TL;DR
This study directly compares 16S rRNA and shotgun metagenomic sequencing for profiling the circulating microbiome in blood. They found that 16S rRNA sequencing, despite lower sequencing depth, captured a broader range of microbial signals and is a more sensitive and cost-effective approach for low-biomass samples like blood, while also revealing a stable, compartment-independent core microbiome.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Characterizing the microbiome in blood is challenging due to its extremely low microbial biomass and high proportion of host DNA. This makes it difficult to obtain accurate and comprehensive microbial profiles. Currently, two main sequencing methods are used: 16S rRNA gene sequencing, which targets a specific gene and is cost-effective for identifying bacteria at the genus level, and shotgun metagenomic sequencing, which sequences all DNA in a sample and can provide species-level and functional information but requires much higher sequencing depth. However, there's been a lack of direct comparison between these methods specifically for blood samples, leaving researchers unsure which approach is best suited for this low-biomass environment. This paper aims to bridge that gap by systematically comparing the two methods in patients undergoing transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) procedures, which allows for simultaneous sampling from different vascular compartments (portal, hepatic, and peripheral veins) within the same individual, minimizing inter-patient variability.
Methods
The study employed two primary sequencing techniques:
- Shotgun Metagenomic Sequencing: DNA libraries were prepared using the TruSeq Nano DNA High Throughput Library Prep Kit and sequenced on an Illumina NovaSeq platform. Raw reads underwent quality control using
fastp, followed by host DNA removal via alignment to the human reference genome usingBWA. Microbial taxonomic classification was performed using the Kraken2-Bracken pipeline with the PlusPF database. - 16S rRNA Gene Sequencing: The V3-V4 hypervariable regions of the bacterial 16S rRNA gene were amplified using specific primers. Libraries were prepared using the TruSeq Nano DNA LT Library Prep Kit and sequenced on an Illumina NovaSeq system. Quality control and denoising were done using
VSEARCH, followed by chimera removal. Amplicon Sequence Variants (ASVs) were inferred, and taxonomic classification was assigned usingVSEARCHagainst the Ribosomal Database Project (RDP) 16S rRNA database.
For comparative analysis, both methods were restricted to bacterial taxa. Relative Species Abundance (RSA) distributions were analyzed using Preston plots, and species richness was estimated using rarefaction curves with phyloseq and vegan. Statistical comparisons utilized non-parametric tests due to non-normal distributions.
Datasets
The study utilized blood samples collected from 10 patients undergoing TIPS procedures. Samples were collected from three distinct vascular compartments: portal vein (Po), hepatic vein (H), and peripheral vein (Pe) from each patient. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focused on comparing existing sequencing methodologies on this specific patient cohort.
Key Insights and Ideas
- 16S rRNA is More Sensitive for Low-Biomass Samples: The most striking finding is that 16S rRNA sequencing, despite significantly lower sequencing depth, identified a substantially broader range of microbial signals (approximately 10 times more phyla/genera) compared to shotgun metagenomics in blood samples. This highlights the challenge of host DNA contamination in blood and the efficiency of targeted 16S rRNA sequencing for such samples.
- Shotgun Sequencing Suffers from Host DNA Contamination: The lower yield of high-quality microbial reads from shotgun sequencing, even with high initial depth, underscores the significant issue of host DNA contamination in blood. This necessitates extensive host DNA removal steps, which can impact the recovery of microbial DNA.
- Compartment-Independent Core Microbiome: Despite sampling from portal, hepatic, and peripheral veins, the study found no significant differences in alpha or beta diversity across these compartments. This suggests a homogeneous microbial composition throughout the circulatory system, with a stable "core microbiota" consistently detected by both methods.
- Primer Bias is a Factor: In silico analysis of genera detected only by shotgun sequencing revealed that they often lacked perfect matches to the 16S rRNA primers used, providing a mechanistic explanation for their absence in 16S data.
- 16S rRNA is the Preferred Method for Blood: Given its higher sensitivity, broader taxonomic coverage, and cost-effectiveness for low-biomass samples like blood, 16S rRNA sequencing is presented as the more practical approach for circulating microbiome profiling in clinical settings.
Key Results
- Sequencing Depth vs. Yield: Shotgun metagenomics generated a massive amount of raw data (7,024,580,376 reads), but only yielded 722,195 effective reads per sample after quality control and host DNA removal. In contrast, 16S rRNA sequencing produced 6,612,678 raw reads, yielding a significantly higher number of effective reads (102,011 ± 20,918 per sample).
- Taxonomic Recovery: 16S rRNA sequencing identified 240 genera, while shotgun sequencing identified only 76 genera in the study's blood samples.
- Diversity: No significant differences in alpha or beta diversity were observed between the different vascular compartments (portal, hepatic, peripheral) for either sequencing method.
- Correlation: Pearson correlation coefficients between shared genera detected by both methods were low (average 0.12 ± 0.22 in hepatic vein, 0.085 ± 0.20 in peripheral vein, and 0.172 ± 0.23 in portal vein), indicating limited concordance at the genus level.
- RSA Distribution: 16S rRNA sequencing showed a positively skewed RSA distribution with greater skewness than shotgun metagenomics, reflecting its ability to capture rare taxa.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- Low Microbial Biomass: The inherent challenge of low microbial biomass in blood is a persistent limitation for both methods.
- Host DNA Contamination: Shotgun sequencing is particularly affected by host DNA contamination.
- Primer Bias: 16S rRNA sequencing is susceptible to primer bias, which can lead to the underrepresentation or complete absence of certain taxa.
- Chimeric Artifacts: While analyzed, chimeric artifacts are a potential source of error in 16S rRNA sequencing.
- DNA-Based Detection: Both methods detect microbial DNA, not viable microbes, making it impossible to distinguish between live bacteria and fragments from translocation or degradation.
- Small Sample Size: The study included only 10 patients, which limits the generalizability of findings.
- Future Work:
- Next-Generation Approaches: The authors suggest that culturomics, single-cell bacterial sequencing, and molecular-sensing technologies are crucial for accurately assessing microbial viability and metabolic function.
- Overcoming Barriers: Further research is needed to overcome the challenges of low-biomass detection and advance translational applications.
- Increasing Sequencing Depth: While 16S rRNA is preferred, increasing sequencing depth for shotgun metagenomics might improve its performance, though it remains resource-intensive.
Summary updated