Chord bearing capacity in long-span tubular trusses

Brian M. Kozy, R. Boyle, Christopher EarlsSteel 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the bearing capacity of circular hollow structural section (HSS) chords in long-span tubular trusses, a critical but under-specified area in current design codes. By combining full-scale experimental testing with advanced finite element analysis, the authors develop new capacity equations for axial load, moment, and combined loading, offering a more robust design approach for these structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing safe and efficient long-span tubular trusses, particularly for overhead highway signs, presents a challenge at the bearing connection region. Existing design specifications often lack direct guidance for the capacity of tubular truss chords under concentrated reaction forces near the open end. This omission is problematic because these connections are frequently the controlling element in the design of structures with slender members. The paper addresses this gap by focusing on the specific failure mode of local collapse in the HSS chord wall at the bearing support, a phenomenon highlighted by a past structural failure.

Methods

The research employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Full-Scale Experimental Testing: Two identical specimens of a typical overhead sign truss bearing configuration were tested to failure. This provided crucial real-world data on load-deflection behavior and failure mechanisms.
  • Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis (FEA): Sophisticated FEA models were developed using ABAQUS. These models incorporated geometric and material nonlinearities to accurately capture the complex behavior of the HSS chords, including yielding and plastic collapse. The FEA techniques were validated against the experimental results.
  • Parametric Studies: Once validated, the FEA models were used to conduct extensive parametric studies. This involved systematically varying key geometric and material parameters (e.g., HSS diameter, wall thickness, ST flange width, end distance, yield strength) to understand their influence on bearing capacity.
  • Development of Capacity Equations: Based on the insights gained from experimental testing and parametric studies, new semi-empirical capacity equations were developed for axial load, moment, and combined axial load and moment. These equations are intended to provide a more accurate and reliable basis for design.

Datasets

  • Experimental Data: Load-deflection data and strain gauge measurements from two full-scale experimental tests on HSS chord specimens.
  • Finite Element Analysis Results: Extensive load-deflection and stress contour data generated from numerous FEA simulations covering a wide range of parametric variations.
  • Existing Specifications: Data and equations from relevant design codes and manuals (AISC, AASHTO, AWS, CIDECT) were used as a basis for modifying and developing new capacity equations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bearing Region Vulnerability: The bearing connection region, where reaction forces are applied near the open end of HSS chords, is indeed susceptible to local collapse, as evidenced by experimental failures and the need for specific design considerations.
  • FEA as a Powerful Tool: Nonlinear FEA proved to be a robust method for simulating the complex failure mechanisms, validating experimental findings, and conducting parametric studies that would be impractical through testing alone.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The study revealed that while some parameters (like ST depth) have a significant impact on capacity, others (like saddle width and end distance beyond a certain threshold) have a less pronounced effect.
  • Yield Line Mechanism Dominance: The failure mechanism is consistently characterized by a yield line collapse, where plastic hinges form in the HSS chord wall, leading to instability.
  • Need for New Equations: Existing specifications, while providing some related provisions, do not adequately address the specific bearing capacity of these configurations, necessitating the development of new, tailored equations.

Key Results

  • Experimental Capacity: The ultimate bearing capacity for the tested configuration was found to be 96 kips, with first yield occurring around 40 kips.
  • Approximate Methods: Four modified approximate methods based on existing specifications were evaluated, all providing a safe estimate of bearing capacity but with potentially low safety margins.
  • Parametric Study Findings:
    • Axial load capacity increases with ST flange width, chord wall thickness, and chord yield strength.
  • The influence of HSS chord diameter and ST depth on axial capacity is less significant, provided certain ratios are maintained.
  • Moment capacity is primarily controlled by the ST stem depth.
  • The open end of the HSS chord ceases to influence the failure mechanism when the ST is located at a distance of approximately 33 inches (1.27D) or more from the end.
  • Developed Capacity Equations: New capacity equations were formulated for axial load (both complex and simplified versions), moment, and combined axial load and moment, showing good correlation with FEA results.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Applicability: The research focused on a specific bearing configuration involving a curved saddle bearing and an ST intermediate branch member. The authors acknowledge that other configurations (e.g., flat bearing surfaces, HSS branch members, gusset plate connections) may require different approaches.
  • Experimental Data Limitations: While two tests were conducted, further experimental testing is recommended to further validate the proposed capacity equations.
  • Statistical Analysis: Additional statistical analysis is suggested to quantify the structural safety provided by the new equations, considering the variability of real-world structures.
  • Hot Spot Stresses and Fatigue: The study identified "hot spot" stresses at the tips of the ST flange, suggesting a potential for low-cycle and high-cycle fatigue issues that warrant further investigation.
  • Slender Chord Connections: For slender chord bearing connections, particularly flat-plate details, the design and analysis of stiffening measures are recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

The capacity of tubular truss chords subjected to concentrated reaction forces in the vicinity of the open end (i.e., the bearing region) is not directly treated by existing design specifications; although capacity equations are promulgated for related tubular joint configurations. The lack of direct treatment of bearing capacity in existing design specifications seems to represent an unsatisfactory situation given the fact that connections very often control the design of long-span tubular structures comprised of members with slender cross-sections. The case of the simple-span overhead highway sign truss is studied, in which the bearing reaction is applied near the chord end. The present research is aimed at assessing the validity of adapting existing specifications' capacity equations from related cases so as to be applicable in determining design capacity in tubular truss bearing regions. These modified capacity equations are subsequently used in comparisons with full-scale experimental results obtained from testing carried out at the University of Pittsburgh.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kozy2006chord,
  author = {Brian M. Kozy and R. Boyle and Christopher Earls},
  title = {{Chord bearing capacity in long-span tubular trusses}},
  booktitle = {Steel},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.12989/scs.2006.6.2.103},
}
Figure