City-Level CH4 Emissions from Anthropogenic Sources and Its Environmental Behaviors in China’s Cold Cities

Weiwei Song, Wanying Yao, Yixuan Zhao, Mengying Wang, Ruihan Chen, Zhiyu Zhu, Zhi Gao, Chunhui Li, Miao Liang, Dajiang YuAtmosphere 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study develops a detailed city-level methane (CH4) emission inventory for China's coldest region, Heilongjiang province, revealing distinct seasonal patterns and urban source profiles. It highlights the significant contribution of agriculture, particularly rice cultivation, and the influence of extreme cold weather on emission behaviors, offering crucial data for targeted climate mitigation strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Methane (CH4) is a potent greenhouse gas, and understanding its emission sources and behaviors is critical for effective climate change mitigation. While global and national CH4 inventories exist, there's a need for finer-scale, city-level data that accounts for unique regional characteristics. This is particularly true for regions with extreme climatic conditions, like China's cold cities, where seasonal variations in human activities and meteorological factors can significantly influence emission patterns. Previous studies have often aggregated emissions or focused on broader regions, potentially masking important city-specific dynamics and the impact of extreme cold on emission sources like agriculture and energy consumption. This paper aims to fill this gap by creating a detailed, city-level CH4 inventory for Heilongjiang province, a region characterized by its extreme cold and significant agricultural and energy sectors.

Methods

The researchers developed a city-level CH4 emission inventory by adapting established methodologies and incorporating region-specific data. They categorized CH4 emissions into several key anthropogenic sectors: rice cultivation, livestock (enteric fermentation and manure management), biomass burning, coal mining, oil and gas exploitation, wastewater disposal, and landfill. For each sector, they utilized specific emission factors, often adapted from IPCC guidelines and previous studies, and combined them with local activity data. Activity data was primarily sourced from the Heilongjiang Province Statistical Year Book. A key aspect of their methodology was the consideration of the unique meteorological conditions of the region, particularly the extreme cold during the heating period, and how this influences seasonal emission patterns. They also analyzed the temporal trends of CH4 emissions from 2003 to 2020 and compared emissions during heating and non-heating periods.

Datasets

The primary dataset used for activity data was the Heilongjiang Province Statistical Year Book. Emission factors were adapted from IPCC 2006 guidelines and previous studies. Atmospheric CH4 mixing ratio data was obtained from the Longfengshan Background Station, which is part of the WMO/GAW network.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seasonal Emission Dominance: The study reveals a stark contrast between heating and non-heating periods. Agriculture, especially rice cultivation, dominates emissions during the non-heating season, while during the heating period, biomass burning, livestock, wastewater, and coal mining become more significant. This highlights the critical role of seasonal activity shifts in shaping a region's greenhouse gas profile.
  • City-Specific Emission Profiles: CH4 emissions are not uniform across cities. For example, Daqing's emissions are heavily influenced by oil and gas exploration, while Jiamusi's are dominated by rice cultivation. This underscores the necessity of city-level inventories for targeted mitigation efforts, as a one-size-fits-all approach would be ineffective.
  • Agriculture's Enduring Importance: Despite the focus on energy sectors in cold regions, agriculture, particularly rice cultivation, remains a dominant and growing source of CH4 emissions in Heilongjiang, contributing significantly to the overall provincial emissions.
  • Impact of Extreme Cold: The extreme temperature variations (over 60°C difference) in Heilongjiang significantly influence emission behaviors, leading to distinct seasonal patterns in sectors like rice cultivation, biomass burning, and livestock, while having less impact on wastewater and fossil fuel production.

Key Results

  • Provincial Trend: CH4 emissions in Heilongjiang province increased from 2003 to 2012, reaching 2993.26 Gg with an annual growth rate of 2.85%, before slightly decreasing to 2740.63 Gg in 2020.
  • Top Emitting Cities: In 2020, Harbin, Daqing, Jiamusi, and Hegang were the highest CH4 emitters, with emissions of 337.23 Gg, 330.01 Gg, 328.55 Gg, and 307.42 Gg, respectively.
  • Sectoral Contributions: Agriculture (rice cultivation, livestock, biomass burning) contributed 51.24–62.12% of total emissions, with a gradual increase. Energy-related sources (coal mining, oil and gas exploration, fossil fuel combustion) decreased from 37.91% to 23.87% between 2003 and 2020.
  • Seasonal Differences: Non-heating period emissions were approximately double those of the heating period. Rice cultivation was the dominant source in the non-heating period (56%), while biomass burning, livestock, wastewater, and coal mining were key during the heating period.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Uncertainty: The authors acknowledge that emission factors and activity data can have inherent uncertainties, especially for specific local conditions. For instance, the recovery of CH4 from manure management was assumed to be 15% due to data limitations.
  • Model Simplifications: Some calculations, like those for landfill emissions, were based on assumptions that might not perfectly reflect real-world complexities (e.g., first-level attenuation).
  • Future Work: The study suggests that scaled inventories are crucial for estimating the reliability and sensitivity of bottom-up emission inventories and for developing integrated control strategies tailored to city-level characteristics. Further research could focus on refining emission factors, improving activity data collection, and exploring the effectiveness of specific mitigation technologies in cold urban environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Distinguished features of cities influence the characteristics of CH4 emissions. A city-level emission inventory represents the characteristics of CH4 on a smaller scale, according to the special factors in each city. A city-level emission inventory was established to reveal the characteristics and source profile of CH4 emissions in the coldest province, which is a typical provincial cold region in northeast China. The dominant sources were identified for targeted cities. Rice cultivation, coal mining, oil and gas exploitation, and livestock are the dominant emission sectors. Emissions from other sectors, including wastewater disposal, biomass burning, landfill, etc. were also estimated. The provincial CH4 emissions increased gradually from 2003 to 2012, up to 2993.26 Gg with an annual increase rate of 2.85%; the emissions were 2740.63 in 2020. The emissions of CH4 in Harbin, Daqing, Jiamusi, and Hegang cities were higher than in the other nine cities, which were 337.23 Gg, 330.01 Gg, 328.55 Gg, and 307.42 Gg in 2020, respectively. Agriculture, including the rice cultivation, livestock, and biomass burning sectors contributed to 51.24–62.12% of total emissions, and the contributions increased gradually. Coal mining, oil and gas exploration, and fossil fuel combustion are energy-related sources, which contributed up to 37.91% of the total emissions, and the proportion kept decreasing to 23.87% in 2020. Furthermore, meteorological factors are especially relevant to the region, by which the differences of ambient temperature are over 60 °C (±30 °C). In the summer, CH4 emissions from the rice cultivation, biomass burning, livestock, and landfill sectors are obviously distinct from the heating period (winter), while few differences in CH4 emissions are found from wastewater disposal and the fossil fuel production sectors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2023city,
  author = {Weiwei Song and Wanying Yao and Yixuan Zhao and Mengying Wang and Ruihan Chen and Zhiyu Zhu and Zhi Gao and Chunhui Li and Miao Liang and Dajiang Yu},
  title = {{City-Level CH4 Emissions from Anthropogenic Sources and Its Environmental Behaviors in China’s Cold Cities}},
  booktitle = {Atmosphere},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/atmos14030535},
}
Figure