Climate-mediated spatiotemporal variability in the terrestrial productivity across Europe

Xiuchen Wu, Miguel D. Mahecha, Markus Reichstein, Philippe Ciais, M. Wattenbach, Flurin Babst, D. Frank, Christian Zang2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that Europe's terrestrial productivity, from crops to forests, is highly variable and increasingly sensitive to climate, especially in drier regions. The findings highlight a growing vulnerability of European ecosystems to climate change, with significant implications for the continent's carbon cycle.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately predicting future climate and carbon cycle changes hinges on understanding how terrestrial productivity responds to climate variability. While we know climate influences productivity, the intricate spatiotemporal patterns of this variability and the underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by investigating how climate drives year-to-year fluctuations (interannual variability, or IAV) in terrestrial productivity across Europe, and how this sensitivity has changed over time. This is crucial because terrestrial ecosystems play a vital role in the global carbon balance, acting as both sinks and sources of carbon dioxide.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-proxy approach to assess terrestrial productivity. They analyzed:

  • Crop Yield Data: Using historical data from EUROSTAT, they focused on four key crops (barley, wheat, grain maize, and potatoes).
  • Tree Ring Data: Standardized tree-ring indices (TRI) from a pan-European network were used as a proxy for forest growth.
  • Remote Sensing Data: Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and Fraction of Absorbed Photosynthetically Active Radiation (FAPAR) from satellite observations provided broader vegetation activity indicators.
  • Modeled Productivity: Gridded gross primary production (GPP) data, derived from integrating in-situ measurements with satellite data, offered another measure of ecosystem productivity.

These productivity proxies were then analyzed in conjunction with climate variables, including temperature (TMP), water availability index (WAI), consecutive frost days (CFD), and maximum daily temperature (MMT). Key analytical techniques included:

  • Coefficient of Variation (CV): To quantify year-to-year variability in productivity.
  • Spearman's Rank Correlation: To assess relationships between different productivity proxies and climate variables.
  • Moving Least-Squares Regressions (Theil-Sen slope method): To identify temporal trends in productivity variability and climate sensitivity over time.
  • General Linear Models and Response Function Analysis: To determine the specific relationships between productivity and climate variables.

Datasets

The study utilized several key datasets:

  • EUROSTAT Regional Crop Yield Statistics: Covering 1975–2009 for barley, wheat, grain maize, and potatoes.
  • Tree Ring Network Data: A pan-European dataset of tree-ring width indices.
  • GIMMS NDVI and FAPAR Data: Derived from AVHRR satellite observations (1982–2008).
  • Gridded GPP Data: Spatially distributed estimates for Europe (1982–2008).
  • Climate Data:
    • CRU TS 3.1 monthly temperature data (1975–2009).
  • Water Availability Index (WAI) data (1975–2009).
  • European Climate Assessment (ECA) project data for consecutive frost days (CFD) and maximum daily temperature (MMT) (1975–2009).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water is King (Especially in the South): Terrestrial productivity in Europe is significantly more variable in drier, water-limited regions (Mediterranean and temperate continental Europe) compared to wetter, oceanic areas. Water availability, more than temperature, appears to be the dominant driver of these spatial patterns in temperate Europe.
  • Increasing Vulnerability: There's a clear trend of increasing interannual variability in productivity and a growing sensitivity to water availability, particularly in Europe's drier regions. This suggests these ecosystems are becoming more vulnerable to climate fluctuations.
  • Non-Linear Responses: The findings point towards non-linear responses of carbon fluxes to climate variability, meaning small changes in climate can have disproportionately large impacts on productivity.
  • Shifting Sensitivities: The study reveals that the sensitivity of productivity to climate has changed over time, with a notable increase in recent decades, especially in water-limited areas.

Key Results

  • Spatial Heterogeneity: Productivity IAV is not uniform across Europe; it's significantly higher in southern and eastern Europe.
  • Correlation Strength: Stronger correlations were found between crop yield IAV and NDVI, GPP, and FAPAR in drier European regions.
  • Trend in Variability: For most crops (except potatoes), there's a marked increasing trend in the interannual variability of crop yield, especially in water-limited regions.
  • Climate Sensitivity Trends: A pronounced change in climate sensitivity (YIAV) of crop yield is observed, with a general increase for both temperature and water availability in water-limited regions.
  • Regional Differences: The study highlights that climate variations explain only 20-40% of the spatial variance in productivity IAV in much of temperate Europe, suggesting other factors are also at play.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Discrepancies: The study acknowledges that different proxy datasets (e.g., crop yield vs. tree rings) show some discrepancies in their IAV patterns. This is attributed to factors like intensive human management for crops, carry-over effects of climate on tree growth, and species-specific characteristics.
  • Unresolved Mechanisms: While the study identifies increasing IAV and sensitivity in water-limited regions, the precise underlying mechanisms remain to be fully resolved.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that atmospheric inversion and land-surface modeling will be crucial for further identifying and attributing changes in productivity's climate sensitivity. They also emphasize the need for continued development of proxy and historical datasets to build a robust empirical baseline for understanding past carbon cycle processes. The increasing vulnerability of European ecosystems to climate change, particularly water availability, warrants further investigation into its implications for carbon sinks and the overall carbon balance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantifying the interannual variability (IAV) of the terrestrial productivity and its sensitivity to climate is crucial for improving carbon budget predictions. However, the influence of climate and other mechanisms underlying the spatiotemporal patterns of IAV of productivity are not well understood. In this study we investigated the spatiotemporal patterns of IAV of historical observations of crop yields, tree ring width, remote sensing retrievals of FAPAR and NDVI, and other variables relevant to the terrestrial productivity in Europe in tandem with a set of climate variables. Our results reveal distinct spatial patterns in the IAV of most variables linked to terrestrial productivity. In particular, we find higher IAV in water-limited regions of Europe (Mediterranean and temperate continental Europe) compared to other regions. Our results further indicate that variations in the water balance during active growing season exert a more pronounced and direct effect than variations of temperature on explaining the spatial patterns in IAV of productivity related variables in temperate Europe. We also observe a~temporally increasing trend in the IAV of terrestrial productivity and an increasing sensitivity of productivity to water availability in dry regions of Europe, which is likely attributable to the recently increased IAV of water availability in these regions. These findings suggest nonlinear responses of carbon fluxes to climate variability in Europe and that the IAV of terrestrial productivity has become more sensitive and more vulnerable to changes in water availability in the dry regions in Europe. The changing climate sensitivity of terrestrial productivity accompanied by the changing IAV of climate could impact carbon stocks and the net carbon balance of European ecosystems.
BibTeX
@misc{wu2013climate,
  author = {Xiuchen Wu and Miguel D. Mahecha and Markus Reichstein and Philippe Ciais and M. Wattenbach and Flurin Babst and D. Frank and Christian Zang},
  title = {{Climate-mediated spatiotemporal variability in the terrestrial productivity across Europe}},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5194/bgd-10-17511-2013},
}
Figure