CHY loop integrands from holomorphic forms

Humberto Gomez, Sebastian Mizera, Guojun ZhangJournal of High Energy Physics 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel method for constructing scattering amplitudes in quantum field theory beyond the simplest tree-level calculations. By leveraging geometric concepts from holomorphic forms on Riemann surfaces, the authors develop a systematic way to build "CHY integrands" for $\Phi^3$ theory up to two loops, offering a powerful tool for analytical calculations and paving the way for higher-loop orders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Calculating scattering amplitudes in quantum field theory, especially for processes with many particles or multiple "loops" (representing quantum fluctuations), becomes incredibly complex very quickly. While the Cachazo-He-Yuan (CHY) formalism provides an elegant way to compute tree-level amplitudes using scattering equations on Riemann spheres, extending this to loop level has been a significant challenge. Direct evaluation of loop integrals is notoriously difficult, and existing methods for loop-level CHY amplitudes are often cumbersome or limited in scope. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a more systematic and geometrically-inspired approach to constructing CHY integrands for loop amplitudes, specifically for $\Phi^3$ theory, up to two loops.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in a novel construction of CHY integrands for loop amplitudes. Instead of directly tackling the loop integrals, the authors propose building blocks derived from holomorphic forms on Riemann surfaces.

  • Holomorphic Forms and Building Blocks: They start with the mathematical objects known as holomorphic forms on tori (one loop) and double tori (two loops). By "pinching" these surfaces (a mathematical operation that simplifies their topology), they obtain meromorphic forms. These meromorphic forms are then used to construct "building blocks" for the CHY integrands. For two loops, they define three specific quadratic differentials based on these forms.
  • Gluing Rules: To assemble these building blocks into complete CHY integrands that correspond to Feynman diagrams, they introduce "gluing rules." These rules are analogous to how Feynman diagrams are constructed by connecting vertices and propagators, but are adapted for the CHY graph representation.
  • Λ-Algorithm Extension: As a complementary tool, the authors extend the "Λ-algorithm," a graphical method for analytically evaluating CHY integrals, to two loops. This algorithm provides a systematic way to perform the integration once the CHY integrand is constructed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geometric Foundation for Loop Amplitudes: The paper demonstrates that the complex world of loop amplitudes can be elegantly approached using geometric concepts from complex analysis (holomorphic forms on Riemann surfaces). This provides a powerful new perspective on a notoriously difficult problem.
  • Systematic Construction of CHY Integrands: By defining building blocks and gluing rules, the authors offer a systematic procedure to translate Feynman diagrams into their CHY integrand counterparts, even at two-loop level. This moves beyond ad-hoc methods and provides a generalizable framework.
  • Unification of Tree and Loop Level: The approach aims to maintain a similar structure between tree-level and loop-level CHY calculations, making the transition more natural and potentially simplifying future extensions.
  • The Λ-Algorithm as a Powerful Computational Tool: The extension of the Λ-algorithm to two loops is crucial. It provides an efficient way to actually compute the integrals of the constructed CHY integrands, validating the construction and enabling explicit calculations.

Key Results

  • The paper successfully constructs CHY integrands for $\Phi^3$ theory up to two loops, based on holomorphic forms.
  • Simple rules are provided for translating Feynman diagrams into these CHY integrands.
  • The Λ-algorithm is extended to two loops, enabling analytical computation of these integrands.
  • The proposed prescription for CHY integrands is analytically verified for up to seven external particles at two loops.
  • The work provides a natural pathway for generalizing the approach to higher-loop orders.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalization to Higher Loops: While the paper lays the groundwork for higher-loop orders, the explicit construction and analysis for three loops and beyond are left as future research directions.
  • Other Theories: The current work focuses on $\Phi^3$ theory. Generalizing this approach to other theories, such as bi-adjoint scalar, Yang-Mills, and Einstein gravity, is a significant avenue for future work.
  • Compact Expressions: The authors suggest exploring ways to derive compact expressions for CHY integrands, similar to existing work at one loop, which could further simplify calculations.
  • Understanding Constraints: The paper raises questions about the constraints imposed by factorization properties on the choice of building blocks and quadratic differentials, which warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently, the Cachazo-He-Yuan (CHY) approach for calculating scattering amplitudes has been extended beyond tree level. In this paper, we introduce a way of constructing CHY integrands for Φ3 theory up to two loops from holomorphic forms on Riemann surfaces. We give simple rules for translating Feynman diagrams into the corresponding CHY integrands. As a complementary result, we extend the Λ-algorithm, originally introduced in arXiv:1604.05373 , to two loops. Using this approach, we are able to analytically verify our prescription for the CHY integrands up to seven external particles at two loops. In addition, it gives a natural way of extending to higher-loop orders.
BibTeX
@article{gomez2017chy,
  author = {Humberto Gomez and Sebastian Mizera and Guojun Zhang},
  title = {{CHY loop integrands from holomorphic forms}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep03(2017)092},
}
Figure