Jian Zhou, Xianzeng Liu, Wei Zhang, Shichuo Li, Tao JiangCancer 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first clinical practice guidelines for glioma-related epilepsy (GRE) in China, offering a much-needed framework for diagnosis and treatment. By synthesizing existing evidence and expert consensus, these guidelines aim to standardize care, reduce complications, and improve the quality of life for patients with diffuse gliomas who experience seizures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Glioma-related epilepsy (GRE) is a significant complication for patients with diffuse gliomas, characterized by epileptic seizures secondary to the tumor. This condition imposes a substantial financial and psychosocial burden, negatively impacting patients' quality of life. Despite the prevalence of GRE, there has been a lack of standardized clinical guidelines to guide optimal diagnosis and treatment strategies. This gap leads to variability in patient care and potentially suboptimal outcomes, as conventional treatments (antiepileptic drugs and anti-tumor therapies) are not always effective, with 20-40% of patients experiencing uncontrolled seizures.

Methods

The development of these guidelines involved a rigorous, multi-step process:

  • Literature Review: A comprehensive review of relevant domestic and international literature was conducted.
  • Evidence Grading: The evaluated literature was graded based on the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine Levels of Evidence.
  • Consensus Meetings: Three consensus meetings were held among the guideline committee members to discuss and formulate recommendations.
  • Expert Input: The recommendations were informed by the collective experience of over 3000 GRE cases from 24 tertiary hospitals specializing in epilepsy, glioma, and GRE research in China.

This approach combines evidence-based medicine with practical clinical experience to create actionable guidelines.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on synthesizing existing literature and expert consensus rather than presenting novel experimental data or training on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GRE is a Complex Interplay: The epileptogenesis of GRE is multifactorial, involving tumor location, histology, microenvironment, and specific genetic alterations, highlighting the need for a holistic diagnostic and treatment approach.
  • IDH1 Mutation is Key: The IDH1 mutation status is a crucial factor, particularly for low-grade gliomas (LGGs), and is closely associated with GRE. This emphasizes the importance of molecular pathology in diagnosis.
  • Diagnosis Requires a Dual Approach: Diagnosing GRE necessitates not only identifying the glioma but also confirming and characterizing the epilepsy, and crucially, establishing the link between the two.
  • AEDs: Tailored and Cautious Use: Antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) are essential, with levetiracetam (LEV) and valproic acid (VPA) being recommended for monotherapy due to their efficacy and convenience. However, hepatic enzyme-inducing AEDs should be avoided in patients undergoing chemotherapy.
  • AED Withdrawal is Nuanced: AED withdrawal is a complex issue, with specific recommendations based on seizure history, tumor status, and risk factors. It's generally not recommended for glioblastoma (GBM) patients or those with anaplastic gliomas and incomplete resection or intractable seizures.
  • Surgery as a Dual-Purpose Intervention: While tumor control remains the primary goal of surgery, seizure control is recognized as a significant secondary objective. Maximal safe resection is strongly associated with improved seizure outcomes.
  • Radiotherapy and Chemotherapy Show Efficacy: Both radiotherapy and chemotherapy have demonstrated a significant positive effect on inhibiting GRE, even independent of surgical resection.

Key Results

The paper presents a comprehensive set of recommendations for the diagnosis and treatment of GRE, including:

  • Diagnostic Flowchart: A detailed flowchart guides clinicians through the diagnostic process, integrating imaging, electroencephalography (EEG), and pathological findings.
  • Treatment Strategies: Specific recommendations are provided for AED administration, including preferred agents, polytherapy options, and timing of withdrawal.
  • Surgical Considerations: Guidelines emphasize maximal safe resection and the use of advanced techniques like intraoperative electrocorticography for refractory GRE.
  • Role of Adjuvant Therapies: Radiotherapy and chemotherapy are highlighted for their significant role in seizure control.
  • Risk Stratification: The guidelines identify high-risk factors for intraoperative and postoperative seizures, informing prophylactic AED use.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the recommendations are based on a combination of evidence and expert consensus, and for some controversial issues, expert consensus serves as the primary reference. The heterogeneity in drug dosage and duration in clinical studies is also noted as a limitation for specific AED recommendations.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests the need for further high-quality prospective studies to refine recommendations, particularly regarding AED withdrawal and the precise role of various adjuvant therapies. The development of these guidelines itself represents a step towards better management, and future work will likely involve their implementation and refinement based on real-world outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

The current work will provide a framework and assurance for the diagnosis and treatment strategy of GRE to reduce complications and costs caused by unnecessary treatment. Additionally, it can serve as a reference for all professionals involved in the management of patients with GRE.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liang2019clinical,
  author = {Shuli Liang and Xing Fan and Ming Zhao and Xia Shan and Wenling Li and Ping Ding and Gan You and Zhen Hong and Xuejun Yang and Guoming Luan and Wenbin Ma and Hui Yang and Yongpin You and Tianming Yang and Liang Li and Wei‐Ping Liao and Lei Wang and Xun Wu and Xinguang Yu and Jianguo Zhang and Qing Mao and Yuping Wang and Wenbin Li and Xuefeng Wang and Chuanlu Jiang and Xiaoyan Liu and Songtao Qi and Xingzhou Liu and Yan Qu and Jiwen Xu and Weimin Wang and Zhi Song and Jinsong Wu and Zhixiong Liu and Ling Chen and Yuanxiang Lin and Jian Zhou and Xianzeng Liu and Wei Zhang and Shichuo Li and Tao Jiang},
  title = {{Clinical practice guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of adult diffuse glioma‐related epilepsy}},
  booktitle = {Cancer},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1002/cam4.2362},
}
Figure