Chow quotients of Grassmannians by diagonal subtori

Noah Giansiracusa, Xian WuarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The literature on maximal torus orbits in the Grassmannian is vast; in this paper we initiate a program to extend this to diagonal subtori. Our main focus is generalizing portions of Kapranov's seminal work on Chow quotient compactifications of these orbit spaces. This leads naturally to discrete polymatroids, generalizing the matroidal framework underlying Kapranov's results. By generalizing the Gelfand-MacPherson isomorphism, these Chow quotients are seen to compactify spaces of arrangements of parameterized linear subspaces, and a generalized Gale duality holds here. A special case is birational to the Chen-Gibney-Krashen moduli space of pointed trees of projective spaces, and we show that the question of whether this birational map is an isomorphism is a specific instance of a much more general question that hasn't previously appeared in the literature, namely, whether the geometric Borel transfer principle in non-reductive GIT extends to an isomorphism of Chow quotients.

Introduction

The Grassmannian $Gr(d, n)$, the space of all $d$-dimensional subspaces of an $n$-dimensional vector space, is a fundamental object in algebraic geometry. A central area of study involves the action of the "maximal torus"—a group of scaling operations—on this space. In 1993, Mikhail Kapranov demonstrated how to compactify the space of these torus orbits using Chow quotients, creating a well-behaved space that includes limit orbits.

However, Kapranov’s work assumed the torus acts with maximal symmetry, where each coordinate is scaled independently. This paper addresses the gap where some coordinates are scaled by the same factor—an action by a diagonal subtorus. This shift significantly complicates the geometry and combinatorics, necessitating a move from standard matroids to more complex structures.

Combinatorial Foundations: From Matroids to Discrete Polymatroids

The transition from a maximal torus to a diagonal subtorus is mirrored by the transition from sets to multisets in matroid theory. The authors replace the matroids used by Kapranov with discrete polymatroids. These structures allow for tracking the "multiplicity" of coordinates scaled by the same torus factor.

A geometric representation of a discrete polymatroid as a subpolytope within a projected hypersimplex.

Theorem 1.1 establishes a formal bijection between rank $d$ discrete polymatroids and specific subpolytopes of projected hypersimplices. As illustrated in Figure 1, these polytopes provide a geometric realization of the combinatorial data. The authors utilize the theory of secondary polytopes and polytopal subdivisions to describe the boundary of the resulting Chow quotients.

The Generalized Gelfand-MacPherson Isomorphism

A key methodological contribution is the adaptation of a proof technique by Thaddeus to establish a Generalized Gelfand-MacPherson Isomorphism (Theorem 1.3). This result proves an isomorphism between the Grassmannian Chow quotient and a specific quotient of products of projective spaces by the general linear group ($GL_d$).

This provides a concrete geometric interpretation: while Kapranov’s quotients compactify arrangements of points or hyperplanes, these new quotients compactify arrangements of parameterized linear subspaces. This means the space captures not only the position of a subspace but also its internal scaling properties.

Duality and Moduli Space Connections

The authors derive a new version of Gale duality, a classic symmetry in geometry, that applies to these parameterized arrangements. Furthermore, they demonstrate that a specific case of their construction is birational to the Chen-Gibney-Krashen moduli space of pointed trees of projective spaces.

Non-Reductive GIT and the Borel Transfer Principle

The paper connects these geometric constructions to a deep question in Geometric Invariant Theory (GIT): the Borel transfer principle. This principle typically relates invariants of a complex group (like $GL_d$) to a simpler subgroup. The authors suggest that this principle might extend from the world of GIT quotients to the world of Chow quotients.

Whether the birational map to the Chen-Gibney-Krashen space is an actual isomorphism is shown to be a specific instance of this broader question. This inquiry touches on non-reductive groups, which are traditionally more difficult to handle in GIT, marking a significant path for future research.

Conclusion

By extending Kapranov's framework to diagonal subtori, this work provides a new lens through which to view the compactification of Grassmannian orbits. The integration of discrete polymatroids and the exploration of the Borel transfer principle for Chow quotients offer a robust foundation for further study in non-reductive GIT and the moduli of subspace arrangements.

Summary updated

Abstract

The literature on maximal torus orbits in the Grassmannian is vast; in this paper we initiate a program to extend this to diagonal subtori. Our main focus is generalizing portions of Kapranov's seminal work on Chow quotient compactifications of these orbit spaces. This leads naturally to discrete polymatroids, generalizing the matroidal framework underlying Kapranov's results. By generalizing the Gelfand-MacPherson isomorphism, these Chow quotients are seen to compactify spaces of arrangements of parameterized linear subspaces, and a generalized Gale duality holds here. A special case is birational to the Chen-Gibney-Krashen moduli space of pointed trees of projective spaces, and we show that the question of whether this birational map is an isomorphism is a specific instance of a much more general question that hasn't previously appeared in the literature, namely, whether the geometric Borel transfer principle in non-reductive GIT extends to an isomorphism of Chow quotients.
BibTeX
@misc{giansiracusa2019chow,
  author = {Noah Giansiracusa and Xian Wu},
  title = {{Chow quotients of Grassmannians by diagonal subtori}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1909.13333},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1909.13333},
}
Figure