Circadian rhythm and cell population growth

Jean Clairambault, Stéphane Gaubert, Thomas LepoutreMath. Comput. Model 2011 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper explores the mathematical underpinnings of how circadian rhythms influence cell proliferation, particularly in the context of cancer growth. The authors develop a theoretical framework using partial differential equations to model cell division and demonstrate a key convexity result that supports the efficacy of chronotherapeutics (timed drug delivery) and suggests that disrupted circadian rhythms might accelerate tumor growth by weakening healthy tissues, rather than directly affecting tumor cells.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the intriguing observation that disrupting the natural 24-hour biological rhythms (circadian rhythms) in laboratory animals can lead to accelerated tumor growth. This phenomenon, also observed clinically where patients with well-maintained circadian rhythms tend to have better prognoses, suggests a deep connection between our internal biological clocks and cell proliferation, especially in the context of cancer. The authors aim to provide a mathematical explanation for this link, specifically by modeling how periodic biological controls, like circadian rhythms, affect cell division in both healthy and cancerous tissues. They seek to understand the precise mechanisms by which these rhythms influence growth and to explore their implications for cancer treatment, particularly chronotherapeutics.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in developing and analyzing mathematical models of cell population dynamics. They employ age-structured partial differential equations (PDEs) to describe the cell division cycle, where "age" refers to the progression through different phases of the cycle (G1, S, G2, M). These models incorporate time-dependent coefficients to represent the influence of periodic biological signals, such as circadian rhythms, on parameters like cell death rates and transition rates between cell cycle phases.

A significant part of the work involves analyzing the dominant eigenvalue of these PDE systems. This eigenvalue, often referred to as the Floquet eigenvalue ($\lambda_F$), governs the overall growth rate of the cell population. The authors compare this eigenvalue under periodic control (representing a healthy circadian rhythm) with scenarios of constant control (representing a disrupted rhythm or constant drug delivery). A key contribution is the derivation of a general convexity inequality for this dominant eigenvalue. This inequality provides a theoretical basis for understanding why periodic control can be more effective than constant control, particularly in the context of drug delivery for cancer treatment.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical modeling and mathematical analysis, drawing on existing biological experimental results for motivation and validation rather than using specific datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Circadian Rhythms as a Growth Regulator: The paper solidifies the understanding that circadian clocks are not just passive biological phenomena but actively regulate fundamental processes like cell metabolism and proliferation.
  • Convexity as a Foundation for Chronotherapeutics: The derived convexity inequality for the dominant eigenvalue provides a robust mathematical justification for the success of chronotherapeutics. It suggests that timed drug delivery, by leveraging periodic biological rhythms, can lead to better outcomes than constant administration.
  • Indirect Impact on Tumor Growth: A surprising and important insight is the hypothesis that the acceleration of tumor growth due to circadian disruption might be an indirect effect. Instead of directly promoting tumor cells, the disruption might weaken the healthy tissues that are responsible for fighting the tumor, thereby indirectly benefiting the cancer.
  • Periodic vs. Constant Control: The mathematical analysis reveals that periodic control, even with the same average parameters as constant control, can lead to different (and often more favorable) growth dynamics, particularly for healthy tissues.

Key Results

  • Convexity Inequality: The paper establishes a general convexity result for the dominant eigenvalue of age-structured cell population models with periodic coefficients. Specifically, the dominant eigenvalue is shown to be convex with respect to death rates and geometrically convex with respect to birth rates. This inequality, $\lambda_F \le \theta \lambda_1 + (1-\theta)\lambda_2$, is a central mathematical finding.
  • Theoretical Support for Chronotherapy: The convexity result implies that periodic drug delivery can be designed to be less toxic to healthy tissues compared to constant delivery, while potentially maintaining or even enhancing therapeutic efficacy.
  • Explanation for Filipski's Experiments: The authors propose that the observed acceleration of tumor growth in disrupted circadian rhythms (Filipski et al.) is likely due to the weakening of the host's immune system or other healthy tissues that combat the tumor, rather than a direct pro-growth effect on tumor cells.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplifications in Models: The authors acknowledge that their models are simplifications of complex biological systems. For instance, they often assume constant progression speeds through cell cycle phases and focus on specific parameters for control.
  • Explaining Filipski's Results: While the paper offers a compelling hypothesis for the Filipski experiments, it notes that averaging coefficients might not be the optimal way to represent circadian rhythm perturbations. They suggest exploring alternative tracks for a more direct explanation.
  • Biological Basis of Convexity: The paper points out that while the mathematical framework for geometric averaging of birth rates is established, a definitive biological justification for this specific type of averaging in cell cycle models is still lacking.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that further biological experiments are needed to confirm their hypothesis about the indirect effects of circadian disruption. They also call for more elaborate, physiologically based mathematical models to further investigate these phenomena. The paper also hints at the potential for genetically determined therapeutic windows, suggesting future research into personalized chronotherapeutics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Molecular circadian clocks, that are found in all nucleated cells of mammals, are known to dictate rhythms of approximately 24 h (circa diem) to many physiological processes. This includes metabolism (e.g., temperature, hormonal blood levels) and cell proliferation. It has been observed in tumor-bearing laboratory rodents that a severe disruption of these physiological rhythms results in accelerated tumor growth.The question of accurately representing the control exerted by circadian clocks on healthy and tumor tissue proliferation to explain this phenomenon has given rise to mathematical developments, which we review. The main goal of these previous works was to examine the influence of a periodic control on the cell division cycle in physiologically structured cell populations, comparing the effects of periodic control with no control, and of different periodic controls between them. We state here a general convexity result that may give a theoretical justification to the concept of cancer chronotherapeutics. Our result also leads us to hypothesize that the above mentioned effect of disruption of circadian rhythms on tumor growth enhancement is indirect, that is, this enhancement is likely to result from the weakening of healthy tissue that is at work fighting tumor growth.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{clairambault2011circadian,
  author = {Jean Clairambault and Stéphane Gaubert and Thomas Lepoutre},
  title = {{Circadian rhythm and cell population growth}},
  booktitle = {Math. Comput. Model},
  year = {2011},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=oNqO0w6jAU},
}
Figure