Clinical and organizational factors associated with mortality during the peak of first COVID-19 wave: the global UNITE-COVID study

Massimiliano Greco, Thomas De Corte, Ari Ercole, Massimo Antonelli, Élie Azoulay, Giuseppe Citerio, Andrew Conway Morris, Gennaro De Pascale, František Duška, Paul Elbers, Sharon Einav, Lui G. Forni, Laurą Galarza, Armand R. J. Girbes, Giacomo Grasselli, V. G. Gusarov, Alasdair Jubb, Jozef Kesecioğlu, Andrea Lavinio, M.c. Martín Delgado, Johannes Mellinghoff, Sheila Nainan Myatra, Marlies Ostermann, Mariangela Pellegrini, Pedro Póvoa, Stefan J. Schaller, Jean–Louis Teboul, Adrian Wong, Jan J. De Waele, Maurizio Cecconi, Marco Bezzi, Alicia Gira, Philipp Eller, Tarikul Hamid, Injamam Ull Haque, Wim De Buyser, Antonella Cudia, Daniel De Backer, Pierre Foulon, Vincent Collin, Jolien Van Hecke, Elisabeth De Waele, Claire Van Malderen, Jean-Baptiste Mesland, Patrick Biston, Michaël Piagnerelli, Lionel Haentjens, Nicolas De Schryver, Jan Van Leemput, Philippe Vanhove, Pierre Bulpa, Viktoria Ilieva, David Katz, Alexandra Binnie, Anna Geagea, Fernando Tirapegui, Gustavo Lago, Jerónimo Graf, Rodrigo Perez-Araos, Patricio Vargas, Felipe Martínez, Eduardo Labarca, Daniel Franco, Daniela Parra-Tanoux, Luis Felipe Reyes, David Yepes, Filip Periš, Sanda Stojanović Stipić, Cynthia Vanessa Campozano Burgos, Paulo Roberto Navas Boada, Jose Luis Barberan Brun, Juan Pablo Paredes Ballesteros, G. Abdel-Nasser, Ahmed Hammouda, Omar Elmandouh, Ahmed Y. Azzam, Aliae Mohamed Hussein, Islam Galal, Ahmed K. Awad, Mohammed A. Azab, Maged Abdalla, Hebatallah Hany Assal, Mostafa Alfishawy, Sherief Ghozy, Samar Tharwat, Abdullah Eldaly, Anneli Ellervee, Veronika Reinhard, Anne Chrisment, Chrystelle Poyat, Julio Badié, Fernando Berdaguer Ferrari, Björn Weiß, Clara Schellenberg, Julius J. Grunow, Marco Lorenz, Peter Spieth, Marc BotaIntensive 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

During the first wave of COVID-19, ICUs worldwide dramatically expanded capacity, admitting nearly 40% of patients to "surge" beds. Surprisingly, this expansion and the use of surge beds did not increase mortality. Instead, older age, invasive mechanical ventilation, and acute kidney injury (AKI) emerged as the strongest predictors of death.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The unprecedented surge of critically ill COVID-19 patients during the pandemic's first wave placed immense strain on Intensive Care Units (ICUs) globally. This led to a critical question: how did ICUs adapt, and what were the consequences of these adaptations, particularly regarding patient outcomes? Specifically, the study aimed to understand the impact of expanding ICU capacity (including using non-traditional "surge" beds) and the associated organizational changes on mortality rates. The authors hypothesized that admitting patients to surge beds might increase mortality due to potentially lower resource availability compared to standard ICUs.

Methods

This study employed a multicenter, international, point prevalence design. Data were collected from 280 ICUs across 46 countries during the peak of the first COVID-19 wave (February 15th to May 15th, 2020). The researchers gathered detailed information on patient demographics, comorbidities, clinical status at ICU admission, organ support received, and various complications during their ICU stay. They also collected data on ICU organizational factors, including bed capacity changes, staffing levels, and the use of surge capacity beds. Statistical analysis involved multivariable mixed-effect models to identify factors associated with mortality, controlling for variations between centers. Sensitivity analyses were conducted to confirm findings, particularly regarding the impact of surge beds and the role of invasive mechanical ventilation.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 4,994 patients admitted to 280 ICUs in 46 countries. This represents a large, global dataset capturing the initial impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on critical care. The data was collected through a secure, cloud-based electronic data capture platform.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surge Capacity Didn't Hurt: The most striking finding is that admitting patients to surge capacity beds, despite the likely strain on resources, was not associated with increased mortality. This suggests that critical care teams were able to effectively manage patient care even in expanded, non-traditional settings.
  • Organizational Adaptations Were Effective (or Neutral): The study highlights the significant efforts made by ICUs to increase capacity and adapt staffing. The fact that these adaptations, including the use of non-ICU staff, did not negatively impact mortality is a testament to the resilience and adaptability of critical care systems.
  • Predictors of Mortality Remain Consistent: Despite the unique circumstances of the pandemic, the strongest predictors of mortality (older age, invasive mechanical ventilation, and AKI) align with established knowledge in critical care medicine. This suggests that while the context was novel, the underlying physiological vulnerabilities of critically ill patients remained key determinants of outcome.
  • Delayed Ventilation is Risky: Patients who required invasive mechanical ventilation after admission to the ICU had a higher mortality rate than those who were already intubated upon admission. This points to the potential dangers of delayed intubation in severe respiratory failure.

Key Results

  • High Mortality: Overall 60-day mortality was 33.9%, with ICU mortality at 32.7%.
  • Surge Bed Usage: Nearly 40% (1986 out of 4994) of patients were admitted to surge capacity beds.
  • No Surge Bed Mortality Impact: After controlling for other factors, admission to a surge capacity bed was not associated with increased mortality (OR 1.01, 95% CI 0.82–1.25).
  • Strongest Mortality Predictors: Invasive mechanical ventilation (OR 14.94), increasing age, acute kidney injury (AKI) (OR 3.63), and pneumothorax (OR 2.55) were significantly associated with increased mortality.
  • Protective Factors: Prolonged delirium (OR 0.22) and tracheostomy (OR 0.35) were associated with survival.
  • Ventilation: 85.8% of patients required invasive mechanical ventilation during their ICU stay, with 46.5% intubated at admission.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Observational Design: The study is observational, meaning it cannot definitively establish causation between variables.
  • Data Collection Challenges: The data was collected during the chaotic first wave, and it's possible not all events were recorded, potentially underestimating adverse events.
  • Generalizability: The study focused on the first wave, and findings may not directly apply to subsequent waves with different variants or vaccination levels.
  • Expertise Not Measured: While patient-to-nurse ratios were analyzed, the level of expertise of the nurses in surge capacity units was not assessed.
  • Organizational Burden: The study could not fully quantify the impact of extreme operating conditions and increased workload on mortality, as this was a systemic issue.

Future work could explore the long-term outcomes of patients admitted to surge beds and investigate the specific organizational strategies that contributed to maintaining similar outcomes across different ICU settings. Further research into the impact of nurse expertise and the nuances of delirium management in crisis situations would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

ICUs responded to the increase in COVID-19 patients by increasing bed availability and staff, admitting up to 40% of patients in surge capacity beds. Although mortality in this population was high, admission to a surge capacity bed was not associated with increased mortality. Older age, invasive mechanical ventilation, and AKI were identified as the strongest predictors of mortality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{greco2022clinical,
  author = {Massimiliano Greco and Thomas De Corte and Ari Ercole and Massimo Antonelli and Élie Azoulay and Giuseppe Citerio and Andrew Conway Morris and Gennaro De Pascale and František Duška and Paul Elbers and Sharon Einav and Lui G. Forni and Laurą Galarza and Armand R. J. Girbes and Giacomo Grasselli and V. G. Gusarov and Alasdair Jubb and Jozef Kesecioğlu and Andrea Lavinio and M.C. Martín Delgado and Johannes Mellinghoff and Sheila Nainan Myatra and Marlies Ostermann and Mariangela Pellegrini and Pedro Póvoa and Stefan J. Schaller and Jean–Louis Teboul and Adrian Wong and Jan J. De Waele and Maurizio Cecconi and Marco Bezzi and Alicia Gira and Philipp Eller and Tarikul Hamid and Injamam Ull Haque and Wim De Buyser and Antonella Cudia and Daniel De Backer and Pierre Foulon and Vincent Collin and Jan J. De Waele and Jolien Van Hecke and Elisabeth De Waele and Claire Van Malderen and Jean-Baptiste Mesland and Patrick Biston and Michaël Piagnerelli and Lionel Haentjens and Nicolas De Schryver and Jan Van Leemput and Philippe Vanhove and Pierre Bulpa and Viktoria Ilieva and David Katz and Alexandra Binnie and Anna Geagea and Fernando Tirapegui and Gustavo Lago and Jerónimo Graf and Rodrigo Perez-Araos and Patricio Vargas and Felipe Martínez and Eduardo Labarca and Daniel Franco and Daniela Parra-Tanoux and Luis Felipe Reyes and David Yepes and Filip Periš and Sanda Stojanović Stipić and Cynthia Vanessa Campozano Burgos and Paulo Roberto Navas Boada and Jose Luis Barberan Brun and Juan Pablo Paredes Ballesteros and G. Abdel-Nasser and Ahmed Hammouda and Omar Elmandouh and Ahmed Y. Azzam and Aliae Mohamed Hussein and Islam Galal and Ahmed K. Awad and Mohammed A. Azab and Maged Abdalla and Hebatallah Hany Assal and Mostafa Alfishawy and Sherief Ghozy and Samar Tharwat and Abdullah Eldaly and Anneli Ellervee and Veronika Reinhard and Anne Chrisment and Chrystelle Poyat and Julio Badié and Fernando Berdaguer Ferrari and Björn Weiß and Clara Schellenberg and Julius J. Grunow and Marco Lorenz and Stefan J. Schaller and Peter Spieth and Marc Bota},
  title = {{Clinical and organizational factors associated with mortality during the peak of first COVID-19 wave: the global UNITE-COVID study}},
  booktitle = {Intensive},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s00134-022-06705-1},
}
Figure