Abstract
It is feasible to identify the palate by 3D-CRV in the first trimester in both healthy and cleft palate fetuses. Together with 2D ultrasonography as a complementary diagnostic tool, 3D-CRV is helpful in classifying the cleft palate with a reasonable degree of certainty.
Introduction
Congenital cleft palate is a common developmental abnormality, yet its prenatal detection rate remains frustratingly low—often between 0% and 22% in routine mid-trimester scans. The primary challenge is anatomical: by the second and third trimesters, the fetal facial bones have hardened (ossified), creating "shadows" that obscure the secondary palate on traditional 2D ultrasound. While 2D markers like the "retronasal triangle" (RNT) exist for first-trimester screening, they are often indirect.
Researchers have demonstrated that a novel 3D ultrasound rendering technology, Crystal and Realistic Vue (CRV), can successfully diagnose cleft palate in fetuses as early as the first trimester (11–13 weeks). By providing high-contrast, multi-planar visualizations of the fetal face, this technique allows clinicians to identify and classify palatal defects far earlier than the traditional mid-trimester scan, offering critical time for genetic counseling and pregnancy management.
Methods and Materials
The study utilized a prospective design, recruiting 124 fetuses (100 healthy and 24 with suspected clefts) between 11 and 13+6 weeks of gestation at the Shenzhen Maternity and Child Healthcare Hospital.
The researchers employed CRV technology on Samsung W10 and WS80A ultrasound systems. CRV is a 3D rendering technique that uses advanced image-contrast enhancement to differentiate between soft tissue and bony structures. The workflow involved:
- 2D Acquisition: Obtaining high-quality coronal and midsagittal views of the fetal face.
- 3D Volume Capture: Collecting 3D data volumes (taking roughly 1.5–2.2 seconds).
- Post-processing: Using "multiplanar mode" to manipulate the 3D volume. By adjusting the Region of Interest (ROI) box and rotating the volume along the X, Y, and Z axes, clinicians could "slice" through the virtual model to see the primary and secondary palate clearly.
Key Insights
- The "Transparency" Advantage: The first trimester is an ideal time for this technology because the fetal facial bones are not yet fully ossified. This lack of dense bone prevents the shadowing that plagues later scans, allowing the ultrasound waves to see the palate more clearly.
- Direct Visualization: While 2D ultrasound relies on indirect signs (like a gap in the retronasal triangle), 3D-CRV allows for the direct visualization of the palatal shelves.
- Classification Power: The technology enables clinicians to classify clefts as unilateral, bilateral, or median. This is vital because median clefts, in particular, are highly correlated with severe holoprosencephaly (a brain development disorder).
Results
- Feasibility: 3D-CRV images of the palatal parts were successfully obtained in 100% of cases (both healthy and abnormal).
- Diagnostic Accuracy: The 24 cases in the cleft group included 15 bilateral, 6 unilateral, and 2 median cleft lip/palate cases, plus one case of "cleft palate alone."
- Associated Anomalies: 62.5% of the cleft group had other anatomical or chromosomal abnormalities (such as Trisomy 13 or 18).
- Efficiency: The 3D data collection was rapid (under 2.5 seconds), making it clinically viable for busy practices, provided high-quality 2D images are obtained first.
Discussion and Limitations
While 3D-CRV offers significant advantages, the authors acknowledge several hurdles to widespread adoption. The quality of the 3D-CRV render is highly operator-dependent, relying on the quality of the initial 2D scan. Additionally, detecting isolated cleft palate (without a cleft lip) remains a challenge; the study included only one such case (n=1). Future multi-center studies are needed to confirm these findings and further refine the learning curve required for sonographers to master 3D-CRV post-processing.
Summary updated