ChronosPerseus: Randomized Point-based Value Iteration with Importance Sampling for POSMDPs

Richard Kohar, François Rivest, Alain GosselinarXiv 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces ChronosPerseus, a novel algorithm for solving Partially Observable Semi-Markov Decision Processes (POSMDPs). By extending existing point-based value iteration methods with importance sampling, ChronosPerseus efficiently handles problems with uncertain observations and continuous-time transitions, offering a more realistic approach to sequential decision-making in complex environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional reinforcement learning often models environments as Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) or Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs). While POMDPs can handle noisy observations, they struggle with scenarios where the time it takes to transition between states is uncertain and continuous. Discretizing time to fit these models leads to the "Curse of Dimensionality," making problems computationally intractable. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a framework, POSMDPs, that explicitly models continuous sojourn times, and then presents ChronosPerseus, an efficient algorithm to solve these POSMDPs. This is crucial for real-world applications where timing is critical, such as scheduling, maintenance, or autonomous systems operating under uncertain durations.

Methods

The core contribution is the ChronosPerseus algorithm, which builds upon the Perseus algorithm (a randomized point-based value iteration method for POMDPs). ChronosPerseus extends Perseus to handle POSMDPs by:

  • Incorporating Continuous Sojourn Times: It directly models the probability distributions of time spent in a state before transitioning, rather than discretizing time.
  • Using Importance Sampling: This technique is employed to efficiently sample sojourn times and update the belief state. Importance sampling helps to reduce the variance of estimates and thus the computational complexity of the solver.
  • Single Backup Operation: A key insight is that sampled sojourn times can be used within a single backup operation, further streamlining the process and reducing computational load.

The algorithm involves collecting beliefs and sojourn time samples from the environment and then iteratively approximating the value function using a backup operator until convergence.

Datasets

The paper evaluates ChronosPerseus on two example problems:

  1. The Bus Problem: An episodic toy problem where an agent navigates bus stops with unknown traffic intensity, deciding whether to stay on the bus or switch to a bike. This problem features mixed observability and a mixture of discrete and continuous random sojourn times.
  2. A Machine Maintenance Problem: A real-world application involving maintaining water filters, presented with a continuous observation space and continuous sojourn times. This problem is non-episodic.

No new datasets were introduced; rather, these problems serve as benchmarks to demonstrate the algorithm's capabilities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Time as a First-Class Citizen: POSMDPs, and by extension ChronosPerseus, treat the duration of state transitions as a critical, probabilistic factor, moving beyond simple discrete time steps.
  • Bridging POMDPs and SMDPs: The framework elegantly combines the challenges of partial observability (from POMDPs) with continuous time transitions (from Semi-Markov Decision Processes), creating a more expressive model for real-world scenarios.
  • Efficiency through Importance Sampling: The use of importance sampling is crucial for making POSMDPs computationally tractable, avoiding the state-space explosion that would occur if time were explicitly discretized.
  • Compression of Temporal Information: By moving temporal information into sojourn time distributions, complex POMDPs requiring temporal state information can be represented more compactly.

Key Results

  • ChronosPerseus successfully solves both episodic and non-episodic POSMDP problems.
  • The algorithm demonstrates effectiveness with mixed observability, discrete/continuous observation spaces, and various temporal distributions (fixed, stochastic continuous).
  • The paper shows that solving POSMDPs with ChronosPerseus is not significantly more complex than solving equivalent POMDPs, especially when compared to time-extended POMDPs.
  • In the machine maintenance problem, ChronosPerseus achieved significant speedups (less than 40 seconds) compared to previous methods (around 16 hours) for similar problem scales, highlighting the efficiency gains from the approach and GPU implementation.
  • The bus problem example illustrates how the agent's decisions adapt based on its evolving belief about traffic intensity, aligning with human intuition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While ChronosPerseus offers significant improvements, the complexity of the UPDATE iteration is still dependent on the number of beliefs, sojourn times, and observations, which can be substantial for very large problems.
  • Convergence: The algorithm relies on convergence criteria for value iteration, and the rate of convergence can be influenced by problem parameters.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this approach can be applied to a wider range of real-world problems where temporal aspects are critical. They also highlight the potential for learning policies in POMDPs where time is the primary source of uncertainty for resolving partially observable states.

Summary updated

Abstract

In reinforcement learning, agents have successfully used environments modeled with Markov decision processes (MDPs). However, in many problem domains, an agent may suffer from noisy observations or random times until its subsequent decision. While partially observable Markov decision processes (POMDPs) have dealt with noisy observations, they have yet to deal with the unknown time aspect. Of course, one could discretize the time, but this leads to Bellman's Curse of Dimensionality. To incorporate continuous sojourn-time distributions in the agent's decision making, we propose that partially observable semi-Markov decision processes (POSMDPs) can be helpful in this regard. We extend \citet{Spaan2005a} randomized point-based value iteration (PBVI) \textsc{Perseus} algorithm used for POMDP to POSMDP by incorporating continuous sojourn time distributions and using importance sampling to reduce the solver complexity. We call this new PBVI algorithm with importance sampling for POSMDPs -- \textsc{ChronosPerseus}. This further allows for compressed complex POMDPs requiring temporal state information by moving this information into state sojourn time of a POMSDP. The second insight is that keeping a set of sampled times and weighting it by its likelihood can be used in a single backup; this helps further reduce the algorithm complexity. The solver also works on episodic and non-episodic problems. We conclude our paper with two examples, an episodic bus problem and a non-episodic maintenance problem.
BibTeX
@misc{kohar2022chronosperseus,
  author = {Richard Kohar and François Rivest and Alain Gosselin},
  title = {{ChronosPerseus: Randomized Point-based Value Iteration with Importance Sampling for POSMDPs}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2207.07825},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.07825},
}

Loading related content...

Figure