Citation Network Analysis of Nurse Staffing Research from the Past Two Decades: 2000–2022

Noriko Morioka, Masanao Ochi, Suguru Okubo, Mutsuko Moriwaki, Kenshi Hayashida, Ichiro Sakata, Masayo KashiwagiHealthcare 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses citation network analysis to map the landscape of nurse staffing research from 2000-2022, revealing a growing field dominated by US and UK researchers. The research primarily clusters around nurse and patient outcomes in acute care, mandate evaluation, nursing homes, and school nurses, with a notable gap in evidence from non-Western countries and community settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ensuring adequate nurse staffing is crucial for patient safety and a positive healthcare environment. However, the sheer volume of research on nurse staffing has made it challenging to grasp the overall trends, identify key contributors, and pinpoint emerging research areas. Traditional literature reviews struggle to provide a comprehensive overview of this rapidly expanding field. This paper aims to address this by providing a "bird's-eye view" of nurse staffing research over the last two decades, identifying its core themes, leading researchers, and geographical distribution, thereby highlighting potential research gaps.

Methods

The researchers employed a citation network analysis to visualize the relationships between research papers. This involved:

  • Data Extraction: Bibliometric information was extracted from PubMed for articles published between January 2000 and September 2022, using a comprehensive search strategy for terms related to "nurse staffing."
  • Network Construction: Direct citation relationships, co-citation relationships, and bibliographic coupling were used to build a network of interconnected papers. Weighting functions were applied to represent the importance of these relationships.
  • Clustering: A modularity maximization algorithm was used to group papers into clusters based on their citation patterns. Papers without citation relationships were excluded.
  • Keyword Analysis: Within each cluster, Term Frequency-Inverse Cluster Frequency (TF-ICF) was calculated to identify representative keywords that characterize the research themes of each cluster. This metric highlights words that are frequent within a specific cluster but less common across all clusters.
  • Trend Analysis: The number of publications per year and the proportion of papers within each cluster over time were analyzed to identify trends.
  • Author and Journal Analysis: The top contributing authors and journals were identified to understand the key players and publication venues in the field.

Datasets

The primary dataset used was PubMed, a comprehensive database of biomedical literature. The search strategy included a range of keywords related to "nurse staffing" and its variations, applied to titles and abstracts. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study analyzed existing published literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Growing Field, Concentrated Expertise: Nurse staffing research has seen a significant increase in publications over the past two decades, but this growth is heavily concentrated among researchers from the US and UK.
  • Dominance of Acute Care: The majority of research (over 80%) falls into the top three clusters: nurse outcomes in acute care, patient outcomes in acute care, and nurse staffing mandate evaluation. This suggests a strong focus on hospital settings.
  • The "Magnet Hospital" Connection: The prominence of researchers from the University of Pennsylvania, known for their work on "magnet hospitals," highlights the link between research on positive work environments and nurse staffing.
  • Policy-Driven Research: The significant cluster on "nurse staffing mandate evaluation" underscores the impact of policy interventions, particularly in places like California, on shaping research agendas.
  • Under-Researched Areas: The study clearly identifies a gap in research originating from African and Asian countries, as well as a relative lack of focus on long-term care and community settings compared to acute care.

Key Results

  • Publication Volume: A total of 2167 papers were analyzed, with the number of publications increasing steadily from 26 in 2000 to over 160 per year after 2020.
  • Major Clusters: Five main clusters were identified:
  • "Nurse outcome research in acute care hospitals" (771 papers)
    1. "Patient outcome research in acute care hospitals" (614 papers)
    2. "Nurse staffing mandate evaluation research" (537 papers)
    3. "Nursing home research" (138 papers)
    4. "School nurse research" (53 papers)
  • Leading Contributors: Dr. Linda Aiken (University of Pennsylvania, USA), Dr. Douglas M. Sloane (University of Pennsylvania, USA), and Dr. Peter Griffiths (University of Southampton, UK) were among the most prolific authors.
  • Top Journals: The Journal of Nursing Administration, Journal of Nursing Management, and International Journal of Nursing Studies published the most articles in this field.
  • Geographic Bias: The US and UK were the leading countries in nurse staffing research, followed by Canada, Australia, and Belgium.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Database Limitations: The study relied on PubMed, which might not capture all relevant literature, and excluded articles not in English, potentially overestimating geographic bias. Future work could incorporate other databases like Web of Science.
  • Citation Bias: Citation network analysis can be biased towards older or highly cited papers. The authors acknowledge that evaluating researchers solely by citation metrics can be invalid.
  • Quality Assessment: The study provides a landscape of research but does not evaluate the quality of individual articles, unlike a systematic review.
  • Geographic and Setting Expansion: The authors strongly advocate for increased research from non-Western countries and a greater focus on long-term care and community settings to ensure the safety of patients and nurses across all practice environments. This is crucial for developing more globally applicable and equitable nurse staffing strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Studies have indicated that higher numbers of nurses regarding staffing ensure patient safety and a better practice environment. Using citation analysis, this study visualizes the landscape of nurse staffing research over the last two decades to show the overall publication trends, major contributors, and main research topics. We extracted bibliometric information from PubMed from January 2000 to September 2022. After clustering the network, we analyzed each cluster's characteristics by keyword. A total of 2167 papers were considered for analysis, and 14 clusters were created. The analysis showed that the number of papers published per year has been increasing. Researchers from the US, the UK, Canada, Australia, and Belgium have led this field. As the main clusters in nurse staffing research during the past two decades, the following five research settings were identified: nurse outcome and patient outcome research in acute care hospitals, nurse staffing mandate evaluation research, nursing home research, and school nurse research. The first three clusters accounted for more than 80% of the total number of published papers, and this ratio has not changed in the past 20 years. To further develop nurse staffing research globally, evidence from other geographic areas, such as African and Asian countries, and from long-term care or community settings is necessary.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{morioka2023citation,
  author = {Noriko Morioka and Masanao Ochi and Suguru Okubo and Mutsuko Moriwaki and Kenshi Hayashida and Ichiro Sakata and Masayo Kashiwagi},
  title = {{Citation Network Analysis of Nurse Staffing Research from the Past Two Decades: 2000–2022}},
  booktitle = {Healthcare},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/healthcare11233050},
}
Figure