Circular Valorization of Pulp and Paper Mill Biosolids for Sustainable Soil Management and Crop Production in Cold-Region Agroecosystems

Emmanuel A. Badewa, Y. X. Song, Xinran Duan, Patrick A. Levasseur, Amanda Diochon, Shawn Sexsmith, Lisa C. Jones, L. J. Johnston, Tamsin Patience, Nathan Basiliko, Nikolai DeMartiniResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Sustainable valorization of pulp and paper mill biosolids (PPMB) can improve soil fertility and reduce reliance on synthetic fertilizers in cold-region agriculture. This two-year field study assessed PPMB as a soil amendment for canola (Brassica napus L.) and wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) in Northern Manitoba, Canada. Six treatments—control, urea, mixed PPMB, and three PPMB–urea combinations—were tested in a randomized complete block design. PPMB application reduced soil bulk density by 15-20% compared to urea and increased soil organic carbon by up to 21% under mixed PPMB. Microbial respiration responses were variable, and yield outcomes for both crops were comparable to or higher than urea. Redundancy analysis showed positive links between improved soil attributes and yield. The findings indicated that PPMB can sustain crop production and improve soil health in cold climates, supporting circular bioeconomy applications in northern agriculture.

Introduction

In subarctic agroecosystems like Northern Manitoba, agriculture faces significant hurdles: short growing seasons, sensitive soils (specifically Rego Gleysols), and a heavy reliance on synthetic nitrogen fertilizers like urea. While urea is the standard, it can be inefficient and environmentally taxing in these climates. Simultaneously, the pulp and paper industry produces vast quantities of organic residuals—biosolids—that are often landfilled or incinerated, incurring high costs and contributing to greenhouse gas emissions.

This study explores the "valorization" of these industrial by-products, transforming them into a resource to close the nutrient loop. By investigating pulp and paper mill biosolids (PPMB) as a soil amendment, researchers aimed to determine if these materials could improve soil structure and fertility without the historical risks of contamination, thereby supporting a circular bioeconomy.

Methodology

The research was conducted over a two-year period (2023–2024) at Round the Bend Farm near The Pas, Manitoba. The experimental design utilized a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with six distinct treatments:

  1. Control: No amendment.
  2. Urea: Standard inorganic nitrogen fertilizer.
  3. SecBioUrea: Secondary PPMB (aerobically treated) blended with 50% urea.
  4. MixedBioUrea: Mixed PPMB blended with 50% urea.
  5. PriBioUrea: Primary PPMB (from effluent clarification) blended with 50% urea.
  6. MixBio: 100% mixed PPMB.

The team employed an Integrated Soil Health Evaluation, using Redundancy Analysis (RDA) to identify variability and multiple linear regression to link soil conditions to crop performance. A standardized Soil Health Score (SHS) was then used to rank the effectiveness of each treatment.

Key Results and Agronomic Performance

The application of PPMB yielded significant improvements in both soil physical properties and crop productivity. Notably, soil organic carbon increased by up to 21% in plots treated with mixed PPMB. Furthermore, a 15–20% reduction in soil bulk density was observed compared to urea-only plots within just two years—a remarkably rapid physical improvement for such a short timeframe.

In terms of productivity, the SecBioUrea treatment emerged as a top performer. In the first year, canola yields under this treatment were 173% higher than the unfertilized control and outperformed standard urea applications. The study confirmed that PPMB can successfully reduce the need for inorganic nitrogen fertilizer by up to 50% without sacrificing yield.

Crop yield performance of canola and wheat under various treatments over two years.

Discussion: The "Secondary" Advantage and Safety

The superior performance of secondary biosolids is attributed to their lower carbon-to-nitrogen (C/N) ratio and higher phosphorus availability. Unlike primary biosolids, which can sometimes temporarily "lock up" nitrogen as microbes decompose high-carbon material, secondary biosolids provide more immediate nutrient availability. Blending these organic residuals with inorganic urea (as seen in the SecBioUrea and MixBioUrea treatments) provides a synergistic effect: immediate nitrogen for plant uptake and long-term organic matter for soil structure.

Safety concerns regarding heavy metals and pathogens were also addressed. Modern paper milling processes using chlorine dioxide have eliminated the risk of organochlorines. This study confirmed that metal and pathogen levels remained well within safe regulatory limits post-application, validating PPMB as a safe agricultural amendment.

Integrated soil health evaluation and final ranking of treatments for canola and wheat.

Conclusion

The Integrated Soil Health Evaluation identified SecBioUrea and MixBioUrea as the most effective management strategies, balancing high agronomic output with long-term soil health benefits. While this two-year study provides a promising snapshot, future work should focus on long-term monitoring of trace metal accumulation and nutrient leaching. Additionally, expanding this research to different soil textures and climatic zones will help generalize these findings for broader application in cold-region agriculture.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Sustainable valorization of pulp and paper mill biosolids (PPMB) can improve soil fertility and reduce reliance on synthetic fertilizers in cold-region agriculture. This two-year field study assessed PPMB as a soil amendment for canola ( <italic>Brassica napus L.)</italic> and wheat ( <italic>Triticum aestivum L.</italic> ) in Northern Manitoba, Canada. Six treatments; control, urea, mixed PPMB, and three PPMB–urea combinations; were tested in a randomized complete block design. PPMB application reduced soil bulk density by 15-20% compared to urea and increased soil organic carbon by up to 21% under mixed PPMB. Microbial respiration responses were variable, and yield outcomes for both crops were comparable to or higher than urea. Redundancy analysis showed positive links between improved soil attributes and yield. The findings indicated that PPMB can sustain crop production and improve soil health in cold climates, supporting circular bioeconomy applications in northern agriculture.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{badewa2025circular,
  author = {Emmanuel A. Badewa and Y. X. Song and Xinran Duan and Patrick A. Levasseur and Amanda Diochon and Shawn Sexsmith and Lisa C. Jones and L. J. Johnston and Tamsin Patience and Nathan Basiliko and Nikolai DeMartini},
  title = {{Circular Valorization of Pulp and Paper Mill Biosolids for Sustainable Soil Management and Crop Production in Cold-Region Agroecosystems}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-8232268/v1},
}
Figure