Circulating tRNA-Derived Small RNAs as Novel Radiation Biomarkers of Heavy Ion, Proton and X-ray Exposure

Wenjun Wei, Hao Bai, Yaxiong Chen, Tongshan Zhang, Yanan Zhang, Junrui Hua, Jinpeng He, Nan Ding, Heng Zhou, Jufang WangInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper identifies five specific tRNA-derived small RNAs (tsRNAs) in blood serum that reliably decrease in abundance after exposure to heavy ion, proton, or X-ray radiation. These tsRNAs can be used to develop sensitive and specific multi-factor models for assessing radiation exposure levels, offering a promising new avenue for rapid, minimally invasive biodosimetry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate and timely assessment of radiation exposure is crucial for managing health risks following nuclear accidents, space missions, or other radiation events. Traditional physical dosimeters measure external radiation but don't reflect individual biological responses. Existing biological biomarkers, like chromosomal aberrations, are often complex, time-consuming to analyze, and may not be sensitive enough for low-dose exposures. The need for effective, minimally invasive, and rapid biomarkers that can indicate both the type and dose of radiation is therefore significant. While circulating small non-coding RNAs (sncRNAs) have emerged as promising candidates, the specific role of tRNA-derived small RNAs (tsRNAs) as radiation biomarkers, particularly in response to different types of ionizing radiation, remained largely unexplored.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage approach:

  1. RNA Sequencing (RNA-seq): Serum samples from mice exposed to varying doses of carbon ions were subjected to RNA sequencing to identify differentially expressed sncRNAs. This is a standard high-throughput technique for profiling RNA populations.
  2. Bioinformatics Analysis: Reads were mapped to tRNA and miRNA databases to classify sncRNAs. Specific focus was placed on tsRNAs, categorizing them into tRNA-related fragments (tRFs) and tRNA halves (tiRNAs).
  3. Quantitative Real-Time PCR (RT-qPCR): This is a standard technique used to validate the expression levels of candidate biomarkers identified by RNA-seq. It allows for precise quantification of specific RNA molecules.
  4. Dose and Time-Response Studies: Mice were exposed to different doses of carbon ions, X-rays, and protons, and serum samples were collected at various time points to assess how the expression of candidate tsRNAs changed with radiation dose and over time.
  5. Multi-factor Modeling: Logistic regression was used to build models combining the expression levels of multiple tsRNAs to predict exposure degrees. This is a statistical approach to identify relationships between multiple variables and an outcome.
  6. Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) Curve Analysis: This standard statistical method was used to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of the developed models and individual tsRNAs, assessing their sensitivity and specificity in distinguishing between irradiated and non-irradiated individuals.

Datasets

The study utilized serum samples from Kunming mice exposed to carbon ions, X-rays, and protons. Additional validation was performed using serum from C57BL/6 and Balb/c mice, as well as human serum from healthy volunteers. The RNA sequencing data was generated from pooled serum samples from mice in different dose groups.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • tsRNAs as a Promising Class of Biomarkers: The study strongly suggests that tsRNAs, which are more abundant in serum than miRNAs, are excellent candidates for radiation biomarkers due to their stability and ease of detection.
  • Conserved Radiation Response: The identified tsRNAs showed a consistent decrease in expression across different types of ionizing radiation (heavy ion, proton, X-ray) and in different mouse strains, indicating a conserved biological response.
  • Early and Sustained Response: The tsRNAs demonstrated a detectable decrease in expression as early as 6 hours post-exposure and maintained this trend for up to 7 days, with some persisting for 15-30 days, highlighting a broad detection window.
  • Multi-tsRNA Models Outperform Single Biomarkers: Combining multiple tsRNAs into a predictive model significantly improved the sensitivity and specificity for assessing radiation exposure degree compared to using individual tsRNAs.

Key Results

  • Identification of 5 Biomarker tsRNAs: The study identified five specific tsRNAs (one tiRNA and four tRFs) that consistently decreased in serum levels following exposure to carbon ions, X-rays, and protons.
  • Dose-Dependent Decrease: The expression of these five tsRNAs showed a significant dose-dependent decrease, with notable changes observed even at low doses (0.05 Gy).
  • Broad Radiation Type Coverage: The identified tsRNAs responded to carbon ions, X-rays, and protons, making them versatile biomarkers.
  • Human Detectability: The five tsRNA biomarkers were successfully detected in human serum, with stable background levels regardless of sex.
  • High Model Performance: Multi-factor models built using these five tsRNAs achieved high areas under the ROC curve (AUC), ranging from 0.955 to 0.984, indicating excellent accuracy in predicting radiation exposure degrees. For example, the model for proton irradiation achieved an AUC of 0.984.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited to Male Mice: The initial validation of radiation responses in different mouse strains was conducted using male mice. Further research on female mice is needed to confirm these findings across sexes.
  • Mechanism Unclear: While the study identifies responsive tsRNAs, the underlying molecular mechanisms driving their differential expression after radiation exposure remain to be elucidated. The authors suggest investigating tRNA modifications and RNase activity.
  • Integrated Database Scarcity: The lack of comprehensive databases for tsRNA target genes and biological functions hinders a deeper understanding of their roles in radiation response.
  • Clinical Translation: While human serum was tested, further validation in larger human cohorts and clinical settings is necessary before these tsRNAs can be widely adopted as clinical biomarkers.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose developing these tsRNA biomarkers into a rapid, minimally invasive assay for triage and dose assessment, particularly for applications in nuclear accidents and space exploration. They also suggest exploring the biological roles of these tsRNAs in radiation response through cell models.

Summary updated

Abstract

The effective and minimally invasive radiation biomarkers are valuable for exposure scenarios in nuclear accidents or space missions. Recent studies have opened the new sight of circulating small non-coding RNA (sncRNA) as radiation biomarkers. The tRNA-derived small RNA (tsRNA) is a new class of sncRNA. It is more abundant than other kinds of sncRNAs in extracellular vesicles or blood, presenting great potential as promising biomarkers. However, the circulating tsRNAs in response to ionizing radiation have not been reported. In this research, Kunming mice were total-body exposed to 0.05-2 Gy of carbon ions, protons, or X-rays, and the RNA sequencing was performed to profile the expression of sncRNAs in serum. After conditional screening and validation, we firstly identified 5 tsRNAs including 4 tRNA-related fragments (tRFs) and 1 tRNA half (tiRNA) which showed a significant level decrease after exposure to three kinds of radiations. Moreover, the radiation responses of these 5 serum tsRNAs were reproduced in other mouse strains, and the sequences of them could be detected in serum of humans. Furthermore, we developed multi-factor models based on tsRNA biomarkers to indicate the degree of radiation exposure with high sensitivity and specificity. These findings suggest that the circulating tsRNAs can serve as new minimally invasive biomarkers and can make a triage or dose assessment from blood sample collection within 4 h in exposure scenarios.
BibTeX
@article{wei2021circulating,
  author = {Wenjun Wei and Hao Bai and Yaxiong Chen and Tongshan Zhang and Yanan Zhang and Junrui Hua and Jinpeng He and Nan Ding and Heng Zhou and Jufang Wang},
  title = {{Circulating tRNA-Derived Small RNAs as Novel Radiation Biomarkers of Heavy Ion, Proton and X-ray Exposure}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms222413476},
}
Figure