Clinical analysis of the acromial height-measuring device combined with new-type clavicular hook plate and standard clavicular hook plate in the treatment of Neer type II distal clavicle fractures

Dashuang Li, Rui Qiao, Na Yang, Kun Zhang, Yangjun Zhu, Zhe SongJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a novel acromial height-measuring device and an improved clavicular hook plate for treating distal clavicle fractures. The new approach significantly reduces the incidence of subacromial impingement syndrome (SIS) and improves short-term functional recovery compared to standard hook plates, offering a promising alternative for patients.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Distal clavicle fractures, particularly Neer type II, are common shoulder injuries that often require surgical intervention. The standard treatment involves a clavicular hook plate, which, while effective in stabilizing the fracture, can lead to complications. These include subacromial impingement syndrome (SIS), characterized by shoulder pain and limited mobility, as well as acromion osteolysis (bone degradation around the plate). These issues arise because the hook of the plate can impinge on the subacromial space, irritating the bursa and tendons. The authors aimed to address this by developing a method to better fit the hook plate to the patient's anatomy, thereby minimizing impingement.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of 81 patients with Neer type II distal clavicle fractures. Patients were divided into two groups: an experimental group (32 patients) treated with the new acromial height-measuring device and an improved clavicular hook plate, and a control group (49 patients) treated with a standard clavicular hook plate.

The key innovation is the acromial height-measuring device. This device is used during surgery to measure the height of the acromion. This measurement is then used to select an improved clavicular hook plate with a specific hook depth that is designed to have a minimal difference (ideally <6 mm) from the measured acromial height. This aims to prevent the hook from excessively encroaching on the subacromial space. The improved hook plate also features a modified hook angle (110° option) and a more versatile screw hole design for better fixation, especially in comminuted fractures.

Postoperative outcomes were assessed using the Constant-Murley score (for shoulder function), the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) for pain, and the incidence of acromion osteolysis and SIS.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved a retrospective analysis of patient data collected at Xi'an Honghui Hospital.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Anatomical Fit is Crucial: The study strongly suggests that a better anatomical fit of the clavicular hook plate to the acromion is key to reducing postoperative complications like SIS.
  • The "Sweet Spot" for Hook Depth: By using an acromial height-measuring device, the authors identified a critical range for the difference between acromial height and hook plate depth (<6 mm) to minimize impingement.
  • Improved Plate Design Matters: Beyond the measurement device, modifications to the hook plate itself (angle, screw placement) contribute to better outcomes.
  • Short-Term Gains, Long-Term Similarity: While the new method shows significant short-term benefits in pain reduction and functional recovery, the long-term outcomes (after one year) appear to converge with the standard method.

Key Results

  • Reduced SIS: The experimental group (new device + improved plate) had a significantly lower incidence of SIS (9.34%) compared to the control group (28.57%) (P<0.05).
  • Improved Functional Scores: The experimental group showed significantly better Constant-Murley scores at 3 and 6 months post-surgery and lower VAS scores at 1 week and 3 months post-surgery compared to the control group (P<0.05).
  • No Significant Difference in Acromion Osteolysis: The incidence of acromion osteolysis was not significantly different between the two groups (P>0.05).
  • Long-Term Convergence: While short-term functional improvements were noted, Constant-Murley scores at one year and VAS scores at six months post-surgery showed no statistically significant difference between the groups.
  • No Major Complications: Both groups had successful surgeries with no instances of non-union, delayed union, internal fixation failure, or infection.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Acromion Type Not Considered: The study did not account for variations in acromion morphology, which could influence outcomes.
  • Ideal vs. Actual Measurement: The controlled difference of <6 mm was based on prior imaging studies, and actual intraoperative measurements might differ, potentially leading to stress fractures if the difference is too small. Further research is needed to precisely define the optimal difference.
  • Small Sample Size and Single Center: The study's sample size was relatively small, and it was conducted at a single institution, limiting generalizability.
  • Confounding Factors: The control group represented an earlier surgical period, and the experimental group a later one. This temporal difference, along with accumulated clinical experience and evolving surgical concepts, could have influenced the results.

Future work should focus on larger, multi-center studies to validate these findings. Further investigation into the precise relationship between acromial height-hook plate depth difference and SIS incidence is also warranted. The authors also suggest that the choice of fixation method (hook plate vs. locking plate) should consider fracture characteristics, comminution, and patient bone quality.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Distal clavicular fracture is a shoulder joint injury that is common in clinical settings and is generally surgically treated using the clavicular hook plate technique with a confirmed curative effect. However, symptoms, such as shoulder abduction limitation, shoulder discomfort, and postoperative joint pain, may occur in some patients. To overcome these problems, after a previous study we developed an acromial height-measuring device and a new type of clavicular hook plate. This study aimed to investigate whether an acromial height-measuring device combined with an improved new-type clavicular hook plate can better reduce the incidence of complications and improve postoperative function. To provide patients with better treatment effects, an acromion gauge and clavicular hook plate are used. Methods A retrospective analysis was performed on 81 patients with distal clavicular fractures admitted to our hospital. They were divided into experimental and control groups according to different plates, and the Constant–Murley score, visual analogue scale score, incidence of acromion osteolysis, and incidence of subacromial impingement syndrome were compared. Results Compared with the standard clavicular hook plate, the acromial height-measuring device combined with the new-type clavicular hook plate in the treatment of distal clavicle fractures has a lower incidence of subacromial impingement syndrome with better postoperative functional recovery and quality of life. Conclusions We considered the acromial height-measuring device combined with the new clavicular hook plate to be a safe and promising alternative to distal clavicular fractures.
BibTeX
@article{li2022clinical,
  author = {Dashuang Li and Rui Qiao and Na Yang and Kun Zhang and Yangjun Zhu and Zhe Song},
  title = {{Clinical analysis of the acromial height-measuring device combined with new-type clavicular hook plate and standard clavicular hook plate in the treatment of Neer type II distal clavicle fractures}},
  journal = {Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1186/s13018-022-03338-4},
}
Figure