Circular Economy Innovation in Built Environments: Mapping Policy Thresholds and Resonant Resilience via DEMATEL–TAISM

Zhuo Su, Junlong Peng, Mengyu Wang, Guyue Gui, Qian Meng, Ying Su, Z. J. Xiao, Sisi ZhangBuildings 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of driving circular economy adoption in the construction sector by developing a novel model that quantifies the interplay between policy, market forces, and organizational capabilities. It reveals a critical ~30% policy support threshold and a "resonant resilience" mechanism crucial for sustainable transformation, offering actionable insights for policymakers and industry leaders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The construction industry is a major contributor to resource consumption and emissions, making a shift to a circular economy essential for sustainability goals, especially under China's "dual-carbon" strategy. However, a clear understanding of what specifically drives this transition at the enterprise level is lacking. Existing research often focuses on isolated technological or process improvements, failing to capture the dynamic, multi-dimensional interactions between policy incentives, market demand, and organizational capacity. This gap hinders the development of effective strategies for sustained circularity and resilience in the face of policy volatility and market uncertainty.

Methods

The study employs a sophisticated, integrated methodological framework combining two powerful analytical tools:

  • Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (DEMATEL): This method is used to quantify the direct and indirect causal relationships between identified influencing factors. It helps to understand the "driving power" and "dependence" of each factor, moving beyond simple correlations to reveal causal strengths.
  • Total Adversarial Interpretive Structural Modeling (TAISM): Building upon the causal network established by DEMATEL, TAISM constructs a hierarchical structure. Unlike traditional methods, TAISM incorporates "adversarial logic" and recursive mechanisms, allowing it to capture dynamic adaptation sequences and reveal dominant, transitional, and foundational elements within the system. This approach avoids subjective thresholding and provides a more nuanced, multilayered understanding of complex interactions.

The research also includes a sensitivity analysis to test the robustness of the model by varying expert weights, ensuring its reliability across different perspectives.

Datasets

The study utilized survey data collected from 150 mid- and senior-level managers and technical experts in the construction industry. This data was gathered through an online questionnaire administered via the "Wenjuanxing" platform. The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather uses empirical data to validate its proposed model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Policy is the Primary Catalyst, but Not Enough Alone: Fiscal incentives and regulations are the initial drivers, but they need to be substantial (at least 30% of total network weight) to kickstart the circular economy transition. Market forces alone cannot sustain the necessary investments.
  • The "Resonant Resilience" Mechanism: A crucial finding is the synergistic reinforcement between supply chain resilience and organizational governance. This "resonant resilience" amplifies policy signals and market demand, leading to improved cost performance and sustainability.
  • A Five-Stage Causal Pathway: The study identifies a clear progression: Policy → Market → Supply Chain → Organization → Performance. Understanding this pathway is key to designing effective interventions.
  • Critical Leverage Points: Fiscal incentives (A1), supply chain resilience (B3), and organizational governance (C4) are identified as the most impactful nodes for intervention. Strengthening these simultaneously is more effective than focusing on individual elements.
  • Digitalization Needs Governance: The effectiveness of digital technologies (like BIM) is highly dependent on concurrent organizational governance realignment, challenging the notion of technological determinism.

Key Results

  • The study identified 20 core drivers of enterprise vitality in the construction sector, categorized into five dimensions: policy adaptability, market environment, enterprise competitiveness, external risk, and enterprise adaptive capacity.
  • DEMATEL analysis revealed that policy variables (A1-A4) are the strongest outward drivers, with fiscal incentives (A1) being the most significant.
  • TAISM analysis mapped a five-stage hierarchical structure, showing how policy signals are amplified through market and supply chain nodes to organizational capabilities, ultimately impacting financial outcomes.
  • Sensitivity analysis demonstrated high structural stability, with 87% of variable hierarchies remaining unchanged across different expert weighting scenarios, and causality fluctuations within ±0.6% for key factors.
  • The model suggests that policy support needs to constitute at least 30% of the total network weight for market capital to be insufficient on its own.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Expert Bias: While sensitivity analysis was performed, the reliance on expert opinion inherently introduces some level of subjectivity.
  • Regional Data Constraints: The study's data is primarily from China, limiting its direct generalizability to other regions without further validation.
  • Cross-Sectional Data: The analysis is based on a snapshot in time, which may not fully capture long-term dynamic processes.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Validating the framework using multi-regional panel data.
  • Incorporating real-time IoT-based monitoring for dynamic data collection.
  • Employing Bayesian causal inference methods for more robust analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Under China’s dual-carbon strategy, the construction sector still lacks a systematic quantitative view of what drives its shift to a circular economy. This study couples the Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (DEMATEL) with Total Adversarial Interpretive Structural Modeling (TAISM) to build a weighted, multi-layer model of the policy–market–organization–technology chain. DEMATEL measures causal strengths, and TAISM arranges the variables into five levels without subjective thresholds, revealing a five-stage activation pathway. Fiscal incentives and regulations start the cascade; market demand amplifies their effect into a “resonant resilience” mechanism that improves cost performance. Robustness tests show 87% hierarchy stability and causal variation within ±0.6%. Sensitivity checks indicate that policy support must supply at least 30% of total network weight, because market capital alone cannot meet circular-construction costs. A three-tier intervention—policy incentives, financial amplification, and digital decomposition via green finance, BIM, and material passports—is therefore recommended.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{su2025circular,
  author = {Zhuo Su and Junlong Peng and Mengyu Wang and Guyue Gui and Qian Meng and Ying Su and Z. J. Xiao and Sisi Zhang},
  title = {{Circular Economy Innovation in Built Environments: Mapping Policy Thresholds and Resonant Resilience via DEMATEL–TAISM}},
  booktitle = {Buildings},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/buildings15122110},
}
Figure