Clinical course of nontraumatic nonaneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage: a single institution experience over 10 years and review of the contemporary literature

Mehmet Akçakaya, Aydın Aydöseli, Yavuz Aras, Pulat Akın Sabancı, Mehmet Barbüroğlu, Görkem Alkır, Altay Sencer, Serra Sencer, Kubilay Aydın, Talat Kırış, Kemal Hepgül, Ömer Faruk Ünal, Orhan Barlas, Nail İzgiTurkish 2016 · DOI

Abstract

We suggest our diagnostic work-up for patients with nPM-SAH, namely repeat DSA and spinal MRI, until an evidence-based guideline is established for the patient management.

Introduction

Subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) is a critical neurological emergency, typically associated with ruptured intracranial aneurysms. However, in approximately 15% of cases, initial digital subtraction angiography (DSA)—the diagnostic gold standard—fails to identify a source of bleeding. These cases are termed nontraumatic nonaneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhages (NNSAH).

The management of NNSAH remains a subject of debate. While some bleeding patterns are considered benign, others may mask underlying pathologies. This study evaluates the clinical course of NNSAH based on bleeding patterns to refine diagnostic protocols.

Methods

Researchers at Istanbul University conducted a retrospective analysis of 81 NNSAH patients treated between 2004 and 2014. Patients were categorized into three groups based on initial CT imaging:

  1. Perimesencephalic SAH (PM-SAH): Blood localized to the cisterns around the midbrain (n=33).
  2. Non-perimesencephalic SAH (nPM-SAH): Blood extending into the Sylvian fissure or ventricles (n=41).
  3. CT-negative SAH: SAH confirmed via lumbar puncture despite negative CT (n=7).

The diagnostic protocol included an initial four-vessel DSA, cranial MRI within the first week, a repeat DSA 7–21 days later, and spinal MRI to exclude spinal vascular malformations or tumors.

Initial CT scan showing a typical subarachnoid hemorrhage pattern.

Results and Discussion

The study revealed significant clinical differences between PM-SAH and nPM-SAH patterns.

Prognostic Value of Bleeding Patterns

Patients with nPM-SAH experienced significantly longer hospitalizations compared to those with PM-SAH (14.7 vs. 6.3 days, p < 0.001). Furthermore, the nPM-SAH group exhibited higher rates of radiological vasospasm (29% vs. 12%) and included the only mortality in the cohort.

Diagnostic Yield of Follow-up Imaging

The "aggressive" follow-up protocol proved vital for the nPM-SAH group. Repeat DSA identified hidden aneurysms in 4.9% of nPM-SAH cases, while spinal MRI uncovered spinal pathologies (e.g., arteriovenous malformations or schwannomas) in 7.3%. Notably, no additional pathologies were found in the PM-SAH or CT-negative groups through these follow-up modalities.

Digital subtraction angiography (DSA) used to evaluate cerebral vasculature for aneurysms.

The Role of Cranial MRI

While frequently performed, cranial MRI did not provide additional diagnostic information regarding the source of hemorrhage in this study, suggesting its utility may be limited in the acute work-up of NNSAH.

Conclusion

The clinical course of NNSAH is heavily influenced by the initial bleeding pattern. While PM-SAH follows a generally benign course, nPM-SAH requires a rigorous diagnostic work-up. We recommend that patients with nPM-SAH undergo repeat DSA and spinal MRI to ensure that occult aneurysms or spinal lesions are not overlooked. Future prospective, multi-center studies are needed to formalize these management guidelines.

Summary updated

Abstract

We suggest our diagnostic work-up for patients with nPM-SAH, namely repeat DSA and spinal MRI, until an evidence-based guideline is established for the patient management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{akcakaya2016clinical,
  author = {Mehmet Akçakaya and Aydın Aydöseli and Yavuz Aras and Pulat Akın Sabancı and Mehmet Barbüroğlu and Görkem Alkır and Altay Sencer and Serra Sencer and Kubilay Aydın and Talat Kırış and Kemal Hepgül and Ömer Faruk Ünal and Orhan Barlas and Nail İzgi},
  title = {{Clinical course of nontraumatic nonaneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage: a single institution experience over 10 years and review of the contemporary literature}},
  booktitle = {Turkish},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.5137/1019-5149.jtn.18359-16.2},
}
Figure