Chromatin state barriers enforce an irreversible mammalian cell fate decision

M. Andrés Blanco, David B. Sykes, Lei Gu, Mengjun Wu, Ricardo Petroni, Rahul Karnik, Mathias J. Wawer, Joshua Rico, Haitao Li, William D. Jacobus, Ashwini Jambhekar, Sihem Cheloufi, Alexander Meissner, Konrad Hochedlinger, David T. Scadden, Yang ShibioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Scientists have discovered that the "point of no return" for cell differentiation isn't due to permanent epigenetic marks like DNA methylation or H3K27me3. Instead, it's the loss of access to crucial regulatory DNA regions, driven by changes in chromatin accessibility, that locks cells into a specific fate. This finding opens new avenues for understanding and potentially manipulating cell identity, with implications for regenerative medicine and cancer therapies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cell differentiation, the process by which a less specialized cell becomes a more specialized cell type, is fundamental to development and tissue maintenance. While we know differentiation is generally a one-way street – cells don't typically revert to a less specialized state – the precise molecular mechanisms that enforce this irreversibility have remained elusive. Specifically, researchers wanted to understand what molecular "locks" prevent a differentiated cell from becoming a progenitor cell again. This is crucial for understanding how cell identity is maintained and has significant implications for tissue regeneration and cancer therapies that aim to induce differentiation.

Methods

The researchers utilized a sophisticated experimental system involving conditional myeloid progenitor cells. By using an inducible transcription factor (ER-HOXA9), they could precisely control the cells' ability to self-renew or differentiate. They employed a range of cutting-edge techniques to investigate the molecular changes occurring during this process:

  • RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq): To profile gene expression changes over time.
  • ATAC-sequencing (ATAC-seq): To map regions of open chromatin, indicating accessible regulatory DNA.
  • ChIP-sequencing (ChIP-seq): To identify the binding sites of specific transcription factors (like ER-HOXA9) and to map histone modifications (H3K27ac, H3K4me3, H3K27me3).
  • Reduced Representation Bisulfite Sequencing (RRBS): To analyze DNA methylation patterns.
  • Flow Cytometry: To assess cell surface markers indicative of differentiation (e.g., CD11b) and to quantify cell populations.

A key aspect of their approach was the ability to temporarily "pause" differentiation and then attempt to "rescue" the cells by reintroducing the inducer, allowing them to pinpoint the exact moment when this rescue became impossible.

Datasets

The study primarily used data generated from their experimental system involving ER-HOXA9 and ER-HOXB8 cell lines. They also incorporated publicly available datasets for in vivo validation:

  • RNA-seq and ATAC-seq data from sorted human GMPs and monocytes (GSE74912).
  • ATAC-seq data from sorted mouse GMPs and monocytes (GSE143270).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chromatin accessibility, not just repressive marks, is key: The study's most striking finding is that the "point of no return" in differentiation isn't dictated by stable, repressive epigenetic marks like DNA methylation or H3K27me3. Instead, it's the loss of access to regulatory DNA regions that locks cells into their fate.
  • Enhancers as barriers to de-differentiation: The research highlights a novel role for enhancers – regulatory DNA elements that control gene expression – acting as "barriers" to prevent cells from reverting to a progenitor state. When these enhancers become inaccessible, the cell's identity is solidified.
  • Disruption of positive feedback loops: The irreversible commitment is linked to the breakdown of positive feedback loops involving transcription factors. When these loops are broken, even re-expressing a key transcription factor can't restore the progenitor state.
  • "Soft" epigenetic memory: The findings suggest that "softer" epigenetic changes, like dynamic chromatin accessibility, are sufficient to enforce irreversible cell fate decisions in adult progenitor cells, contrasting with models focused on permanent marks in embryonic stem cells.

Key Results

  • Identification of a "point of no return": The researchers precisely mapped a window of commitment in myeloid differentiation, typically occurring around 72 hours of ER-HOXA9 inactivation, after which cells could not be reverted to their progenitor state.
  • No role for DNA methylation or H3K27me3 in commitment: Contrary to some hypotheses, these repressive marks did not show significant changes or correlation with the commitment point.
  • Dramatic loss of chromatin accessibility: ATAC-seq data revealed a significant decrease in open chromatin regions after the commitment point, particularly at regulatory sites.
  • Reactivated ER-HOXA9 fails to re-bind key targets: After commitment, reactivated ER-HOXA9 could only bind a small fraction of its original target sites, and crucially, these did not include the master regulators of the progenitor state.
  • Meis1's role in plasticity: Enforcing the expression of the co-factor Meis1 could extend the window of cellular plasticity, delaying the irreversible commitment point.
  • In vivo conservation: The key epigenomic features observed in the model system, particularly the reduction in chromatin accessibility, were also found in human and mouse hematopoietic cells during differentiation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model system specificity: While the ER-HOXA9 model is powerful, the authors acknowledge that the specific mechanisms might differ in other cell types or developmental contexts, especially early embryonic development.
  • Heterogeneity: The study observed subtle cellular heterogeneity in reaching the commitment point, suggesting that cell cycle status or starting population heterogeneity might influence this window. Future work could involve cell cycle synchronization or single-cell approaches to address this.
  • Generalizability: Further research is needed to determine the generalizability of these findings across different cell lineages and to understand how genetic backgrounds might influence the effectiveness of targeting these mechanisms.
  • Therapeutic applications: The authors suggest that targeting factors regulating chromatin remodeling and accessibility could be a promising strategy for developing new AML differentiation therapies, but this requires further investigation into specific vulnerabilities and genetic contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary Stem and progenitor cells have the capacity to balance self-renewal and differentiation. Hematopoietic myeloid progenitors replenish more than 25 billion terminally differentiated neutrophils every day under homeostatic conditions and can increase this output in response to stress or infection. At what point along the spectrum of maturation do progenitors lose capacity for self-renewal and become irreversibly committed to differentiation? Using a system of conditional myeloid development that can be toggled between self-renewal and differentiation, we interrogated determinants of this ‘point of no return’ in differentiation commitment. Irreversible commitment is due primarily to loss of open regulatory site access and disruption of a positive feedback transcription factor activation loop. Restoration of the transcription factor feedback loop extends the window of cell plasticity and alters the point of no return. These findings demonstrate how the chromatin state enforces and perpetuates cell fate and identifies potential avenues for manipulating cell identity. Highlights There exists a point of irreversible commitment in granulocytic differentiation Chromatin state dynamics establish the transition from self-renewal to differentiation commitment Reduced chromatin accessibility underlies an irreversible loss of regulatory site access Restoration of a transcription factor feedback loop alters the differentiation commitment point
BibTeX
@misc{blanco2021chromatin,
  author = {M. Andrés Blanco and David B. Sykes and Lei Gu and Mengjun Wu and Ricardo Petroni and Rahul Karnik and Mathias J. Wawer and Joshua Rico and Haitao Li and William D. Jacobus and Ashwini Jambhekar and Sihem Cheloufi and Alexander Meissner and Konrad Hochedlinger and David T. Scadden and Yang Shi},
  title = {{Chromatin state barriers enforce an irreversible mammalian cell fate decision}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.05.12.443709},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure