Classes of metastable thermodynamic quantum time crystals

С. И. Мухин, Timur R. GalimzyanovPhysical Review. B./Physical Review. B 2019 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper investigates "thermodynamic quantum time crystals" (TQTCs), a theoretical concept describing exotic quantum states that oscillate in imaginary time. The authors prove that for interacting Fermi systems, these TQTCs are always metastable, meaning they can never be the true ground state or a stable equilibrium state. This is because a simpler, non-oscillating state (a classical order parameter) always has lower free energy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In quantum many-body systems, degenerate states with broken symmetries can sometimes be connected by "instantons." These are special solutions to the equations of motion that are periodic in imaginary (Matsubara) time. The concept of a "thermodynamic quantum time crystal" (TQTC) emerged from the idea that these instantonic solutions could represent a novel type of quantum order, potentially even a ground state. However, the stability of such states has been a significant open question. This paper directly addresses this by rigorously proving that TQTCs, as defined by specific classes of instantonic solutions, cannot achieve true thermodynamic equilibrium or act as the ground state in interacting Fermi systems.

Methods

The authors employ a functional integral formalism, relating the partition function of a many-body system to its Euclidean action. They analyze the system's behavior by extremizing this action, which is a standard technique in quantum field theory. The core of their proof involves:

  • Hubbard-Stratonovich (HS) transformation: This technique is used to decouple interaction terms in the Hamiltonian, introducing auxiliary fields (the "quantum order parameters" or QOPs) that represent the order in the system.
  • Matsubara time periodicity: The analysis focuses on solutions that are periodic in imaginary time, a key characteristic of instantons and TQTCs.
  • Mean-field analysis: The paper starts by considering mean-field solutions, which represent classical order parameters (COPs), and then compares their stability to the more complex QOPs.
  • Floquet theory: The authors utilize Floquet indices (quasi-energies) to analyze the spectrum of the system when subjected to time-dependent potentials (represented by the QOPs).
  • Analytical proof: The central contribution is an analytical "no-go" theorem that demonstrates the metastability of TQTCs for specific classes of solutions. This involves comparing the free energies (Euclidean actions) of TQTC states with those of classical order parameter states.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TQTCs are inherently metastable: The most significant finding is that TQTCs, arising from specific instantonic solutions, are never the true ground state or a stable equilibrium state in interacting Fermi systems. They are always outcompeted by simpler, non-oscillating classical order parameter states.
  • Free energy comparison is key: The proof hinges on a direct comparison of the free energies (Euclidean actions) of TQTC states and classical order parameter states. The TQTC states are shown to always possess a higher free energy.
  • "Hidden order" vs. "true order": The paper distinguishes between QOPs (representing "hidden order" or TQTCs) and COPs (representing "true thermodynamic equilibrium"). While QOPs can exist, they are not the most stable configuration.
  • Generalizability of the proof: The "no-go" theorem is proven for two general classes of QOP solutions, suggesting its broad applicability to systems with competing charge, spin, and superconducting orders.
  • Pseudo-gap behavior: The paper connects TQTC solutions to a "pseudo-gap" phenomenon in the density of states, which is less energetically favorable than the gapped state formed by classical order parameters.

Key Results

The paper analytically proves that for two general classes of quantum order parameters (QOPs) in interacting Fermi systems, the corresponding thermodynamic quantum time crystal (TQTC) states are metastable. This means their free energy is always higher than that of classical order parameter (COP) states, which represent true thermodynamic equilibrium. The proof is demonstrated by comparing the Euclidean actions (free energies) of these states, showing that the COP states always have a lower free energy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Specific classes of solutions: The "no-go" theorem is proven for two specific classes of QOP solutions. While these are presented as general, it's possible that other, more complex QOP configurations might exist that are not covered by this proof.
  • Interacting Fermi systems: The proof is specifically for interacting Fermi systems. The stability of TQTCs in other types of systems (e.g., bosonic systems, or systems with different interaction types) is not addressed.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that their work provides a direct demonstration of the "no-go" theorem and connects TQTC solutions to pseudo-gap thermodynamic behavior. Further exploration of these connections and the implications for different physical systems could be future directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantum field theories of many-body systems predict ``instantonic crystals'' connecting degenerate thermodynamic states with classically broken symmetries. The instantons break continuous translation symmetry of Euclidean space along the axis of imaginary time. The possibility for the emergence of ``thermodynamic quantum time crystals'' that extremize the Euclidean action of the system appeals to the imagination. However, the authors prove here that at least two general classes of ``instantonic crystals'', connecting states of Fermi systems with charge, spin, or superconducting orders can constitute neither thermodynamic equilibrium nor the ground state.
BibTeX
@article{2019classes,
  author = {С. И. Мухин and Timur R. Galimzyanov},
  title = {{Classes of metastable thermodynamic quantum time crystals}},
  journal = {Physical Review. B./Physical Review. B},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.100.081103},
}
Figure