Climate sensitivity of tropical and subtropical marine low cloud amount to ENSO and global warming due to doubled CO2

Ping Zhu, James J. Hack, J. T. Kiehl, Christopher S. BrethertonJournal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how tropical and subtropical marine low clouds respond to both short-term climate fluctuations (like El Niño) and long-term global warming from doubled CO2. It reveals that these two drivers impact low clouds through distinct physical processes, with El Niño affecting clouds via atmospheric convection and global warming influencing them through changes in atmospheric stability and mixed layer depth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how clouds, particularly low-lying marine clouds, respond to climate change is crucial because they play a significant role in Earth's radiative balance. These clouds can either amplify or dampen global warming through feedback mechanisms, but their behavior is complex and not fully understood. Previous research has shown conflicting results from climate models regarding cloud feedbacks, especially in subtropical subsidence regions. This study aims to clarify these differences by systematically analyzing low cloud responses to both observed short-term climate variability (El Niño) and simulated long-term warming (doubled CO2), using satellite data, reanalysis products, and advanced climate models.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Satellite Observations: Utilizes data from the International Satellite Cloud Climatology Project (ISCCP) to observe changes in low cloud amount.
  • Atmospheric Reanalyses: Leverages European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF) reanalyses to examine atmospheric thermodynamic and dynamic states.
  • Climate Model Simulations:
    • SST-forced simulations: NCAR (CAM3, CAM3-UW) and GFDL (AM2) models are run with observed sea surface temperatures (SSTs) to evaluate their ability to reproduce ENSO-related low cloud changes.
  • Coupled simulations: The same models are run with doubled CO2 concentrations to investigate long-term climate change impacts.
  • Atmospheric Mixed Layer Model: A simplified model is used to explore the thermodynamic mechanisms controlling low cloud changes in response to doubled CO2.

Datasets

  • International Satellite Cloud Climatology Project (ISCCP) D2 products: Monthly mean global cloudiness data, classified by cloud-top pressure and optical thickness. Used for observational analysis of low cloud changes.
  • ECMWF Reanalyses: Used to analyze atmospheric thermodynamic and dynamic states.
  • NCAR and GFDL Climate Model Simulations:
    • SST-forced simulations (1978-2001) for ENSO analysis.
  • Doubled CO2 experiments (run-to-steady-state) for long-term climate change analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Distinct Drivers, Distinct Responses: El Niño and doubled CO2 have fundamentally different impacts on low clouds, driven by different physical processes. This is a key takeaway, highlighting the need to consider specific climate forcings.
  • ENSO and Convection: El Niño's impact on low clouds is primarily linked to changes in atmospheric convection, particularly in the eastern tropical Pacific, where increased SSTs enhance convection, leading to a breakdown of low clouds.
  • Doubled CO2 and Stability: Global warming from doubled CO2 leads to an increase in low clouds in subtropical subsidence regions, driven by enhanced atmospheric stability above the inversion layer.
  • SST Gradient Matters for Warming: For doubled CO2, low cloud increase appears to favor regions where SST increases less. This counter-intuitive finding is explained by the mixed layer model, where reduced mixed layer depth in areas with smaller SST increases traps moisture, promoting cloud formation.
  • Model Biases and Reasons: The study identifies model biases in simulating ENSO responses, particularly in relative humidity changes, suggesting that even when models reproduce observed cloud changes, it might be for the "wrong reasons" due to flawed parameterizations.

Key Results

  • ENSO: Low cloud amount reduction during ENSO is negatively correlated with local SST anomaly, occurring in ascending branches with weak atmospheric stability. This is attributed to enhanced atmospheric convection breaking down low clouds.
  • Doubled CO2: Low cloud amount increase is simulated in subtropical subsidence regimes with strong atmospheric stability. This increase is correlated with the spatial SST change pattern, favoring areas with less SST increase.
  • Mixed Layer Model: Demonstrates that increased atmospheric stratification above the inversion in a warmer climate reduces mixed layer depth, trapping moisture and favoring low cloud formation.
  • Model Performance: NCAR models (CAM3, CAM3-UW) generally show better agreement with observed ENSO-related low cloud changes than GFDL's AM2, though all models exhibit biases.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Obscuring Effect: ISCCP observations may underestimate low cloud amounts due to obscuring by mid and high clouds, though the study attempts to account for this.
  • Cloud Condensate: The study focuses on low cloud amount and does not fully address changes in cloud condensate, which is acknowledged as an important area for future research.
  • Model Parameterizations: Differences in model parameterizations (turbulence, shallow convection, cloud overlap) are highlighted as sources of model biases and differing results, suggesting a need for careful examination and novel evaluation approaches.
  • SST Change Determination: The paper raises the question of what determines the SST change in a coupled system, indicating that further research into surface parameterization and boundary layer schemes is needed.
  • Cloud-top Radiative Cooling: The effect of cloud-top radiative cooling on mixed layer growth is complex and not fully quantified in this study, requiring off-line radiative transfer calculations for further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, we systematically analyzed the sensitivity of tropical and subtropical marine low cloud amount to the short‐term climate anomaly associated with the 1997–1998 El Niño and the long‐term climate change caused by doubled CO 2 using the International Satellite Cloud Climatology Project (ISCCP) cloud measurements, European Centre for Medium‐Range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF) reanalyses, and the sea surface temperature (SST) forced and coupled simulations performed by the latest version of the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) and Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory (GFDL) climate models. It is found that the changes in low cloud amount associated with the 1997–1998 El Niño and the doubled CO 2 induced climate change have different characteristics and are controlled by different physical processes. Most reduction in low cloud amount related to the 1997–1998 El Niño occurs in the eastern tropical Pacific associated with an upward large‐scale motion and a weak atmospheric stability measured by the 500 hPa vertical velocity and the potential temperature difference between 700 hPa and the surface, and is negatively correlated to the local SST anomaly. In addition to the other mechanisms suggested by the previous studies, our analyses based on the ISCCP observations indicate that the change in atmospheric convective activities in these regions is one of the reasons responsible for the change in low cloud amount. In contrast, most increase in low cloud amount due to doubled CO 2 simulated by the NCAR and GFDL models occurs in the subtropical subsidence regimes associated with a strong atmospheric stability, and is closely related to the spatial change pattern of SST consistent with previous studies. The increase in low cloud amount appears to favor the location where SST is less increased. After removing the background mean SST increase due to doubled CO 2 , the results show a clear negative correlation between the change in low cloud and the SST change. An analysis based on the simple atmospheric mixed layer model demonstrates a thermodynamic reason for such a change. The increase in the above‐inversion atmospheric stratification due to doubled CO 2 tends to reduce the mixed layer depth in the areas with a small temperature increase, which helps to trap the moisture within the mixed layer, thus, favors low cloud formation.
BibTeX
@article{zhu2007climate,
  author = {Ping Zhu and James J. Hack and J. T. Kiehl and Christopher S. Bretherton},
  title = {{Climate sensitivity of tropical and subtropical marine low cloud amount to ENSO and global warming due to doubled CO<sub>2</sub>}},
  journal = {Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1029/2006jd008174},
}
Figure