Clinical effect of the internal fixation for rib fracture with single utility port complete video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery

Jindong Wang, Zhiguang Sun, Yongshuai Liu, Wei-yong Gong, Jianxin Wang, Junyi Deng, Yue Fu, Jishan LanJournal of Cardiothoracic Surgery 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The internal fixation for rib fractures with single-operation-port complete VATS is a feasible, safe, simple, and minimally invasive surgical procedure to treat multiple rib fractures, which is worthy of clinical application.

Introduction

Multiple rib fractures, particularly those resulting in "flail chest," are a major source of morbidity in trauma patients. While internal fixation using plates to stabilize the bone is the gold standard for restoring chest wall stability, the traditional "open" approach is ironically traumatic. It requires large incisions (10–15 cm) and the cutting of major chest wall muscles and nerves, often leading to chronic pain, restricted movement, and high infection rates.

Previous attempts at minimally invasive surgery often used a "hybrid" approach, still requiring a small external incision to place the plates. This study evaluates a complete VATS (Video-Assisted Thoracoscopic Surgery) procedure, where the reduction and fixation of the ribs happen entirely within the thoracic cavity, sparing the external musculature.

Methods

The study retrospectively analyzed 73 patients with multiple rib fractures at the Cangzhou Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine Hospital between June 2019 and December 2021. Patients were divided into a Study Group (n=42) receiving single-operation-port complete VATS and a Control Group (n=31) receiving traditional open internal fixation via thoracotomy.

The VATS procedure utilized only two small incisions: a 4 cm "utility" port and a 2 cm observation port. Surgeons used specialized instruments, including "peach shape" reduction forceps and puncture hooks, to realign the ribs from the inside.

Specialized surgical instruments used for internal fixation, including reduction forceps and memory alloy plates.

Fixation was achieved using reverse memory alloy rib plates (TiNi). These plates are pre-cooled to remain flexible, delivered through the port, and then "activated" with 45°C sterile saline, causing them to contract and grip the internal cortex of the rib firmly.

Intraoperative thoracoscopic views showing the rib fracture site and the internal fixation process.

Results and Key Insights

The VATS group showed statistically significant improvements across almost every recovery metric compared to the open surgery group:

  • Reduced Trauma: Blood loss was reduced by nearly 44% (65.58 mL vs. 116.75 mL).
  • Enhanced Recovery: Visual Analog Scale (VAS) pain scores on the 7th day were significantly lower (2.13 vs. 4.38). Patients also had shorter chest tube placement times (3.13 days vs. 5.87 days) and shorter overall hospital stays.
  • Surgical Efficiency: Despite the technical complexity, operative time was nearly identical to open surgery (approx. 84 vs 88 minutes), suggesting the technique is efficient once mastered.
  • Internal vs. External Fixation: By fixing the plate to the internal cortex, surgeons avoid dissecting essential muscle layers like the latissimus dorsi. The thermal activation of TiNi plates eliminates the need for screwdrivers in confined spaces.
  • Comprehensive Care: Thoracoscopy provides a superior view of the entire chest cavity, allowing for better management of hemothorax and lung lacerations.

Discussion and Limitations

While the results are promising, the study is limited by its retrospective design and relatively small sample size. Furthermore, the follow-up focused on short-term recovery (up to 7 days); long-term outcomes like bone union rates and chronic pain at 6 months require further investigation. Anatomically, the technique can be challenging for fractures in the extreme upper or posterior regions of the chest wall.

Conclusion

Single-operation-port complete VATS for rib fixation is a safe and effective minimally invasive alternative to traditional thoracotomy, offering reduced postoperative pain and faster recovery without sacrificing structural stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

The internal fixation for rib fractures with single-operation-port complete VATS is a feasible, safe, simple, and minimally invasive surgical procedure to treat multiple rib fractures, which is worthy of clinical application.
BibTeX
@article{wang2024clinical,
  author = {Jindong Wang and Zhiguang Sun and Yongshuai Liu and Wei-yong Gong and Jianxin Wang and Junyi Deng and Yue Fu and Jishan Lan},
  title = {{Clinical effect of the internal fixation for rib fracture with single utility port complete video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery}},
  journal = {Journal of Cardiothoracic Surgery},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s13019-024-02517-0},
}
Figure