Chromosome-length genome assemblies of six legume species provide insights into genome organization, evolution, and agronomic traits for crop improvement

Vanika Garg, Olga Dudchenko, Jinpeng Wang, Aamir W. Khan, Saurabh Gupta, Parwinder Kaur, Kai Han, Rachit K. Saxena, Sandip M. Kale, Melanie Pham, Jigao Yu, Annapurna Chitikineni, Zhikang Zhang, Guangyi Fan, Christopher Lui, Vinodkumar Valluri, Fanbo Meng, Aditi Bhandari, Xiaochuan Liu, Tao Yang, Hua Chen, Babu Valliyodan, Manish Roorkiwal, Chengcheng Shi, Hong Yang, Neva C. Durand, Manish K. Pandey, Guowei Li, Rutwik Barmukh, Xingjun Wang, Xiao‐Ping Chen, Hon‐Ming Lam, Huifang Jiang, Xuxiao Zong, Xuanqiang Liang, Xin Liu, Boshou Liao, Baozhu Guo, Scott A. Jackson, Henry T. Nguyen, Weijian Zhuang, Wan Shu-bo, Xiyin Wang, Erez Lieberman Aiden, Jeffrey L. Bennetzen, Rajeev K. VarshneyJournal of Advanced Research 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents chromosome-length genome assemblies for six important legume species, significantly improving upon previous fragmented drafts. These high-quality assemblies enable a deeper understanding of legume genome evolution and provide a powerful resource for accelerating crop improvement through more precise genetic analyses and breeding applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Legume crops are vital for global food security, providing essential protein and oil while enriching soil nitrogen. However, their genetic improvement has been hampered by the lack of high-quality genome assemblies. Previous "draft" assemblies, often based on short-read sequencing, were fragmented and contained errors, limiting their utility for detailed genomic studies and precise trait association. This paper addresses this gap by generating chromosome-length genome assemblies for six key legume species, aiming to unlock their full potential for crop improvement.

Methods

The core innovation in this study is the use of in situ Hi-C technology to significantly improve existing draft genome assemblies. Hi-C data captures the 3D organization of chromatin within the nucleus, providing long-range physical links between DNA fragments. These links were used with the 3D de novo assembly (3D-DNA) pipeline to anchor, order, and orient contigs into chromosome-length scaffolds. The resulting "C assemblies" were then polished using Juicebox Assembly Tools. Beyond assembly, the researchers employed a suite of computational methods for:

  • Repeat identification: Using RepeatModeler and RepeatMasker.
  • Gene prediction and annotation: Integrating homology-based, ab initio, and transcriptome-based evidence with tools like BRAKER and EvidenceModeler.
  • Comparative genomics: Analyzing gene family expansion/contraction (CAFE), inferring gene colinearity (ColinearScan), and performing phylogenetic analyses (OrthoFinder).
  • Evolutionary dating: Estimating divergence times using synonymous nucleotide substitution rates (Ks) and a normal fitting distribution.
  • Trait association: High-resolution mapping of QTLs and performing Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS).

Datasets

The study utilized existing draft genome assemblies ("D assemblies") for six legume species as a starting point. The primary new dataset generated was in situ Hi-C sequencing data for these six species:

  • Chickpea (Cicer arietinum)
  • Pigeonpea (Cajanus cajan)
  • Soybean (Glycine max)
  • Subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum)
  • Arachis duranensis (wild groundnut progenitor)
  • Arachis ipaensis (wild groundnut progenitor)

Additionally, publicly available RNA-Seq datasets and protein sequences from related species were used for gene prediction and annotation. For comparative analyses, genomes of Medicago truncatula, Lotus japonicus, and Vitis vinifera (grape) were used as references.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hi-C is a game-changer for legume genomics: The study unequivocally demonstrates that Hi-C technology is crucial for resolving fragmented legume genomes into chromosome-length scaffolds, overcoming limitations of previous short-read assemblies.
  • Legume genomes are dynamic and complex: The comparative analyses revealed significant gene family expansions and contractions, highlighting the evolutionary forces that shaped unique legume traits like nodulation and oil biosynthesis.
  • Ancient polyploidization events shaped legume diversity: The research provides refined estimates for key polyploidization events (ECH, LCT, SST), offering a clearer timeline for legume diversification.
  • Improved assemblies directly translate to better genetic insights: The study showcases how higher-quality assemblies lead to more precise QTL mapping and more robust GWAS results, accelerating the identification of genes underlying important agronomic traits.
  • "Legumepedia" as a valuable community resource: The creation of an online repository for all generated data and annotations is a significant contribution, fostering further research in the legume community.

Key Results

  • Chromosome-length assemblies: Successfully generated chromosome-length genome assemblies for six legume species, with scaffold N50 values ranging from 51.53 Mb to 136.73 Mb.
  • Improved contiguity and accuracy: The "C assemblies" showed a significant increase in the percentage of sequences anchored to pseudomolecules (e.g., from 65.24% to 92.59% in pigeonpea) and corrected numerous assembly errors, including inversions.
  • Enhanced gene annotation: Predicted gene models were more accurate, with a notable reduction in gene model numbers in pigeonpea compared to the draft assembly, suggesting the draft had inflated gene counts.
  • Refined evolutionary timelines: The study provided updated divergence times for key legume lineages and polyploidization events.
  • Precise trait mapping: In chickpea, the "QTL-hotspot" region for drought tolerance was refined from hundreds of kilobases to tens of kilobases, identifying fewer, more targeted candidate genes. In pigeonpea, GWAS using the improved assembly identified significantly more marker-trait associations (MTAs) and novel variants.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that despite improvements, the "C assemblies" may still contain some errors. They note that Hi-C data, while excellent for long-range scaffolding, might require additional data for resolving very small adjacent contigs. Future work will undoubtedly leverage these high-quality reference genomes for more in-depth functional genomics studies, targeted gene editing for crop improvement, and further exploration of the evolutionary history and diversity within the legume family. The "Legumepedia" repository is poised to be a central hub for these future endeavors.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study reports chromosome-length genome assemblies of six legume species and demonstrates the utility of these assemblies in crop improvement. The genomic resources developed here will have significant role in accelerating genetic improvement applications of legume crops.
BibTeX
@article{garg2021chromosome,
  author = {Vanika Garg and Olga Dudchenko and Jinpeng Wang and Aamir W. Khan and Saurabh Gupta and Parwinder Kaur and Kai Han and Rachit K. Saxena and Sandip M. Kale and Melanie Pham and Jigao Yu and Annapurna Chitikineni and Zhikang Zhang and Guangyi Fan and Christopher Lui and Vinodkumar Valluri and Fanbo Meng and Aditi Bhandari and Xiaochuan Liu and Tao Yang and Hua Chen and Babu Valliyodan and Manish Roorkiwal and Chengcheng Shi and Hong Yang and Neva C. Durand and Manish K. Pandey and Guowei Li and Rutwik Barmukh and Xingjun Wang and Xiao‐Ping Chen and Hon‐Ming Lam and Huifang Jiang and Xuxiao Zong and Xuanqiang Liang and Xin Liu and Boshou Liao and Baozhu Guo and Scott A. Jackson and Henry T. Nguyen and Weijian Zhuang and Wan Shu-bo and Xiyin Wang and Erez Lieberman Aiden and Jeffrey L. Bennetzen and Rajeev K. Varshney},
  title = {{Chromosome-length genome assemblies of six legume species provide insights into genome organization, evolution, and agronomic traits for crop improvement}},
  journal = {Journal of Advanced Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jare.2021.10.009},
}
Figure